Win $100 for your Thanksgiving Dinner Disaster story
By Register Online Staff
Contest entries close SaturdayDid the gravy turn out all lumpy, or maybe it spilled all over Uncle Louie? Did the dog grab the turkey leg and hide under the dinner table with it, growling at anyone who walked by?
Come on, tell us what your worst Thanksgiving meal disaster was, and you might be the person to walk away with $100 from
Vallerga’s Markets in Napa.
Keep your entry to 500 words or less and submit it by placing it in the story comments section below. You have until midnight Saturday, Nov. 22 to write your story and submit it to us.
We will select the finalists and post them here, plus run them in the print edition’s Food section on Tuesday, Nov. 25.
How do we come up with a winner? We don’t, you do.
That’s right, we are letting our readers vote via an online poll that starts when we post the finalists, with the poll running through Thanksgiving weekend, ending at midnight Sunday, Nov. 30.
The winner will be announced online and in print Tuesday, Dec. 2.
Don’t worry if you are not from the Napa area. The
Vallerga's Markets prize is a local supermarket gift certificate, but you non-locals can still play. If you win, please consider donating the prize to the local food bank or Meals on Wheels.
(Note: Don’t write your entry in the story comments section. Write it on your computer, then paste it in to the story comments to make sure you don’t lose your work.)
The goal of the story comments section at NapaValleyRegister.com is to have an open, thought-provoking, civil community forum for all issues.
What gets your comment posted?
• Staying on topic
• Keeping your comment to 300 words or less
• Avoiding name-calling
• Addressing your comments to the message rather than the messenger
What gets your comment deleted?
• Personal attacks
• Derogatory remarks
• Name-calling of any sort
• Going off-topic
• Hate speech
• Racially-insensitive comments
• Implying guilt of a subject in a crime story before there is a court verdict
• Posting e-mail addresses
• Posting comments of a commercial nature
• POSTING WITH ALL CAPITAL LETTERS
• Linking multiple comments together with "to be continued..." to get around the 300 word limit.
The fine print
- Comments are either approved or denied. We do not edit comments.
- You are welcome to modify and resubmit a denied comment.
- Comments may take several hours to be posted.
- Comments posted are those of the writer, and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of NapaValleyRegister.com, its employees or its parent company.
- Do you have information on a story? Please go to our
virtual newsroom to send us a news tip.
- If you feel a posted comment has violated our guidelines, please contact
online@napanews.com or add a comment indicating you have an issue and our moderators will review the comment in question.
jluros wrote on Nov 14, 2008 8:33 AM:
A few years ago, my sister’s new mother-in-law decided it was time that she, and not our mother, have everyone over for Thanksgiving. Our mother is an excellent cook, having taught cooking at the college level, and her Turkey-day dishes have always garnered her fame both inside and outside the family.
The mother-in-law was nonplussed. How could she, without years of training and hours in the kitchen garner the same goodwill with us? She’ll make Thanksgiving dinner! To ensure that she got full credit, our mother was not allowed to interfere in the kitchen.
We arrived around 2, spending the first few hours chatting and watching football. Hindsight being 20/20, we should have noticed the lack of wafting. There were no discernible traces of cinnamon, sweet potato, juicy turkey, or mashed potatoes. We heard noises in the kitchen, but no olfactory cues. Maybe their kitchen is different? Maybe it keeps all it’s treasures hidden? Unfortunately not.
At around 4, curious about the mother-in-law not asking for help, our mother ventured into the kitchen. As if it were Area 51, the mother-in-law said that everything was fine, and that there was nothing to see. Looking over to the oven, our mother noticed that the timer was running, but that the dials were straight up and down. The dial read ominously “OFF”. Thanksgiving was ruined. There would be no cinnamon, no sweet potato, no juicy turkey, nor any mashed potatoes.
We drove down the block to Boston Market and got some meager replacements. I don’t know if it will go down as our worst Thanksgiving when our family history is written, but it will be close. Needless to say, my sister was not married when the next Thanksgiving rolled around. "
supportourown wrote on Nov 14, 2008 9:29 AM:
My story began when I married my husband who comes from a family of 8 children. I love to cook so I wanted to have EVERYONE at our home for our first Thanksgiving as a married couple.
Everyone arrived early, things were going fine, all dishes were coming together at the same time.
Just as we were putting the final touches on the mashed potatos and gravy I hear this noise coming from the laundry room (off the kitchen). When I finally break free to see what was going on I find water backing up the washing machine pipe flooding the floor of the laundry room.
After further investigation we find that our kitchen sink is also backed up so no dishes were going to be cleaned at the end of this magnificent feast.
Long story short - never, EVER, put potato peels in your garbage disposal. Plumbers are very expensive on Thanksgiving Day! "
cathyodom wrote on Nov 14, 2008 11:44 AM:
15 years ago, we moved to Napa, got married and bought a condo. We were excited to have Thanksgiving in our first home, and invited over my husband’s parents.
Our house needed work; Mr. Fix-It had lived there, and did some crazy stuff, like 70’s gold mirrors in the bathroom, speaker wire and newspaper for an outlet. The kitchen had wood floor, pink carpet, a bedroom ceiling fan, and an electric cook-top. There was an odd-little oven where a microwave would go.
I come from a big Italian family (my maiden name is Gumina)and cooking was in my blood. My dad was the chef, and I was his assistant while my mom came home from work, put her feet up, and had a glass of wine.
However, I hadn’t cooked a turkey before, but how hard can it be? Well, you need to follow directions, like cooking it 15 minutes for every pound of meat. I didn’t that first Thanksgiving. I cooked it until it looked brown on the outside. It was NOT done on the inside, it was pink! My in-laws were already sitting at the table. I was so embarrassed! I tried to slice off some pieces that weren’t too bad (they were still a bit pink) and put them in the microwave to zap them.
Well, turns out my in-laws were ok but I ended up the next day at Kaiser with food poisoning and an IV in my arm! I found out my husband’s family has a stomach of steel and I’ve got a tender one! Now, I know how to cook a turkey, and haven’t re-poisoned myself (yet!)! "
christmas78 wrote on Nov 14, 2008 11:51 AM:
So, we all sat around all day, enjoying football, snacking, drinking, enjoying each others company.
At about 4:30 PM, my mom takes out the turkey.. low and behold, it looks like a Griswald turkey.. no meat, all bone, when she put the knife in it, it was all air.
Well, after my family being disappointed and my dad calling the store complaining that they gave him a meatless turkey, grandpa came in and flipped the bird over. Turns out mom had cooked the turkey upside down!!
We still talk about that Thanksgiving and laugh about it. Funny thing is, it was the best turkey we ever had so now we always cook the turkey upside down, as thats where the juices flow to!
Have a great thanksgiving! "
localmomma wrote on Nov 14, 2008 12:21 PM:
It was my first time cooking the big meal, so I was excited to have my small family over to enjoy it. Well I got up at 6am to grease the paper bag to cook the turkey in. I Grease the bag, get the turkey in and come to find out that the damn turkey didnt fit in my tiny oven!! At this point, I am freaking out cause I had about 10 people coming over in a mere 6-7 hours and I cant cook the damn turkey and it is 6am. So I cant just go knock on a neighbor's door to ask them to cook it for me till I can find an alternate oven to finish it. I brain-stormed this brilliant (at the time) idea that I would drop the rack in the oven to the bottom level and pop the already ready to go turkey in. I do so, it fits and I am estatic. So, about 2 hours into cooking just when my boyfriend and I are waking up all the way...we start to smell burning paper. I flip, he flips and we run into the kitchen. It was filled with smoke, pouring out of the oven!! We fling open the windows, doors and my boyfriend goes for the oven with a burst of hot smoke. I guess I didnt grease the bag enough and the paper bag caught fire!! So, in turn burning the outside of the turkey black and not even touching the stuffing of inside of the turkey. Needless to say, Turkey Day was ruined before it even really started! All before 9am on Thanksgiving Day!
My sister made a 'back up turkey' and Saved the Day!! "
flacoman wrote on Nov 14, 2008 1:15 PM:
While sitting with the family watching the game on TV, I heard a shriek from the kitchen. I ran to see what was up, and there, hands to the side of her head and crying, was my wife. At her feet was the Thanksgiving turkey.
When she finally calmed down she excplained that as she was pulling the turkey out for a final basteing, she burned her hand and let go of the pan. The pan with nothing to hold it slid across the rack, out of the oven, bounced off the oven door, did a single flip and deposited the turkey on the floor.
I'm sure I've laughed harder in my life, but I really can't remember when. At that point my mother walked into the kitchen and, catching the mood, doubled over with laughter. Realizing that it wasn't the end of the world, my wife began laughing as well and we three shared a moment I'll never forget.
Mom said we could just put it back in the pan with no harm done. As we started to do that, my wife started crying again saying "his legs are gone." Mr. turkey had flipped over with legs underneath.
We kept the story from the rest of the family and we all ate with gusto.
While almost a tragedy, it turned into a Thanksgiving to remember. "
NapaFurriesMom wrote on Nov 14, 2008 2:26 PM:
Coming from a large Irish family, there are always one or two who are little overfond of the drink. This Thanksgiving was no than any other holiday when the spirits flowed freely.
Finally it was time to carve and serve the turkey, oh joy! As my grandmother went to the kitchen to get the glorious turkey, she noticed that my Aunt and Uncle were no where to be found, they were not seated like the rest of us around the large dining room table. As she walked into the kitchen we all heard a shriek of surprize. When we all rushed to grandmother's side, we at first did not notice anything the matter. It was seconds later we noticed that the turkey platter had only a drumstick and wing, and the backdoor leading out of the kitchen stood wide open...
Auntie and Uncle infused with the spirits had decided to take the turkey to their own party, and snatched it on the run.
We still laugh about it to this day even though they are all long gone.
Happy Thanksgiving Everyone! "
mcrauntie wrote on Nov 14, 2008 9:12 PM:
was'nt working, the turkey is raw so we stuck it in the microwave oven and it cooked it in some places and not in others, so we cut up and cook it some
more till it was done some of it was hard has a brick. oh well, something
always goes wrong every thanksgiving
from the burnt rolls or the yams catching on fire. but at least we are
together. I wonder what will happen this year? who knows!
HAPPY THANKSGIVING EVERYONE "
vocal-de-local wrote on Nov 14, 2008 10:08 PM:
My husband extinguished the flames with baking soda but the smell of burnt plastic lingered. Surprisingly, the turkey and potatoes were fully cooked. The vegetables were slightly undercooked in a healthy way.
Family members were not interacting with each other as usual, though. Flow of conversation was interrupted by constant surveillance of the surrounding area. My relatives wanted pie served right away and they politely came up with excuses to leave as soon as possible. That was the shortest family gathering ever.
Building up the courage to host Thanksgiving dinner took another twelve years. Somehow little footprints of spilled pumpkin pie slowly disappearing at the entrance of a child’s bedroom seemed insignificant by comparison! The opportunity for perspective is the giving I continue to be thankful for. "
SpecEd Teacher wrote on Nov 15, 2008 1:10 PM:
SpecEd Teacher wrote on Nov 15, 2008 1:11 PM:
is my quartz watch blown up in a million pieces!!!!!! As we enjoyed our wine and stuffed our bird, it seems as if my watch fell off my wrist and I unknowingly stuffed it back into the turkey and cooked it for 6 hours!! We laughed so hard we fell to the floor....friends pounding on the door wanting to come in...we just laughed our hearts out as we picked pieces of glass, leather, and metal "hands" out of the stuffing.
This Thanksgiving will be our 20th holiday together.....the last 13 have been in Napa with our 2 daughters. "
Dwayne wrote on Nov 15, 2008 2:23 PM:
It came out perfect, buffet style... A few acted brave and tried a bite or two, others didn't know what mashed potatoes were... They all declared that they didn't "like it", because they weren't "used to it"....
Sooo... I dug some steaks out of the freezer, nuked some potatoes, and grilled steaks for them on the deck...IN THE RAIN... They were happy then.....
We had leftovers for a week... Grrrrrr..... "
surfdogge69 wrote on Nov 15, 2008 4:45 PM:
gogogeo wrote on Nov 15, 2008 5:43 PM:
I tried to recreate the recipe from memory on a Thanksgiving day in 1982. Finding cardoons was not easy but one store did carry it and still does for that matter, Vallergra's.
I began cleaning off the cardoon stalks like grandma did and putting the tougher stringier pieces down the garbage disposal. That was a big mistake!
My sink was clogged big time and my household plunger, drano, screwdrivers, plyers and anything else I tried was to no avail. A big sea of green gunk was floating in my sink and not going anywhere.
Have you ever tried to get a plumber to come out on Thanksgiving? After 15 or so answering machines I was answered by Mr. Plumber himself. He and his son agree to come out and "snake the sink". An hour later the sink was back in operation and my wallet was $250 lighter.
Dear Mr. Vallergra: please put a warning sign on your "cardoons".
George Rothwell
224 9202 "
JMB wrote on Nov 16, 2008 1:28 AM:
That November was unusually warm, like this one. So I didn’t need to use the oven for a few days. After 2-3 days there was a strange smell in the kitchen. I couldn’t figure it out, the garbage was empty. I went to put bread in the oven on the fourth day and there it was, the hens were still in the oven! Crawling with maggots! I screamed, called him at work in a panic, and he said to turn the oven on and roast them. I did, while spraying Febreze around the kitchen. I finally turned the oven off and let it cool, then while holding a dishcloth over my face, dumped it all in our trash bin, sheet pan and all. There was no way I was going to reuse that pan!
So while we had a great Thanksgiving on the actual day, who says you can’t still have a Thanksgiving dinner disaster four days later! We still laugh about it this time of year. "
napanative53 wrote on Nov 17, 2008 1:33 AM:
UncleStuy wrote on Nov 17, 2008 7:09 AM:
napanana wrote on Nov 17, 2008 12:27 PM:
Every one knew that we raised our own meat...and were sort of O.K. with it. Everyone but Rachel......She was about 13 at the time and trying to be really brave about eating someone that had been running around our yard. All seemed well..for the moment. We were all sitting around the table with this fabulous feast in front of us....and Rachel trying to pick around her plate.....she did manage a bite of "Harold".......when my Cute little boy (10) says, "So hey Rachel...how does Harold taste?"
That did it! Poor Rachel turned pale....her little cheeks bulged out.....she grabbed the table cloth to cover her mouth and ran for the back door! Yes...the table cloth! Food and broken dishes everywhere......My son rolling on the floor laughing...Rachel barfing off the back porch.....What else could we do? So we laughed too and cleaned up hte mess. To this day Rachel will not have Thanksgiving at our house. "
zuufa wrote on Nov 17, 2008 1:11 PM:
Betty wrote on Nov 17, 2008 2:25 PM:
To begin, two things you must know. I am a vegetarian and I am not a very religious person, in practice.
Thanksgiving, 2003, was to be different. My son, David, informed me that two of his friends from the UK, Mike and Vicky, would be joining us for Thanksgiving dinner; their first Thanksgiving experience. I decided, in honor of their first Thanksgiving, to forgo my foodie ways and cook a turkey with all of the trimmings.
David, in the mean time, informed his friends that I was a vegetarian, so would not be serving a turkey, but in all other ways they would experience a festive Thanksgiving holiday and dinner.
The day arrived along with my son and our guests. As we seated ourselves for dinner, one of our guests handed me a card. Thanking her, I opened it to find a beautifully decorated, religious, Thanksgiving card. I thought to myself, “My guests are religious so we must say grace.” I handed the card to my husband and as he read it, I asked, “Would you say grace, please?” Bless his heart; on the spot, he managed quite a beautiful grace.
Following the dinner, my son pulled me aside and said, “Mom that was so hilarious that I had trouble controlling my laughter during grace, it was a perfect "Seinfeld." He continued, "Mike and Vicky are not religious at all. They, knowing that you are a vegetarian, did not want to offend you with a card that had a turkey on it, and a religious card was the only other Thanksgiving card they could find. You, in turn, not wanting to offend them, said grace." "
korikill wrote on Nov 17, 2008 2:28 PM:
I had just pulled it out of the oven and walked into the living room when I noticed a terrible, burning-plastic-like odor.
I asked my room mate about it and she informed me that she couldn't find the TV remote and thought she tossed it into the fireplace by accident.
Well, I found the remote under a blanket, but still, there was this noxious smell.
We walked down the hall, and the bedrooms were filled with smoke that made us gag and cough.
I called the business line of the fire department and said (really) 'my house is filled with smoke, but I don't see flames. What should I do?' (I know, not the sharpest tool in the shed...).
The nice lady practically screamed, "GET OUT OF THERE!!"
We bundled up and waited on the front porch.
NINE firefighting vehicles responded, sirens ablazin'.
The Chief ran into our house, turned around and stated, 'Hmm. Smells like fresh baked bread."
I pointed out the back hallway, and he laughed and went to check it out.
Turns out the insulation in the wall had caught fire from a short in the wall heater. Had I not stayed up late to bake bread, we would likely have died from the poisonous smoke.
OK, so the dinner was a disaster, but we lived! And we still laugh about it! "
adventurer wrote on Nov 18, 2008 2:04 PM:
I was getting a little nervous. My family and I were enjoying the crisp November morning, getting up late, meeting friends for breakfast, meandering through the Thanksgiving Day. Mid-day, after someone asked if we had begun to roast our turkey, I grabbed our group and headed for the market to buy one! By late afternoon, purchases made, the preparations started in earnest. Painstakingly injecting the huge bird with oil, trussing his legs, and jamming in the stuffing, we turned on the oven. We returned to family fun, not noticing that time had passed, and no delicious smells were wafting through the kitchen. I opened the pristine oven, and was shocked to find Mr. Tom in his original state. Not a hint of warmth inside the door.
By this time we were ravenous. Darkness descended upon Napa, and our oven was defunct. The good humor of the group turned to snappy, annoyed repartee. Tempers were ignited. We dragged out the camp stove, cooked some string beans and cans of soup, which overflowed all over the stove and floor. Mr. Tom did not get cooked on Thanksgiving Day, 1977.
Napa Register headlines on Friday: thousands of starlings, nesting on power lines, flew off at the same time, snapping the wires. Hundreds of homes were without power on Thanksgiving…
Moral of story: Cook your turkey early…and have a backup plan. "
diehard4ever wrote on Nov 18, 2008 8:52 PM:
I personally like SpecEd Teacher's and JMB's.... "
xtrapeggy wrote on Nov 19, 2008 8:10 AM:
apartmentguy wrote on Nov 19, 2008 10:25 AM:
The Vanishing Pie
Twas the Night before Thanksgiving,
When all was so fair.
The whole house smelled,
of a fresh pie scent in the air.
Just out of the oven,
sat this special dessert.
Cooling in the kitchen,
while in back we did some work.
Then all of a sudden,
Dashing into the room.
Came one of our dogs,
on his face the look of doom!
Up we stood,
hurrying along,
Towards the kitchen,
to see what was wrong
Before our eyes,
was a sight to see!
Paws on the counter,
What could this be!
The other dog had eaten,
every last bite.
The wonderful pie,
had vanished into the night! "
peppermintpatty wrote on Nov 20, 2008 5:10 PM:
Pop-up timers embedded in the turkey hadn’t been invented yet and my mother never used meat thermometers. She plucked pin feathers the night before. The next day set the temperature and counted out the hours until the bird was cooked to perfection. Surely I could do the same. I’d watched from the kitchen door since I could remember.
Thanksgiving day when our guests arrived, the aroma of a perfect turkey roasting filled the house. At the planned time I pulled the bird from the oven to wait while I assembled the rest of our dinner.
My husband flourished the carving knife and began to slice. Instead of admiring ohhs and ahhs there was total silence. The turkey wasn't done. With apologies I shoved the failure back in the oven. An hour later we sat down to a deflated feast. The Thanksgiving candles had burned down to nubs and the dressing was dry. But the turkey was cooked. I wanted to cry. After a slice of pumpkin pie we said goodnight.
As our guests left, the man leaned over and kissed my cheek. “Thanks for a great Thanksgiving. It was just like home. My mom can’t cook turkey either.”
Now, fifty years and two times that number of roast turkey dinners later, even armed with pop-up timer and meat thermometer, I still keep my fingers crossed when my husband’s knife pierces the turkey breast. "
bettye wrote on Nov 20, 2008 10:48 PM:
acarminito wrote on Nov 21, 2008 1:04 PM:
The turkey was thawed, cleaned and prepped. The turkey was doused with herbs and placed into the oven. It was all going exactly as planned. Now all we had to do was be patient while it cooked. We closed the kitchen pocket door and joined our friends in the living room to watch the game.
Well, I guess that my stunted sense for cooking allowed me to linger on the couch much longer than I should have……. By the time anyone smelled the smoke it was much too late. I slammed open the kitchen door to see that the room was filled with thick smoke. Smoke was pouring out of every crevice in the oven. I opened the oven door (not smart – I know – but my desire for a beautiful, happy First Thanskgiving Meal made me lose my senses) I pulled the rack out to find that my precious home-building, friend-bonding, love-gift turkey was in flames. Really.! It was on fire. There were actual flames coming off of the top of the bird.
There are photos somewhere of that half charred, half raw love-bomb in a smoke filled, but sun lit kitchen. We went out for dinner. "
loveone wrote on Nov 21, 2008 2:05 PM:
St.Hell.comNative wrote on Nov 21, 2008 2:33 PM:
spumoni wrote on Nov 21, 2008 3:56 PM:
Ten Rules for a Happy Thanksgiving:
1. Never put potato peels in the garbage disposal.
2. Do not fry a turkey next to a wooden fence.
3. Invest in a meat thermometer and learn how to use it
4. Don't forget to turn on the oven.
5. Do not overserve your aunt and uncle.
6. Remove all watches, jewelry and other loose items before stuffing turkey.
7. Keep dogs away from pies.
8. Do not shower before dinner.
9. Do not serve anything to your guests which previously has had a name.
10. Relax and have a good time. Maybe next year somebody will cook for you. "
koliebug27 wrote on Nov 22, 2008 10:59 AM:
MonezMod wrote on Nov 22, 2008 2:50 PM:
pharper wrote on Nov 22, 2008 4:56 PM:
Needless to say, we don’t bother with fake meat at Thanksgiving dinner anymore. "
adriansmama wrote on Nov 22, 2008 6:14 PM:
On Wednesday the last carload finally arrived from out of state. That first night was like your typical family gathering. The little kids were chasing each other around the house while the teenagers were locked in a bedroom. The adults gathered around the kitchen table and a bottle of wine bring each other up to date on their lives.
Late that night the house is filled with the horrible cries of a child and the calming efforts of a tired father. It seems that my youngest cousin did not in fact suffer from car sickness, she had brought with her the flu. Into the early morning hours as grandma was prepping the turkey she was met with a few looks of disgust passing through the kitchen. Apparently it was highly contagious.
Throughout the day and well into the night 12 out of 15 poor family members tried to share two bathrooms. Most of us tried to sit through some mash potatoes or at least some conversation at the table with some ginger ale but without a doubt this had to be the worst Thanksgiving EVER. The next day two more were stricken with the bug and we all glared at the father that had brought it with him. Not only for bringing it but somehow he had also managed to avoid it. At least until they were halfway home and had to get a room because he was too sick to drive. "
katies wrote on Nov 22, 2008 10:20 PM:
Now it was time to enlist more capable hands to pitch in. We bailed, hauled, flushed, dumped, mopped, wiped, and scrubbed. I don't remember the eating "
Napagrrl wrote on Nov 23, 2008 5:52 PM:
As for the others revealing sometimes embarassing stories, thank you. It is fun to see that everyone has kitchen debacles but that life goes on. For that, I give thanks. "
NVR-Dan Ross wrote on Nov 25, 2008 3:37 PM:
We have selected the five finalists, now it is time for you to select the overall winner of the $100 gift certificate to Vallerga's.
Go to the homepage and check out the finalists, then vote in the online poll for your favorite.
Thanks again for all the great stories.
--Dan "