Man gets 60 days for woman's death
Vehicular manslaughter charge also carries 3 years probation
By MARSHA DORGAN
Register Staff Writer
William McDonough will spend 60 days in Napa County jail for the traffic death of a 39-year-old pregnant Calistoga woman.
Although not charged with road rage, deputy district attorney Catherine Borsetto, who prosecuted the case, alluded it played a major role in Jennifer Haden’s March 2007 death.
McDonough, 48, was charged and pleaded no contest to misdemeanor vehicular manslaughter — non alcohol, non gross negligence. At his sentencing last week, Napa County Superior Court Judge Rodney Stone also ordered McDonough serve three years probation and perform community service.
Haden was killed in a three-car crash on Highway 29, south of Madison Avenue in Yountville. She was driving south on the highway. McDonough was headed north in his Nissan pickup. Where the highway narrows to one lane, McDonough attempted to pass a minivan, driven by Greg DeCaro, 56, of Calistoga.
According to Borsetto’s sentencing brief filed with the court, DeCaro said he honked his horn at McDonough when he made the unsafe pass. McDonough hit his brakes in front of DeCaro’s vehicle in an “act of spite,” Borsetto said in the court document.
McDonough’s braking, caused DeCaro to slam into the back of McDonough’s pickup, pushing him into oncoming traffic and slamming into the driver’s side door of Haden’s Toyota. Haden, who was about four months pregnant, died at the scene.
Witnesses told investigators that they did not see any reason for McDonough to slam on his brakes, and he was speeding and weaving in and out of traffic prior to the accident.
However, McDonough told probation officers in an interview before his sentencing that DeCaro was tailgating him and he was watching his rear-view mirror. He said when he resumed looking at the traffic in front of him, it was stopped and he had to slam on his brakes to avoid hitting a car. He denied speeding and weaving.
McDonough described Haden’s death as a “horrible accident,” according to the probation report.
He said he entered the no contest plea so not to have to put his family and victim’s family through a court trial. He also said in the report that “I didn’t want to fight with the victim’s family in court.”
The probation officer said she did not think McDonough took responsibility for his actions, adding he was “shocked DeCaro was not charged (with a crime) and he was.”
In a letter to Judge Stone, McDonough expressed his sorrow about Haden’s death and how he wanted to address her family earlier.
“I think about the victim all the time and all she is missing out on ... birthdays, motherhood,” McDonough wrote.
Victim impact statements written by Haden’s sister, Kelly Knapp, and friend Kristen Boyd, expressed their grief for the loss of someone very special and close to them. Both asked the court to hand down the maximum sentence, which is one year in county jail.
At the time of her death, Haden was a hostess at Mustard’s Grill on Highway 29, just north of Yountville.
All comments will be screened and may take several hours to be posted.
• Keep comments clear, concise and focused on the topic in the story.
• Comments exceeding 300 words will not be posted.
• Refrain from personal attacks, degrading comments or remarks that do not add to a constructive dialogue.
• Comments implying suspects in crime-related stories are guilty before they have been proven so in a court of law will be deleted.
• Do not post e-mail addresses or links except for pages on Napavalleyregister.com or government Web sites.
• Comments will not be edited - they will be approved or declined.
• Comments may be used in the print edition of the newspaper.
• If you feel a posted comment has violated our guidelines, please contact dross@napanews.com or bkennedy@napanews.com
For further information on the comment guidelines,
click here.
SouthNapa wrote on Aug 23, 2008 12:20 AM:
comment wrote on Aug 23, 2008 2:05 AM:
GregN. wrote on Aug 23, 2008 2:10 AM:
Ephemerol wrote on Aug 23, 2008 2:42 AM:
vercingetorex wrote on Aug 23, 2008 6:02 AM:
An absolute joke. Sleep well, Judge Stone.
"Justice" was not served by you. Not at all. "
Dirty Napkin wrote on Aug 23, 2008 6:11 AM:
ketama wrote on Aug 23, 2008 7:25 AM:
elb wrote on Aug 23, 2008 7:53 AM:
Who can read this story and pretend that they have never "punched it" to get around someone or become angry over being tailgated... (Now whether any of us would risk our own lives by slamming on the breaks so we can possibly be rear-ended is another issue...)
But my point is that we have all become frustrated and taken chances we shouldn't have probably taken while on the roadways. This story begs the question; "Why? Was it really worth the risk?"
This story here should serve to remind us all to slow down and be nice to one another on the road. Yes, to be nice, even, to the jerk that does something he probably shouldn't have done in the first place. "
nan03 wrote on Aug 23, 2008 8:12 AM:
Two Cents wrote on Aug 23, 2008 8:24 AM:
Demo Cracy wrote on Aug 23, 2008 8:34 AM:
amelia wrote on Aug 23, 2008 9:03 AM:
napablogger wrote on Aug 23, 2008 9:36 AM:
Once I made up my mind that I would never get mad again on the road, I found that it was easier to let things other drivers did that made me mad pass on by. Sometimes my wife will comment, like did you see that? and I will just ignore it. It ain't worth it. "
jmo wrote on Aug 23, 2008 9:36 AM:
I don't believe Mc Donough...hw was lieing to try and save his ..s. He should have "maned up"..not plead "no Contest".
I smell a wrongful death law suit coming.
I hope he sleeps well at night. "
amazed wrote on Aug 23, 2008 9:43 AM:
hog1 wrote on Aug 23, 2008 10:16 AM:
reason-ator wrote on Aug 23, 2008 10:40 AM:
In this PC world, stupid people are allowed to drive poorly. and then justify their lousy driving by claiming the other guy had "road rage", which by default supposedly makes the lousy driver a better person ? I'm starting to think there are people who get satisfaction from angering people by driving poorly.
The roads are there for us to share. They're not for us to compete on. If someone wants to risk his life to save a few seconds of his life, why not just let him have his way ?
If you have ten fingers, why do you have to share the biggest finger with everyone ? It's wrong that the horn-honker is getting off even more scot-free than the brake-slammer. "
kevin wrote on Aug 23, 2008 11:07 AM:
McDonough inability to control his vehicle (he locked up his brakes causing an uncontrolled skid into the oncoming traffic) is inexcusable and he deserves jail time for his actions. But I see MANY other drivers every day who have not mastered this same basic driving skill.
However there remains more unanswered questions. Why did the lead vehicle in front of McDonough suddenly slow down? Come to find out, he is DeCaro's friend and they were traveling together in separate vehicles. Did they not want McDonough to get between their vehicles? McDonough would not have known that when he was trying to merge between them. Was he trying to "punish" McDonough by suddenly slowing?
I was following these vehicles that day and I saw no traffic in front of the lead vehicle. The traffic light ahead was green. No dog ran across the road. In my opinion, there was no reason for the lead vehicle to suddenly slow down.
Road rage is a terrible thing. We all experience it. This tragic incident is a reminder that our actions have repercussions, sometimes far in excess of what we intend. "
me2you wrote on Aug 23, 2008 11:44 AM:
14obama wrote on Aug 23, 2008 1:56 PM:
crazylady680 wrote on Aug 23, 2008 2:08 PM:
mafi wrote on Aug 23, 2008 2:09 PM:
savenapa wrote on Aug 23, 2008 2:27 PM:
Winewoman wrote on Aug 23, 2008 2:45 PM:
i4aneye wrote on Aug 23, 2008 2:48 PM:
asahigo wrote on Aug 23, 2008 3:37 PM:
Suze wrote on Aug 23, 2008 5:47 PM:
hawkeye wrote on Aug 23, 2008 9:11 PM:
elb wrote on Aug 23, 2008 9:36 PM:
Maybe at those "Death Trap" locations, the city should post what I call "Since Signs" that tally the reality for the McDonogh's of the planet. Example:
Since 1975
Accidents: 256
Injuries: 220
Deaths: 98
Obviously the occasional roadside memorial isn't slowing people down so maybe a sign like this would serve to remind people that they need to slow down and play nice. "
jmo wrote on Aug 23, 2008 11:08 PM:
Wow!, not a bad idea. Are you listening CHP? "
Native74 wrote on Aug 25, 2008 8:38 AM:
Our local and regional enforcement need to take these calls seriously and not blow it off.
I pray for the family who lost the most from this accident that could have been easily avoided with patience. Something that many of us have seemed to have lost. "
realist2 wrote on Aug 25, 2008 9:59 AM:
My heart goes out to Jennifer's family. I can not imagine losing my daughter in such a senseless manner. 60 days is an insult to humanity. "
mafi wrote on Aug 26, 2008 8:16 AM:
mom4melia wrote on Aug 26, 2008 10:45 AM:
My sis was driving on highway 12. The CHP is really cracking down on that highway (Suisun).
She had this guy behind her pushing her so she would get over only for another car to be in his way. So he would get back behinnd sis and push her again. She had her baby in the back and he was making her nervous. She punched it to get over and away from him.
Guess who got the ticket? And guess what the CHP told sis when she told him why she punched it to get in a safe spot?
He told her she could have simply tapped on the brakes.
After reading this story, I'm more furious than I was before.
Unfreakinbelievable! "
napan007 wrote on Aug 26, 2008 11:33 AM:
There is no need for people to choose to get angry with one another. We all move at different speeds in life as well as in our cars and that's why passing laws and guidelines exist so we can continue our chosen speeds without impeding the flow of traffic. And cops are around to make sure we're not going TOO fast or slow. We don't need to police each other.
Be safe and smart, people! "
Oldies2 wrote on Sep 5, 2008 10:21 AM:
To everyones sorrow, it takes the death of a young woman to draw attention to the fact,no one's going to help you on the road.
I called for help and I was told to come to the Hwy.Patrol Monday and make out a complaint. This was on a Saturday on Hwy. 29. That helps alot!!! "