NVR Logo
Improved marks for Napa schools
State academic exams beat average; Mt. George leads pack
Tuesday, August 19, 2008
Save and Share Share
Napa students are above average when it comes to English, math, science and history.

That’s the bottom line in the results of the most recent California Standards Tests, released last week.
Summaries of California Standards Tests — the most heavily weighted component of a series of Standardized Testing and Reporting (STAR) tests — reveal that proficiency rates of Napa Valley Unified School District students surpass state averages by more than 4 percent in English, nearly 3 percent in history, one point in math and almost four points in science.

“Our first look at our results is very encouraging. ... We see growth in so many areas,” said Elena Toscano, NVUSD assistant superintendent of instruction. NVUSD’s English scores are up from last year for all English learners, socio-economically disadvantaged students and special education students, she said.
As in the 2006-07 school year, Mt. George Elementary School had the highest overall CST scores in the district, followed by Vichy Elementary School.

Janine Burt, principal of Mt. George, said that its class sizes are comparable to other schools throughout the district, with about 20 students per teacher from kindergarten to third grade and approximately 30 students per teacher for its higher grades. Approximately 7 percent of Mt. George’s 190 students are English learners, she said.
Burt identified several factors for Mt. George’s high scores, including collaboration between teachers, parents and staff, a high level of parental involvement and becoming an International Baccalaureate candidate school in 2007.

“It’s a huge benefit that we are a small school, because we can have that personal touch. ... But all the schools in the district work very hard, do great things and every school has unique programs and features,” she said. “Sometimes, achievement can be measured in lots of ways and this is only one measure.”

Gaining ground

Harvest Middle School showed a marked improvement in the 2007-08 California Standards Tests, gaining five percentage points from the previous year for students performing at proficient and advanced levels in math, according to the California Department of Education.

In algebra, the school saw a 12 percentage point gain from the previous year’s CST score — a jump from 33 to nearly 45 percent of tested students performing at proficient and advanced levels.

“I was delighted,” said Linda Beckstrom, principal of Harvest Middle School. “When I checked the scores, I basically did a happy dance. Then we shared them with our teachers and they were equally delighted.”

In addition to the hard work of teachers and students, Beckstrom credited the school’s introduction of a supplementary math program from Folsom-based Pacent Learning Solutions in the middle of last year.

Harvest’s recent success comes on the heels of the California Board of Education’s recent decision to test all eighth-grade California students in algebra by the fall of 2011, forcing many of the state’s school districts to modify their curriculum accordingly.

Toscano said in recent years, NVUSD teachers began teaching age-appropriate “algebraic thinking” curriculum to younger students, preparing them for the course before they entered the eighth grade. Still, she said, the mandate will present substantial funding and staffing challenges.

NVUSD Superintendent John Glaser said another of the district’s ongoing challenges includes narrowing the so-called “achievement gap” — a term describing discrepancies between the lower scores of the English learner population and the higher scores of their native English-speaking counterparts.  

Glaser called high-stakes accountability mandates “a double-edged sword.” New mandates present more funding challenges at a time when Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger’s proposed budget would reduce the district’s funding by about $5 million next year. Still, Glaser said, “it’s forcing us to own the success of our neediest students and our staff are doing that with increasing effectiveness.”

While NVUSD’s summary scores are above state averages, Toscano said the latest STAR results “indicate a decrease in proficient (and) advanced math scores after fifth grade. So we are concentrating on support for middle and high schools for sixth grade and up, including Algebra I.”

Last year, NVUSD’s summary test averages beat the state’s by four percentage points in English, five percentage points in history, three percentage points in math and more than three percentage points in science.

Administered annually to students from second to 11th grade, STAR tests reflect results of California Standards Tests, California Alternative Performance Assessments, California Achievement Tests, Standards-based Tests in Spanish, California Modified Assessments and Aprenda Tests.
21 comment(s)

steph wrote on Aug 19, 2008 6:33 AM:

" Nice job to all the hard working students and parents, and most of all, the teachers and administrators at the schools. "

marine1/1 wrote on Aug 19, 2008 8:46 AM:

" Good job to all the hard working teachers,parents and students. Keep up the good work!!!! "

musikluvr wrote on Aug 19, 2008 9:03 AM:

" This is dismal. Just above average is unsatisfactory! We live in one of the most beautiful areas in the state with very little crime and no innercity negativities, yet our schools only do just above average? Our kids are the best, our living conditions are the best - why aren't our schools the best? Why are our kids just average in educational performance? "

kittyamma wrote on Aug 19, 2008 9:11 AM:

" awesome job!!!!!! thank you teachers "

amazed wrote on Aug 19, 2008 9:18 AM:

" But there's no connection between the number of English learners and test scores, right? By the way, how is someone an "English learner" when the curriculum is presented in Spanish? "

C'mon reg get it right wrote on Aug 19, 2008 10:11 AM:

" musikluvr "Why are our kids just average in educational performance?"
Scores are highly correlated to parental involvement. Yes our schools suffer from many woes but something that we share with schools in other parts of the state are parents that for many reasons can not put time into their childs academic life. It's true for English learners as well. Show me an involved parent and I'll show you a good student. "

kbf wrote on Aug 19, 2008 10:13 AM:

" amazed- good point. They didn't say what the schools scores were that teach part in english and part in spanish like Napa Valley Language Academy. I know Mt.George and Vichy have a lot of parent involvement and the english learner schools maybe don't,. "

elb wrote on Aug 19, 2008 10:25 AM:

" I'm still trying to figure out how we cranked out all those Einstein's of the past with only a piece of chalk and a slate board, oh and probably a Bible, yet now we have every fan-dangled program and textbook and teaching technique imaginable and we're barely cranking out a mediocre group of cells.

They call this evolution? "

Grits wrote on Aug 19, 2008 11:29 AM:

" Interesting point, elb! Reminded me of my grandmother, who taught second grade to every resident in her small town for generations, and she told me all a really good teacher needed was a chalkboard and some chalk - and a paddle! "

steph wrote on Aug 19, 2008 11:53 AM:

" elb--That's a pretty interesting conclusion, that we "cranked out all those Einsteins of the past". You sure about that? What was the average highest level of education per American back in the day? I'm not sure I agree with your starting assumption.
The problem today is that education is compulsory, and not seen by many as the privilege that it is. It's free babysitting for many. Also we're importing many families who do not understand our educational system here, as they were not well-educated in their homelands. Some take advantage of the privilege and insist that their children succeed in school, some just don't really know how, and some abuse the privilege with disastrous results seen in the schools and for their individual children.

Back in the day, children were better behaved, too, and also education was less important in the attainment of middle-class status,so standards were not as high. Back in the day, we didn't have as much testing, so who knew how the schools were doing?

I'm glad to see Dr. Glaser admitting that standardized testing, though posing many challenges, actually improves education. Once schools are held accountable for outcomes, methods improve and ALL students get better educations--not just those who were lucky to be born to conscientious parents of the upper classes. Even students who may be reluctant will hopefully be grateful some day to the teachers and counselors and principals who tried VERY hard every imaginable way to get the kids to take in the education they'll need to be as successful as possible.

Congrats to the teachers--your hard work is visible for all to see. Napa schools have AWESOME teachers! "

winemd wrote on Aug 19, 2008 1:28 PM:

" I am a parent at Napa Valley Language Academy, so I can speak to the issue of teaching in Spanish. NVLA has made dramatic improvements in API and in AYP, although we are still in Program Improvement. The students start kindergarten with 80% of their day in Spanish, and the % of English increases with every grade to 60 or 65% English in 6th (I think my numbers are right). For some time period during the day (it varies by grade level), Spanish speakers go to English Language development time while English speakers have Spanish Language Development. I knew this would be a good model for my English speaking children to learn a second language fluently. The difference for the Spanish speaking children is that many of them don't have a solid foundation in their native language. My daughter could count to ten in Spanish by kindergarten (thank you Sesame Street), and some of her Spanish speaking peers could not, much less in English. So they end up learning both simultaneously.
Part of the difficulty with how the testing is scored has to do with English proficiency. A person who speaks another language is classified as an English learner, and their test scores are naturally not proficient in English. When they learn enough English to be proficient, they are reclassified, and no longer a part of the subgroup. So the English learner subgroup (if that is a significant population at a school), is always the students who are not yet proficient, so they don't test at proficient levels. At NVLA, the Hispanic population met proficiency criteria, but English learners didn't, which makes sense, by definition. I also notice the % proficent goes up by grade level. 6th grade has more proficent students than second grade does, which also makes sense. "

spectator wrote on Aug 19, 2008 2:15 PM:

" Actually if you read the printed version of this story you will see that the schools all have been given their own scores and I know that NVLA compared to other similar demographic schools scored the highest. Felicidades NVLA!!! Dos Idiomas, Un Corazón!! You are the best. "

amazed wrote on Aug 19, 2008 2:45 PM:

" "If that is a significant population at school," winemd? For crying out loud, there are more assignments handed out in Spanish at Silverado Middle School, for example, than in English. "

winemd wrote on Aug 19, 2008 4:22 PM:

" Not all of the elementary schools have a significant population that is Hispanic, or low income, or English learners. The state only counts subgroups of significant populations. I don't know about middle schools (not quite there yet). If you look at the scores in detail, you can find out what subroups are significant in each school. "

winemd wrote on Aug 19, 2008 4:58 PM:

" I would also like to comment about parent involvement. All families are supposed to volunteer for one hour per month at NVLA. For many families it is very difficult to do this, since all of the adults in the house work during the day. We started last year having "Power Hour Volunteer night", which is one night a month where parents can come and volunteer with small tasks like cutting and folding and stapling. This has been great, because it gives parents a chance to participate, but not feel like they are going to be asked to chair a committee. Everyone, no matter what language they speak, can help. The parent group provides pizza, and we all get to know each other better, adults and students. It is less intimidating than a "meeting" so parents speak to each other about their concerns. Research shows that parental involvement results in benefits for students, teachers, and the parents. Many parents gain confidence in themselves and the school by being involved. The schools have less money this year, so there are plenty of tasks parents can do to save the school money. In this economy, parents have less money to give sot they can give their time to the school. A win-win! "

funnyme wrote on Aug 19, 2008 7:18 PM:

" Grits,
Check out Angelina Gervasio's column (Opinion/Columnists/Not your average kid), you'll love what she has to say about paddles! "

steph wrote on Aug 19, 2008 7:23 PM:

" It's going to be another awesome year at Napa High. My kids are coming home with stories about their teachers that make ME want to go back to high school. The teachers are very engaged and humorous and eager to have the students learn.

We are so blessed to have such good schools for our children. "

pharper wrote on Aug 19, 2008 7:33 PM:

" I think it's funny that someone commented that there was perhaps less involvement at schools with primarily Hispanic kids. My elementary school was about 80% Hispanic (Carneros School) and the parents that show up to PTA meetings and Family Fun Days and other school activities are about 95% Hispanic. Seeing as how I am at the school watching kids while their parents are in the PTA meeting every time there is one, it amazes me how anyone could assume that Hispanic parents are less involved than white parents, when not only is it blatantly untrue, but Hispanic parents (in my personal experience; I cannot speak for other schools) are perhaps more involved. "

justnana wrote on Aug 19, 2008 8:55 PM:

" Read the stats on Pueblo Vista vs. Pueblo Vista Alternative... English: 32.4 vs 60, Math: 40.7 vs 70.3, Science 24.1 vs 75. Both schools share a campus and both have dedicated qualified teachers. Parental involvement certainly. Alternative parents are by definition more involved. That is one of the basic premises of "alternative" schools. In addition, English learners are far in the majority at the traditional PV. My friend had to request that the parent handouts given to her child be in English because she kept getting everything in Spanish. Everyone assumes that Vichy and Mt.George will be on top...they don't have the same population as Shearer, McPherson, Pueblo Vista etc. I don't see how anyone cannot see that this is clearly the reason some schools score higher than others. "

noblindershere wrote on Aug 19, 2008 9:53 PM:

" musikluvr, what does living in a beautiful area have to do with test results? Parental involvement and parent attitude toward education is the primary factor here. I taught in this district for years and the attitude of the parents for the most part was disrespectful at the high school level. The excuses they would come up with for their child, the many times they would pull their child out of school, the lack of respect for teachers was unbelievable. I would say that this came from white, middle/working class families that probably never left Napa. My hispanic and white upper class parents were the ones that were the most responsive. Great kids maybe, great parents...not so much. I'm a parent of a Vichy student and now more than ever it is time for all parents to spend atleast four hours a month in their childs classroom. Our schools need money yes, but more importantly they need the man power to make local education what it should be, number one. Stop beating down public education if you don't have any recent personal experience with it. I would much rather send my child to Vichy than to St. A's, they have 36 kids in the 2008-09 kidergarten class and only a part time aid... NO THANKS My most respectful, successful and outgoing students came from households of varying backgrounds, but one thing they all had in common were parents that respected the true value of a good education that is offered in the NVUSD. The most successful students that I had and that I read about in the paper were educated through the NVUSD, just read about one of them today-Chrissy Elles living in Bolivia. Amazing kid...amazing parents. "

jimmie wrote on Aug 20, 2008 9:55 PM:

" Ms. Burt is, hands down, a great principal. From what I've seen so far in K and 1st grades, Mt. George definitely does NOT have any emphasis on technololgy, it is good, old-fashioned learning. The emphasis at Mt. George is on being a community and not letting any kids fall between the cracks and Ms. Burt, in her loving way, leads the agenda. Mt. George is so lucky to have her! "

Comment guidelines
All comments will be screened and may take several hours to be posted.
• Keep comments clear, concise and focused on the topic in the story.
• Comments exceeding 300 words will not be posted.
• Refrain from personal attacks, degrading comments or remarks that do not add to a constructive dialogue.
• Comments implying suspects in crime-related stories are guilty before they have been proven so in a court of law will be deleted.
• Do not post e-mail addresses or links except for pages on Napavalleyregister.com or government Web sites.
• Comments will not be edited - they will be approved or declined.
• Comments may be used in the print edition of the newspaper.
• If you feel a posted comment has violated our guidelines, please contact dross@napanews.com or bkennedy@napanews.com
For further information on the comment guidelines, click here.
Search:
Advanced searchWeb Search Powered By Yahoo! Search
Copyright © 2008 Napa Valley Publishing, a member of Lee Enterprises, Inc.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy