NVR Logo
Shooter gets 70 years in Gee case
Brothers sentenced for AmCan slaying
Wednesday, September 24, 2008
Save and Share Share
Between the two of them, the teen brothers convicted of murder will spend a total of 90 years in state prison.

The courtroom was packed with family, friends and law enforcement on Tuesday afternoon as Napa County Superior Court Judge Ray Guadagni handed down the lengthy sentences to convicted killers Junor Douglas, 19, and Marquis Douglas, 18, both of Vallejo for the shooting death of 16-year-old Anthony Gee at an American Canyon sweet 16 birthday party.
Gee was killed by a single bullet wound to his head on Jan. 27, 2007.

Junor was sentenced to 70 years to life, and Marquis was given a 20-years-to-life term in state prison. In June, a jury found the brothers both guilty of second-degree murder and several other felonies.
At the sentencing, it was Anthony Gee’s parents — Cathy and Leland Gee — who addressed their son’s killers face to face for the first time.

Crying, but keeping her composure, Cathy Gee told the court of the agony she has gone through since the night she received that “horrible phone call. My world has been destroyed. I talked to Anthony on his cell phone 15 minutes before he was shot to death. Then I got the phone call, asking me if I was Anthony Gee’s mother. What’s happened? Is he all right? That’s all I could say,” Cathy said. “I held his hand in the emergency room, it was hooked up to all kinds of tubes and bags. I held it tight while I watched him die. I asked him to use his pipeline to God to ask for a miracle to save him. He waived his three fingers at me. I know he was saying good-bye. He couldn’t stay.”
Gee directed her comments directly to the Douglas brothers, who sat just feet away, dressed in jail house blue sweatsuits.

“I’m angry,” she said. “Marquis, why did you carry a gun to the party that night? Junor, you have caused a living nightmare for all of our family just because you were angry with a chaperone that night. You destroyed my whole world just because you were angry with a chaperone,” she said, brushing the streaming tears from her face. “How dare you play God and take a human life.”

Leland Gee’s voice rang out in the courtroom as he addressed the young defendants.

“I am speaking directly to you,” Leland said, his eyes fixed on Junor and Marquis.

“You took my only son. You took his future and my future. This year was to hold many joyous occasions for us. My son was going to graduate from high school. He had a very bright future as professional baseball pitcher. You two crushed all those milestones,” he said. “Anthony is gone, but you two will continue to live and drain the resources of our society. You are victims of your own stupidity. The loss of Anthony tore a hole in my heart that will sadden me for the rest of my days.”

The Douglas brothers, along with two of their friends also attended the birthday party. Junor got into an argument with rival rappers from Vallejo, who were not invited. A party chaperone broke up the confrontation and threw Junor out of the garage where the majority of guests had gathered.

Marquis brought his .33-caliber revolver to the party for protection. Angry with the chaperone, Junor got the gun from his brother and fired a shot toward the garage where a large number of partygoers, including Gee and the chaperone, had gathered. The bullet struck Gee in the head. He was taken to Santa Rosa Memorial Hospital where he died early the next morning.

At Tuesday’s sentencing, Junor and Marquis’ mother Arnetha Warrior-Griffin also spoke to the court.

She told the Gee family how sorry she was about their loss and that she prays for them every day.

Griffin also used the chance to explain why Marquis carried a gun.

She said he and Junor were victims of physical attacks. She said they had been “jumped” several times and beat up while walking to and from school.

“I was nervous for my boys and they were scared. I didn’t know Marquis had a gun, I would never had condoned it,” Griffin said. “I’m not trying to justify what they did, I’m just begging the court to have mercy on my children and give them a second chance. I know Marquis should not have had no gun, but he is a good boy.”

Marquis read a prepared statement to the court.

“My life has never been the same. I changed a lot of people’s lives that night of Jan. 27. But I never encouraged anyone to do anything. I didn’t shoot nobody. I am upset the jury found me guilty of aiding and abetting my brother’s crime. I know my actions were negligent. But everybody makes mistakes,” Marquis said. “I am really sorry, but I have to leave my past behind me. I’m sorry for Anthony. He never deserved to die like that. If I could have a second chance, I would never touch a gun again.”

The boys’ grandmother also pleaded with court to show mercy.

“My grandsons are not thugs. Junor has a 2-year-old baby boy, Junor Junior. He’s a real good daddy. I want to see my great grandson grow up with seeing his daddy on this side of the bars,” she said.

Junor’s attorney Jim McEntee and Merv Lernhart, who is representing Marquis, argued for probation and reduced sentences.

McEntee asked Guadagni to reduce the second-degree murder charge to firing into inhabited dwelling. “Junor is not a cold-blooded murderer.”

Throughout the trial, McEntee argued Junor never meant to shoot anyone. He said Junor fired the gun into the air to scare the people who threw him out of the party. He argued the gun jammed, and when Junor went to clear it, it accidentally went off, striking Gee.

Lernhart stressed to Guadagni that Marquis was only 16 when Gee died, and he has no prior criminal record. He also argued there was no evidence to show that Marquis intended to harm anyone, and he struggled with Junor to keep him from taking the gun.

Lieberstein argued neither of the defendants were candidates for probation and should be given the maximum sentences.

“They have ruined multiple lives,” he said. “They changed Anthony Gee’s dreams forever. They also changed their dreams, and they have to be held accountable. I really don’t think they understand what they did and why they were found guilty. If Marquis had not been at that party armed, Anthony would still be alive.”

In addition to the second-degree murder charges, both boys were found guilty of intentionally shooting into an inhabited building, intentionally discharging a firearm in a negligent manner, causing death and possession of firearm by a minor. Junor was also found guilty of five special allegations while his brother was found guilty of possession of live ammunition by a minor.

Gee was raised in Calistoga and moved to American Canyon in high school, where he attended Vintage High School. At the time of his death he lived with his family in Fairfield.
74 comment(s)

angry citizen wrote on Sep 23, 2008 8:24 PM:

" Good for justice. Use a gun, be stupid, destory lives and whole familes - rot in prison. Good job D.A. Gary Lieberstein in steering this case and putting out a strong message that we will not and can not tolerate brutal violence! "

whoa cowboy wrote on Sep 23, 2008 8:39 PM:

" Sorry a good daddy doesn't go out partying and shoot a gun just to scare people. Maybe he should have stayed home and played with his baby or been out working to support his baby. They are common thugs and I'm sorry they weren't instilled with better morals, and a general respect for human life. "

Amcanresident wrote on Sep 23, 2008 8:41 PM:

" Wow, I'm not shocked about the sentence. My condelences to the family, both sides. Marquis, the 16 year old that tried to stop his both got 20 years to life. Wow, what a county i moved to. I'm definetly not in SF or Marin anymore. I can not understand how a teacher who stat rapes his teenage student gets 6 moths and probation, and a 16 year old who attempts to stop another from commiting a crime gets 20 to life. I'm not saying that the boy should've got off, but it doesn't add up. "

SouthNapa wrote on Sep 23, 2008 9:05 PM:

" Marquis was the one who brought the gun. Although he tried to stop his brother from using the gun, had he not brought the gun, the shooting wouldn't have happened. I applaud these sentences and hopefully it sends a message to everybody that senseless murder won't be tolerated in this county. It's about time the punishment fit the crime! "

jonqcitizen wrote on Sep 23, 2008 9:16 PM:

" Amcanresident- You are definitely not in San Francisco or Marin any more. Residents in Napa County believe people should go to prison when they murder people. Sometimes, residents in Napa County think people shoule be put to death when they murder people. We like it that way.

BTW- I find it interesting that you think Marquis' only action was to attempt to stop a crime. That says a lot. "

Joe wrote on Sep 23, 2008 9:33 PM:

" I bet if the two defendants were females or white males the same age and under the same exact circumstances they would have recieved a lighter sentence. The young black male has a bad reputation in this country. Jury's most likely view them as criminals because of the history of violence these days in other communities. "

bloodagar wrote on Sep 23, 2008 10:00 PM:

" "But I never encouraged anyone to do anything. I didn’t shoot nobody. I am upset the jury found me guilty of aiding and abetting my brother’s crime."

What a punk!

Being in possession of an ILLEGAL firearm proves intent to not do good...
I have no empathy for these two males...they should have stayed home and studied instead of prowling the streets with an illegal firearm. Seems they WERE cowards then, and it doesn't matter now. "

Joe wrote on Sep 23, 2008 10:06 PM:

" I spelled "received" wrong in my comment. It's i before e except after c. "

jmo wrote on Sep 23, 2008 10:11 PM:

" Joe, drink some more of the "whoa is me" kool aid!
Southnapa: bring a gun go to jail! Period!!! Oh ya he tried to stop it...touchy feely. I would just stick with guilty go to jail! Why give Marquis any space. I applaud your final conclusions. "

B-Side wrote on Sep 23, 2008 10:40 PM:

" So the gun jammed and he was trying to clear it??? Really? I'm not an expert on guns but how exactly does a .33-caliber revolver jam? If I were trying to clear a jammed gun I would have it pointed at the ground. One less trigger finger on the streets; I'll sleep good tonight. "

Two Cents wrote on Sep 23, 2008 10:50 PM:

" Good job Judge Ray Guadagni! Thank you for removing these punks off our streets.
People wonder why kids are the way they are. Read the mothers and grandmothers statements.. "he shouldnt have had a gun, but he's a good boy" HA! Good boys drive around with loaded weapons at 16 & 17? Fire into random homes intentionally?
"My grandsons are not thugs"? Really? Fighting with rappers from Vallejo at a party, got mad and decided to shoot randomly inside someone's home which could have AND DID take someone's life. But they're not thugs, eh grandma?
And where's Dad's comment... oh yea, we know how that one goes..
This is what happens when parent(s) turn a blind eye to their kids' behavior.
Pull your head out ladies! Your sons are punks and your grandsons are thugs. They are now going to a population of their peers to sit and think about how stupid their actions were.
To the Gee family, reading your statements to the boys brought tears to my eyes.. I cannot imagine losing one of my children, especially at the hands of fools like these.
May you find some comfort knowing that you'll see your son again and that he's waiting for you in a wonderful place. "

naynay wrote on Sep 24, 2008 12:37 AM:

" this is the mother and this is to any person who has any comments to me
i am very sorry for this tragedy and the gee family as well as my family will never be the same. also 2 cents you would have had to be in the court room to hear everything I said my mother, my sister, my daughter and my older son. My family refuses to give the nvr a comment. We give all comments to the newspaper of my hometown. I know my comments are not going to make it to this newspaper. well they dan? "

naynay wrote on Sep 24, 2008 1:22 AM:

" thank you dan! any one who as any thing you say about me I will be ready in the evening it's way past my bed time and I have not had sleep for 2 days so napa have fun beating me up remember you do not know anything about me only my coworkers do so have fun. I might responed back this evening! "

kracker wrote on Sep 24, 2008 5:54 AM:

" I am appalled that people would play the race card in this situation! They killed a young man! To mom and grandma, your "good boys" were punk cowards who carry guns to act tough. Dont drop the soap boys! "

steph wrote on Sep 24, 2008 8:20 AM:

" How sad how sad how sad.

What lessons will be learned to ensure Junor's now fatherless son doesn't grow up under the same circumstances that lead to Junor's mistakes? Who will be this precious child's stable, responsible male role models? "

localmama wrote on Sep 24, 2008 8:23 AM:

" Naynay, I feel for you, however; I feel worse for the Gee family. You should have known what your children were up to. By the way they talk, act around you and their peers. Who were they associating themselves with? Shame on you for not taking more responsibility in their lives. They were very angry young men, how sad. "

valley gril wrote on Sep 24, 2008 8:23 AM:

" This whole situation is tragic, one innocent young man lost his life, two stupid young boys messedtheir lives up... I WILL rest easier knowing that there are 2 less idiots with guns on the streets... If your child has been "jumped" and you want them to feel protected, enroll them in a martial arts class, encourage them to join the wrestling team in school, TEACH THEM GUN SAFETY!! JEEZ!!!! "

steph wrote on Sep 24, 2008 8:43 AM:

" I think the taunts directed at Junor and Marquis, such as those from "kracker" are appalling and disgusting.

Once again I find myself so saddened by how our society treats children, doesn't care for children.

Can't you see what happens to children who grow up without having their most basic emotional and educational needs met? While they do need to be held accountable for their actions, I can't help but feel that the first tragedy was the fact that their father(s) wasn't there for them.

If you're young and thinking of having a baby, make sure you are at a point in your life where you can provide everything that child needs, including love and discipline and a mature, responsible example. Make sure your partner is able to do the same, FOR LIFE.

Because when you don't act responsibly, you risk this story repeating itself in your home.

Children need two parents who each have a clue. "

mominapa wrote on Sep 24, 2008 8:45 AM:

" It is very hard to know what to say about all this. Anger, hatred and all the other negative emotions are relevant. I'm sorry for Anthony Gee's parents most of all. As Mr. Gee said, his future has changed forever and. as a parent, I know his sadness will be with him always. These boys didn't just kill a young man, they killed his family as they knew it and now they have to pick up the pieces and try to go on and find normalcy when every single day of their lives, their son will be in their minds, thoughts and hearts, but not there to see, talk to kiss and touch. Sure those boys are thugs and sure those boys are stupid and all the rest. Their mother has lost her sons as well. No winners here, only losers because some loser thought he was big and "bad" enough to carry a gun to a party. I'm totally bummed about this whole thing. Not a shred of sunlight in this whole mess. I hope Mr. and Mrs. Gee will find some solace and comfort somewhere along the line. Someday you will smile again and someday you will find things funny again, but you will always hold your son in your heart where he belongs. He belongs in your house and I'm sorry, so sorry for you that this happened. Some of us are so lucky and we don't appreciate it. "

yvonne wrote on Sep 24, 2008 9:52 AM:

" naynay, I am sorry for your loss, but I am glad that your boys are behind bars. I'm not trying to be mean, but a 16 year old with a gun is not someone I want to be running the streets. Why were your boys being threatened and jumped at high school? Is it because of the company they kept? I somehow doubt that your boys were "good boys", I think you''ve probably been unaware of the life they were leading away from home, or maybe unfortunately thats the life you grew up in also. I hope that your grandson grows up healthy and happy and knowing that gangs and thugs aren't the way to be successful in life. I hope that you can find a way to rebuild your life, and that maybe you can teach others like your boys that the life of guns and violence doesn't lead to a good and successful future.

Mr and Mrs Gee, I sincerely hope that you can rebuild your life and find comfort in knowing that Anthony is in a beautiful place and you have a guardian angel watching over you. "

vocal-de-local wrote on Sep 24, 2008 10:01 AM:

" Ditto Steph!

Too many angry young people out there taking their "lack of guidance" out on society. Too many parents having children, not because they're wanted, or because they can afford to care for them or take the time to interact with them; but because it's the social "norm" or they are being rewarded for it. Too many young men and women, often teens, showing off their trophy baby with pierced ears; or a young father will tote his baby son along to a party to show off his virility. He then brings it home and dumps it on the mother and society to raise so that daddy can live his machismo lifestyle by getting more women pregnant. The baby is observed as an object rather than a "being" to be nurtured.

If we cannot stop this, we cannot stop the violence. "

deemac wrote on Sep 24, 2008 10:23 AM:

" Well honestly I don’t think the jury was fair. Anthony Gee was a victim to an innocent crime, yes marquis shouldn’t have brought a gun but a lot of people don’t understand the circumstances we go through to protect our selves these days as young black people in the community. The whole thing was an accident. People are on here calling these young men idiots and telling them how stupid they are, you aren’t supposed to tell a teenager that stuff. 70 years to life for an accident?? Lord have mercy it doesn’t make any sense what so ever. Nay nay i'm sorry for your children they really don’t deserve the sentence they are getting but don’t lose faith GOD has a way of making things fair. "

shaunie wrote on Sep 24, 2008 10:27 AM:

" before i say anything i would like to say sorry to the gee family about what happen. but my cusins where good boys they never got into trouble they were like our best friends and yes i was there yesterday as i watched them say a few lies and look at my cousins with lots of hatrate. but i dont understand why marquis has life, you herd them he didnt shoot gee he tried to stop it. you herd my grandma, aunties,and cousins but still gave him life i just dont no why. and know my cousins arnt thugs, just because they listen to rap and make it doesnt mean there thugs. and now my little cousin baby junor wont have a dad thats there with him and he'll also have a missing uncle. and auntie naynay its going to be okay. "

WatchDoggie wrote on Sep 24, 2008 10:44 AM:

" I read these comments and see how angry people are and the lack of any shred of empathy, and it leaves me no wonder that our children are raised with the same pervasive spirit of venom and vengeance. No wonder they carry guns.
SHAME ON US!

By the way - If your angry brother takes your hemi-powered jacked-up pickup truck, even though you try to stop him, and in a road rage runs someone over with it, do you really believe that you deserve a life sentence for owning and driving such a truck?!? It's absolutely ABSURD to give Marquis a life sentence.

Also - The Register needs to understand: A sentence of 20-life is a LIFE sentence. All the 20 means is that in 20 actual years, Marquis will first sit in front of a parole board. Most people convicted of murder do not get paroled. "

aleph wrote on Sep 24, 2008 11:11 AM:

" Violence is never the answer.

I believe this sentence to be just and this should send a message to those gang members in Napa.

There should be a strict curfew where violence is arising such as in Napa, AC, and Vallejo and shold be enforced by the city. Parents should also contribute in enforcing discipline on their children.

However, a curfew is not going to stop the violence completely. There are many sociological dynamics in our society that should be taken into consideration when creating a firm plan to eliminate violence.

Moreover, it's comical how supporters of owning a gun are now bashing on someone who carried a gun... In the end, it doesn't matter-weapons kill. ....I'm just saying.... "

Dwayne wrote on Sep 24, 2008 11:34 AM:

" deemac...

Both boys were the perpetrators of a killing, and are not the victims as you portray them as... The basic attitude that they are victims of some kind is probably behind the root cause of why they went gunning for anyone...

Shooting into a crowd is no "accident"... Get real...

Oh yes, and I have listened to rap lyrics and understand how shooting and killing is professed to make punks feel manly... That's just plain sick, and certainly contributory... "

napawineo wrote on Sep 24, 2008 11:39 AM:

" Deemac, are you serious???

She/he actuall said the following:

Well honestly I don’t think the jury was fair. Anthony Gee was a victim to an innocent crime, yes marquis shouldn’t have brought a gun but a lot of people don’t understand the circumstances we go through to protect our selves these days as young black people in the community."

WHO CARES! These boys KILLED and Killers get sent to prison... enough said..... These Killers should never be let out...PERIOD............Don't expect anyone to feel sorry for them or YOU or the family of the KILLERS.... WOOPS it was a mistake...yeah RIGHT.... "

y2kcbr wrote on Sep 24, 2008 11:44 AM:

" @ Deemac
I won't bring race, color, creed, choice of backpacks at school...however I wonder about your comment:
"...a lot of people don’t understand the circumstances we go through to protect our selves these days as young black people in the community."

A lot of people don't understand why people choose to shoot eachother. Why a young mans' life was ruined over a teenager who made a bad decision. I feel the choices made that day were extremely bad.

I agree with the right to bear arms, however in YOUR HOUSE, protecting your HOUSE and FAMILY. The brothers' carried a weapon as it is/was status quo in our violent world. The punishment for killing a person in other countries is a .02 cent bullet.

The Douglas' brothers have a unique opportunity here. They get to live. This was the choice the Jury delivered. The Douglas' brothers also played Jury as well when they shot and killed Anthony Gee. Anthony didn't get a choice. "

tiredofcomplainingnapkins wrote on Sep 24, 2008 11:46 AM:

" To Deemac and Shaunie,
I don't know what world your living in but these guys got exactly what they deserve. Good human beings don't get kicked out of a party, go to there car and get a gun, then return to the party and try to shoot it off to scare people. These aren't actions of good people. Junor has a son, a good father would have been home with his kid, not out at some high school party. Stop saying these were good kids because there not. Good kids are busy helping the community, doing good things to help the community and family, not driving around with a gun and then purposely trying to fire it off at a party. I'm thankful these guys are off the street before they could commit another "ACCIDENT". "

kracker wrote on Sep 24, 2008 11:46 AM:

" Accident? What are you smoking? He shot this poor kid! Life sentence for both is getting off easy, how about and eye for eye? If the roles were reversed the family of these 2 would be screaming for maximum punishment. The only losers in this whole ordeal is the Gee family and hardworking Californian's who now how to pay for these 2 to be incarcirated for the rest of there lives. "

B-Side wrote on Sep 24, 2008 11:49 AM:

" WatchDoggie,
Your anology is laughable. A gun is a weapon under any circumstance. Even if you use it to crack open walnuts it was designed and manufactured as a weapon. A truck is only a weapon when so used. Sorry that I have no sympathy.
Had Marquis not been totting a gun, Anthony Gee would most likely
be alive today. "

SouthNapa wrote on Sep 24, 2008 12:28 PM:

" Marquis brought the gun to the party. Just because he didn't fire the gun, it doesn't make him any less accountable. If he keeps the gun at home (or better yet, doesn't have a gun to begin with), this murder doesn't occur. The sentences are justified. Good job by the D.A. and the Judge on getting these criminals off the street! "

wipemedown wrote on Sep 24, 2008 12:46 PM:

" junior junior. .....what a name....I think the judge made a fair decision. Who wants this type of behavior in our state, town, neighborhood? Throw the book and throw it hard. Let it be a lesson for future generations. This behavior will not be tolerated. As far as being sensitive to the douglas brothers. I feel for them, if they were properly taught how to use, clean, maintain, and aim a firearm like anyone with a firearm should know. Families would not be destroyed. The gun jammed......well responsible people are responsible gun owners and now its time to become responsible for past actions. "

1_4eastnapa wrote on Sep 24, 2008 1:08 PM:

" sorry 4 both families, good luck N life and may the lord b w/ us all.. "

meltoes wrote on Sep 24, 2008 1:14 PM:

" Proud to be a Napkin, most of the time, but not now.
I grew up in Napa, and let me tell you this...there were many a party in town where kids were carrying guns and I graduated from Vintage 17 years ago!! Some of the kids at these parties are now business owners and well respected community leaders. Everyone is young and dumb once, just because you make a mistake does that mean you've been a "punk and a thug" your entire life?
Please, people why don't you hold all your angry judgemental comments and save them for a town hall meeting trying to figure out a way to encourage our kids to resort to other means beside violence to resolve conflict.
Being a mother now, I can't believe how these posts are affecting the mothers of all these boys involved. Realize that no matter what your opinion is, your life has not been irrerparably changed forever. Both mothers have lost their sons. Why can't anyone in my beloved community say a kind word to the mothers. And before you go judging so harshly, I would suggest everyone of you clean out your own closets and be sure there are no dust bunnies there.
My thoughts and prayers are with the Gee family AND the Douglas family.
Lastly, thank you Napa for once again reminding me how slow we progress in opening our minds and hearts to others. "

B-Side wrote on Sep 24, 2008 1:26 PM:

" wipemedown
I've never heard of a revolver jamming. Maybe that can, but it seems highly unlikely. It's normally the clip style pistols that get jammed. I'm not buying the gun jamming story.
Let's mourne Anthony Gee's death, then celebrate his life. That's what I'd want. "

angry citizen wrote on Sep 24, 2008 1:33 PM:

" About Marquis...you're all forgetting a few details. He kept bullets for his gun under his bed (just a normal teen??) He left home without his gun, turned around and went back for it before he got on the bus to ride to meet his brother, proudly passed his loaded weapon around the car for all to admire, he left the party to steal in WalMart for awhile, returned to the party, went back out to the car to RETRIEVE the loaded gun when things got tense, went right TOWARDS his brother when his brother was demanding a gun, never yelled out to warn innocents around that Junor took a LOADED gun, ran away WITH Junor afterwards, told tons of lies and stories about what happened, was CONVICTED of intimidating a state witness in the case, convicted of minor in possession of firearm, ETC ETC ETC. It wasn't just that he "tried to stop his brother from taking a loaded gun" like you're all trying to claim. I don't think that sounds like a "good kid" do you? And, would you feel the same if his gun killed your innocent child who thought he was just going to attend a family birthday? Ask yourselves that question HONESTLY !! "

Amcanresident wrote on Sep 24, 2008 2:09 PM:

" 2nd degree murder gets 70 years, having a gun at a party gets 20 years. Stat rapes (plural) by the Hirk wrestling coach gets 6 months and probation. C'mon people, these boys deserve punishment, but if you punish someone, please make things close to remotely equal. Is it beacuse they had a public defender? Is is because they are black? Treat everyone fairly. Is it because he had his own lawyer? Is it because he is white? If you're giving out 2nd degree murder 70 years, at least make it equal, Hirk should've gotten at least 15 years. This is all I am saying. Get all the criminals of the street. The white guy that recently molested that 11 year old in Napa, better get more than probation judge. "

meltoes wrote on Sep 24, 2008 2:14 PM:

" trying this again.
Proud to be a Napkin, most of the time. Not now.
I grew up in Napa and let me tell you this...there were many a party in town where kids carried guns and I graduated from Vintage 17 years ago!!! Some of the kids at those parties are now business owners and well respected community leaders. Everyone is young and dumb once, just because you make a mistake does that mean you've been a "punk and a thug" your entire life?
Please, people why don't you hold all your angry judgemental comments and save them for a townhall meeting to figure out a way to encourage our kids to resort to other means besides violence to resolve conflict.
Being a mother, I can't believe how these posts are affecting the mothers of all the boys involved. Realize that no matter what your opinion is, your life has not been irreparably changed forever. Both mothers have lost their sons. Why can't anyone in my beloved community feel for these mothers. Before you go judging so harshly I would suggest everyone of you clean out your own closets and be sure there are no dust bunnies there.
My thoughts and prayers are with the Gee family AND the Douglas family.
Lastly, thank you Napa for once again reminding me how slow we are to progress in opening our minds and hearts to others. "

napawineo wrote on Sep 24, 2008 2:23 PM:

" amcanresident, 2nd degree MURDER/with a gun at party --- yes gets 70 YEARS --no it isn't because the KILLERS were black --it is because they are KILLERS. Don't compare KILLING to any other crime because these guys are KILLERS and deserve to rot in prison - BLACK OR WHITE... Get a life....stop trying to make the Sentence something other the KILLERS getting what KILLERS deserve...... "

Joe wrote on Sep 24, 2008 2:24 PM:

" Marquis should not have recieved a life sentence. The gun was in the car when Junor got it. It's not like Marquis handed it to him. If he deserves a life sentence then so do all the people who drive drunk and kill people. This kind of stuff has happened before and the gun owner wasn't charged. I think because Marquis is a young black male people view him as a thug and want him off the streets. "

Joe wrote on Sep 24, 2008 2:37 PM:

" Rap music and especially rap music videos play a huge role in the violence with kids these days. All these kids see these rappers talking about killing people. Kids think they are hard when they carry guns and act like gangsters. The rap is even called gangsta rap. Kids want to be like 50 cent and get shot 12 times and live. It's pathetic that mtv caters to all of it "

B-Side wrote on Sep 24, 2008 3:36 PM:

" Joe,

So does TV and the movies. "

napaao wrote on Sep 24, 2008 3:49 PM:

" yeah no second chances here!


"not thugs" LOL!!!!! riiiight

i feel sorry for the gee fam, but this can happen to anyone anywhere. "

tiredofcomplainingnapkins wrote on Sep 24, 2008 4:10 PM:

" To amcanresident,

How could you even argue these two crimes are similar? The coach had consenual sex with minors and now he has to deal with being a sex offender and the shame of what he did. He didn't rape those women. No one died, no other lives have been ruined by his actions. The douglas brothers KILLED someone. They ruined the Gee family lives, as well as there own family. They also put a whole party of people lives at risk by shooting into a crowd. Your crazy if you think someone should get 15 years in prison for having consenual sex with someone. "

jmo wrote on Sep 24, 2008 5:18 PM:

" First off I want to offer my deepest sympathies to the Gee family.

Deemac: step away from the kool aid.

Shaunie: I would like to suggest that you try writing your comments in Word first and use the Spelling and Grammar feature located under tools in the tool bar. I will make it easier for the rest of us to understand your posting.

I am infuriated by this tragic murder. I had to read the article several times and then walk away before these comments.
Thank you Judge Guadagni. You got it right and saw thru all the Douglas, Warrior-Griffin, grand mother, defense attorney etc pleas.

These were two uninvited people to a 16 year olds birthday party.

Leland’s voice rang LOUD for all of us!!!!

Rival rappers? He was 16. Please! Bring a gun scare the bro (“oh ya it was for “PROTECTION")...exactly what ere the rap lines to be? Hey Bro I'm older/ better than you. So, I hope this bullet misses you...maybe everyone??? This doesn’t work for me.
Douglas brothers God will be your (as well as everyone else’s) ultimate judge.

The gall of the defense attorney's to argue for PROBATION and REDUCED sentences... a death/murder occurred here folks!!!
Again thank you Judge Guadagni!!" "

bloodagar wrote on Sep 24, 2008 5:34 PM:

" Oh Shaunie....lets not forget your previous comments on NVR.

The only comment "NAYNAY" or you should be making is "YES, THESE TWO INDIVIDUALS KILLED AN INNOCENT BOY AND THEY WILL PAY THE PRICE"

Any pity parties as shameful at this point! These two are a direct reflection of his family and his environment. "

Annabella wrote on Sep 24, 2008 5:51 PM:

" Do the crime...do the time. What a bloody shame is the stupid deadly emotional act where a young man with great potential is cut down. There are not words I can offer to change things...but let it be a lesson to all young people. Guns kill...that is what they are for nothing more. "

Two Cents wrote on Sep 24, 2008 7:15 PM:

" Jmo.. you are hilarious! I love it... step away from the koolaid!
Seriously.. reading the posts from the family shows how ignorant they really are. Its no wonder these boys turned out how they did.
Who defends their child's need to "protect" themselves in that way? Get a grip people, this is Napa County, not Compton. We dont need drive around with weapons to "protect" ourselves.
These boys are nothing but a bunch of sad wannabes.
And now they're going to find out what REAL hardened criminals are all about and no doubt witness some of the true violence and rage written about in their precious rap songs.
Sad to see the cycle continue.. obviously they had no male presence in their lives to help them become men, and now the 2 yr old boy will be in the same place. Being raised by a grandmother who will be telling him that what their father and uncle did wasnt really all that bad, after all it was just an accident that happened to good boys.
Now they are another financial drain on society and an emotional drain for the Gee family.
You just cant undo bad parenting. Makes me sleep better knowing they're no longer a threat to me or my loved ones. "

Dwayne wrote on Sep 24, 2008 7:33 PM:

" Annabella wrote on Sep 24, 2008 5:51 PM:
" ....Guns kill...that is what they are for nothing more. "

People kill, not guns... I don't know of any guns that are in prison for murder... "

deemac wrote on Sep 24, 2008 7:45 PM:

" For one, I have no relation to the two boys. Just think if that was your son you would be furious, so DON’T even start with me. I really feel people are playing the race card and i find it very offensive. And yes shaunie is a friend of mine, my condolences go out to the Gee family. I’m not justifying what they did was right but God! You guys are killing me. And jmo dont worry about what i write or what i drink because honestley this is very racist to me. "

Joe wrote on Sep 24, 2008 8:15 PM:

" People keep saying they like both brothers did it. I really don't care that Marquis will be in prison for so long. But he shouldn't have recieved that much time. I bet just because they were brothers it influenced a harsher punishment. There is no doubt that if a police captains son had a gun illegally and his friend took it and killed someone he would not receive near that much time if any at all. "

marcydeeds wrote on Sep 24, 2008 9:05 PM:

" Judge Ray is an extremely fair talented judge. People who say that race had anything to do with the sentences are dead wrong.

Everyone complains when defendants receive light sentences that our justice system isn't harsh enough and then it's the other way around when a lengthy sentence is handed down.

Ultimately all judges do the best they can with the laws that are on the books. No judge takes any sentence lightly and I'm sure they agonize over all the tough cases like this one. Decisions like this are based on the facts of the case.

I am thankful for the hard work on the part of the prosecutor and the judge to help keep our streets a bit safer. "

noseyrosie wrote on Sep 24, 2008 9:28 PM:

" Do the crime pay the time! "

bjorn wrote on Sep 24, 2008 9:40 PM:

" I got to know Marquis well during his confinement. Yes what he did was more than dumb but I am impressed by the young man he has become. If he keeps the attitude and outlook he was able to matin in Juvy. he will have a positive impact on those around him.

If any 16 year old thinks he needs a gun for self protection then I think that WE have failed them.

Several years ago when my sun was in Silverado a state test asked the question “ Do you feel save in your school” All the students that said no were called into the office and, in the words of the staff, “We just explained the question and they were given a chance to change their answer” and to my knowledge nothing was changed to make the school safer.

Sounds a little like the Vallejo school that told the Douglas family that since the beatings did not happen on school grounds they couldn’t do anything. And did not even encourage the mother to contact the Police. If anything is going to change, all of us are going to have to go the extra mile and not take the easy way out.
It didn’t happen on my watch. It’s not my neighborhood. It’s not my kid. No longer is an acceptable answer. "

Napagrrl wrote on Sep 25, 2008 10:18 AM:

" While I believe the sentences were too harsh for these two, I'd like to mention something else I have not seen commented upon. I am the parent of high school kids and virtually every week I hear of a party that got out of hand. These are usually "coming of age" parties like Sweet 16 and Quinceaneras. This type of party usually has a larger number of invitees than does a non-milestone birthday. However, for every kid who receives an invitation, many others show up. This is where trouble begins. I have some suggestions: If your kid says he/she is going to such a party, ask to see the invitation. If your child says s/he was verbally invited, call the parent of the honoree for details. If your kid begs you not to call, s/he was probably not invited. If you do call, ask who will be chaparoning. If you or your child is embarrassed to call, just say you're asking if there's anything your child can bring to contribute to the festivities - then ask the questions. If you're hosting such a party, have your child ask invited guests not to give details to anyone else; the fewer uninvited guests who appear, the less trouble. It may not solve all the problems, but maybe it'll help! "

loving&&loved wrote on Sep 25, 2008 10:29 AM:

" I think that most of the people posting nasty and rude comments on here sound real ignorant.
These kids did deserve a punishment but not a punishment that’s going to take away half of their life.
For the people saying they deserved it think about it they took away a life and now the jail system is taking away theirs. Now what sense does that make. Take two/three lives away from people when you could just have them compensate for the one that they took. They should have gotten a lower sentenced and if I was their mother I would get a lawyer and appeal that decision because that isn’t fair on some part. Rapist and people that commit manslaughter get 10 to 15 years while these young boys get 70 and 20. And not to throw the race card up but it does seem like it was because their black. If two white young boys did the same exact crime in American canyon and shot a black boy in a party do you think they would get the same sentence...I think not. So you have to see it from both sides. Imagine that was your son getting killed or your sons that have killed him think what you would want to happen to them. "

shaunie wrote on Sep 25, 2008 10:45 AM:

" jmo I’m tiered of you and all of the other people talking about my cousins because they are good kids but yall wouldn’t know that because you don’t know them and to be honest you don’t even know the gee family ether. I just so happen to no them my entire life. But do you really no why they carried a gun, well because they were constantly jumped just because they weren’t from they area. My auntie had bricks thrown into her house and car and everything. So they no choose but to protect there selves. and as you seen the marquis left the gun in the car he didn’t bring it into the party and thank you demac for your support because were on the opposite side doesn’t mean we aren’t hurt just as much as them. See miss gee didn’t know her son was going to die but ma auntie knows that both her sons will die in there. "

shaunie wrote on Sep 25, 2008 10:55 AM:

" I would like to say that I understand you because I’m only 15 and I go to the same school my cousins attended and its real wild actually I’m in class right now just got done with my work. But it’s funny that it took two boys to ardently kill someone for people to even try to understand what’s going on out here but look at other stuff there’s worst crimes out there look around "

meltoes wrote on Sep 25, 2008 11:11 AM:

" Bottom Line:
One Dead, Two in prison, TWO families destroyed. All for a stupid idea of being disrespected.It took about 20 seconds to ruin all these lives. HOW SAD!!
It's sad to see everyone keeping the hatred going.... "

cbelle wrote on Sep 25, 2008 12:11 PM:

" If you fear for your safety wherever you go, do us a favor and stay home. If trouble follows you there, that is what 911 is for. Leave the freedoms of Sweet 16 parties and spending time with friends and family to the rest of us. I'm sorry, but your story sounds like you were going out looking for trouble to me. Violence begets violence. It will never beget peace. More and more people are afraid for their selves and their children to leave their homes because of things like this. It's time that it is turned the other way around. "

Yvonne wrote on Sep 25, 2008 3:49 PM:

" Shaunie - good kids don't bring guns to a sweet sixteen part. Good kids don't shoot guns into a garage full of people. No, I don't know your cousins, and I don't know the Gee family. Yes, your family hurts because your family members will possibly live the rest of their lives in prison, but you and your family will be able to visit them, talk to them, and write to them. You can still do that, the Gee family members don't have that, because your cousins brought a gun to a party they were not invited to, and one of them decided to shoot that gun. He didn't intend to shoot Anthony in the head and kill him, he was actually mad at the adult who kicked him out of the party that he WAS NOT INVITED TO.
I don't care if you and your cousins are black, green or purple, race has nothing to do with the fact that one of them owned a gun and one decided to use it. They were carrying this gun, not in the area that you say they were constantly jumped in, they were carrying it in a quiet neighborhood that THEY WERE NOT INVITED TO. They caused this disaster, and I'm sorry that you in your youth don't understand that, but hopefully as you grow older you will be able to see the truth. Hopefully you will learn from this tragic lesson and maybe you can teach others in your family and extended family that carrying a gun will cause you to lose your life, figuratively and literally. "

Joe wrote on Sep 25, 2008 4:26 PM:

" This is just another reason why American Canyon should be moved to Solano County. It is so close to Vallejo that all the problems of Vallejo will move right in and the County of Napa will have to deal with it. In the years to come the violence and crime is only going to get worse there. Napa is going to have to deal with all of it at the taxpayers expense. Napa county has way to good of a reputation to risk. American Canyon is going to take that away from us. "

yvonne wrote on Sep 25, 2008 6:23 PM:

" Joe, you have got to be kidding right? You haven't read the paper that you are commenting in regarding the stabbings and beatings going on in Napa? They aren't going on in American Canyon, and they aren't being committed by people from American Canyon are they? The two arrests for the beating and murder over a cell phone and pocket change were residents of Napa, not AC and not Vallejo. How about the stabbings that have taken place in the last week or so, they have taken place in Napa, not American Canyon.
Like it or not, American Canyon is part of Napa County, and not part of Solano County. We pay taxes to Napa County, I know my property taxes get mailed to Napa, the same as yours, of course assuming you bought property in Napa county.
But, what has this to do with the tragic death of a young man, and the tragic choices made by two other young men, regardless of where they live? "

vocal-de-local wrote on Sep 25, 2008 11:45 PM:

" shaunie, my son was bullied mercilessly as a child. He didn't hit a growth spurt until he was sixteen. prior to that he looked super young. He still looks unbelievably young even though he's in his mid twenties. Unfortunately, his youthful appearance combined with his smaller stature left him very vulnerable to abuse from classmates. Yet he NEVER pulled a gun on anyone or even considered carrying one around.

As a mother, I didn't tolerate the abuse I saw my son being subjected to. My parents must have done something right because I have a fighting spirit to protect my children from abuse combined with the instinct to trust my intuition. I pulled my oldest son out of schools, searched and found better ones and didn't give up. Today, he's self sufficient and doing well.

It's really sad that your cousins suffered abuse and yet no one stuck up for them. I actually pulled my son out of the school system and homeschooled him for awhile. I was so fed up with the abuse he received at school that I decided to homeschool my youngest child all the way until the end of high school.

Take this advice with you shaunie. Value the children you may someday have. Don't bring children into the world until you are self sufficient. It will be a great deal easier if you wait until you are older and more established in your life. Every child has worth. They need to be protected and cherished. Do not have them just because a social system will pay for it. Only bring children into the world when you are truly mature and responsible enough to handle it. You're life will be easier if you wait until you reach stability. I wish I could help. "

bloodagar wrote on Sep 26, 2008 7:10 AM:

" Wow, Shaunie, I didn't realize that you were 15. I apologize for my earlier comments, you are still so young and capable of much more.

Your cousins gave you a good example of a bad example...do not repeat their mistakes. Please sweetheart, think before you act. Turn your pain into something constructive in your community. Study harder than ANY of the classmates you have. Put your social life on the back burner and get your butt to college!!! Do everything that your cousins will be unable to do: that will honor not only them but those they hurt.

That is my best advice to you. Vocal-de-local gives great advice too. "

y2kcbr wrote on Sep 26, 2008 10:01 AM:

" @ Joe
Thanks for the laugh. That has to be the funniest thing that I've read in a LONG time. I will send you a bill to replace the monitor that I spewed coffee on "

loving&&loved wrote on Sep 26, 2008 10:21 AM:

" Don’t you think what you adult say or do influence what we children do now.
I’m 14 and shaunie is one of my friends and we come to this site everyday to see how nasty and rude people are these days.
Don’t you think that affects us and our lives?
To see you people talk down on people you don’t know and never meet now because of the legal system wanted to give them so much time.
That isn’t right how a grown man knew what he was doing and shot matt Garcia and only gets 51 years to life while these boys made a mistake and gets 70 years to life.
Adults want children to respect them and why do you want respect if you can’t give respect? You expect us to be good little children and not make mistakes. Did you people do that when you were younger? I think not. I bet most of you people wanted to shoot someone in you life you probably didn’t have the guts to do it or the equipment to. These brothers made a simple mistake and yes they have to pay for it but not like this. And for all you people saying stuff like "they were mad they were kicked out" no they weren’t you guys don’t know the real story you go by what the newspaper print out but some off that stuff isn’t real. Don’t base your judgment on what you have read. You really had to be there to understand you have to know somebody that was at the party and actually seen and known what happened. If you weren’t then I don’t think you should comment on it. "

jersey guy wrote on Sep 26, 2008 1:19 PM:

" Anybody who recklessly shoots into a crowd deserves 70 years or a very long sentence. Just by doing that, that person has shown that they have no regard for human life and would most likely do it again under similar circumstances. They deserve the sentence to protect other people in the future. "

jersey guy wrote on Sep 26, 2008 1:26 PM:

" loving&&loved: Napa and Napa County are known as being tougher on criminals than Solano County. That is one reason that our violent crime rate is lower, though it may currently be rising.
It doesn't take guts to shoot into a crowd and hit someone who had nothing to do with offending you. Only a coward does that. Yes, I have wanted to "kill" someone in the past, but don't carry a handgun with me for "protection". Carrying around a gun just turns someone into a coward. "

Yvonne wrote on Sep 26, 2008 2:42 PM:

" loving&&loved -
Learn from the mistakes of these two young men, don't follow down that same path. No, I have never wanted to shoot someone in my life, even when I was attacked, robbed and injured, a knife held to my neck, I never once thought about wanting to shoot that man. I have been in pain every day since that experience, I see a doctor twice a month for treatment still, seven years later. I let the legal system punish the man who attacked me and changed the course of my life. I have owned a gun during my life, but I never ever wanted to use it on someone, and it had nothing to do with "guts" it had to do with whats right and whats wrong. It is wrong to take someone's life, even if it is by mistake. Shooting a gun into an inhabited dwelling is wrong, a 16 and 17 year old boy carrying a gun and using it to scare someone or whatever you think they were planning to do is wrong.
They did make a mistake, actually a whole series of mistakes. Unfortunately based on your comments "I bet most of you people wanted to shoot someone in you life" only shows us reading your blog that this problem is wide spread though-out the family and extended family.
No, we were not all at that party, and didn't see it, mostly because we WERE NOT INVITED!
You will grow up (hopefully) and someday understand, and as for the accused in the Garcia case, they haven't been sentenced yet.... "

y2kcbr wrote on Sep 26, 2008 2:50 PM:

" " These brothers made a simple mistake and yes they have to pay for it but not like this. "
A simple mistake is turning a wrong way on a one-way road. Killing someone is not a simple mistake. The mistake was taking a gun to a party. The mistake was going to the party. The mistake is not understanding your friends committed murder and need to pay for this heinous crime. "

Yvonne wrote on Sep 26, 2008 2:52 PM:

" loving&&loved -
Learn from the mistakes of these two young men, don't follow down that same path. No, I have never wanted to shoot someone in my life, even when I was attacked, robbed and injured, a knife held to my neck, I never once thought about wanting to shoot that man. I have been in pain every day since that experience, I see a doctor twice a month for treatment still, seven years later. I let the legal system punish the man who attacked me and changed the course of my life. I have owned a gun during my life, but I never ever wanted to use it on someone, and it had nothing to do with "guts" it had to do with whats right and whats wrong. It is wrong to take someone's life, even if it is by mistake. Shooting a gun into an inhabited dwelling is wrong, a 16 and 17 year old boy carrying a gun and using it to scare someone or whatever you think they were planning to do is wrong.
They did make a mistake, actually a whole series of mistakes. Unfortunately based on your comments "I bet most of you people wanted to shoot someone in you life" only shows us reading your blog that this problem is wide spread though-out the family and extended family.
No, we were not all at that party, and didn't see it happen, mostly because we WERE NOT INVITED!
You will grow up (hopefully) and someday understand, and as for the accused in the Garcia case, they haven't been sentenced yet.... "

cellsitegod wrote on Sep 30, 2008 6:37 AM:

" Never ignore your children.
Invite family togetherness.
Get involved with your kids.
Go to family counciling.
Encourage sensitivity.
Respond to your childs feelings.
Sound like a liberal attitude? "

Comment Guidelines
The goal of the story comments section at NapaValleyRegister.com is to have an open, thought-provoking, civil community forum for all issues.
What gets your comment posted?
• Staying on topic
• Keeping your comment to 300 words or less
• Avoiding name-calling
• Addressing your comments to the message rather than the messenger
What gets your comment deleted?
• Personal attacks
• Derogatory remarks
• Name-calling of any sort
• Going off-topic
• Hate speech
• Racially-insensitive comments
• Implying guilt of a subject in a crime story before there is a court verdict
• Posting e-mail addresses
• Posting comments of a commercial nature
• POSTING WITH ALL CAPITAL LETTERS
• Linking multiple comments together with "to be continued..." to get around the 300 word limit.
The fine print
- Comments are either approved or denied. We do not edit comments.
- You are welcome to modify and resubmit a denied comment.
- Comments may take several hours to be posted.
- Comments posted are those of the writer, and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of NapaValleyRegister.com, its employees or its parent company.
- Do you have information on a story? Please go to our virtual newsroom to send us a news tip.
- If you feel a posted comment has violated our guidelines, please contact online@napanews.com or add a comment indicating you have an issue and our moderators will review the comment in question.
Search:
Web Search Powered
By Yahoo! Search
Napa Valley Register on Facebook
Copyright © 2009 Napa Valley Publishing, a member of Lee Enterprises, Inc.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy