NVR Logo
The Napa Valley-Michoacan connection
Families work in California, revitalize native region
Sunday, July 13, 2008
Save and Share Share
Following the tiled aisle to the altar of a century-old adobe church, Tony Herrera and Rosario Gonzalez walked the same path underneath the same wooden roof as Rosario’s parents had more than 40 years ago.

Herrera and Gonzalez live in Napa, but exchanged vows in El Llano, Mexico, where they and many other Napans retain strong ties.
Just 10 years ago, the walls of El Llano’s quaint church were crumbling, and tiles fell from the ceiling. But the Herreras and many other families who came to the United States from El Llano have donated thousands of dollars to renovate the church.

Through fundraisers fueled by homemade tamales and a strong current of hometown pride, these families have helped replace red roof tiles, reinforce walls and adorn the church’s decade-old altar with banisters. A fresh coat of paint gives the church a brilliant glow.
The church is a symbol of the links between Napa and El Llano, a town about the size of Yountville located in the vast Mexican state of Michoacan.

Herrera works for Swanson Vineyards and Winery in Oakville, while Gonzalez raises their 2-year-old daughter.
“When you’re raised there your dream is to go back home and get married in the church — to walk around the plaza,” said Rolando Herrera, Tony’s older brother and the owner of Mi Sueno Winery in Napa. “The whole town comes together around these events. That’s the beauty. Everybody is welcomed.”

International ties

Since 1942, when the United States’ Bracero Program began luring workers north of the border, more than half of El Llano’s population of 4,500 have emigrated to the U.S. Many live in the Napa Valley. The story is similar in other Michoacan towns: El Capricho, Chavinda, Patzimaro, Churintzio, Atacheo, Zamora, Indaparapeo and Morelia.

Napa Valley is home to some 30,000 people of Mexican descent, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. Frances Ortiz-Chavez, a Napa Valley Unified School District board member who is a member of the El Capricho Association of Napa, said her guess is that the majority of Mexican immigrants come from Michoacan.

They are winemakers, vineyard and cellar workers, office workers, business owners and students at Napa, Vintage, St. Helena or Calistoga high schools. A vineyard in St. Helena is named for the Michoacan town of Patzimaro, because the majority of the winery staff has roots there.

For more than 25 years, donations from the Napa Valley have poured into El Llano for restoration and beautification projects, and for the elaborate December fiestas that reunite Napa Valley families with their friends and relatives.

The family ties, and the financial ties, are only growing.

Spring of hope

On a sunny day in Patzimaro in December 2007, about an hour east of El Llano, a group of men — locals and wine industry workers from the Napa Valley — linger over photographs of themselves from the 1960s. In the photos they are kids, crouching by a natural spring near the center of town.

The spring is now the focus of Club Patzimaro, a group of Napa Valley and Sonoma residents looking to improve ties between Mexico and the U.S.

Club Patzimaro’s current project is to create a filtration system for sewage that flows directly into a nearby stream used to irrigate farmland. The stream originates from a natural spring that overflows from an 180-year-old cement pool, “El Ojo de Agua de las Fuentes.”

Rigo Castillo, the club president, says that through donations and hard work, the water from the stream will improve.

“It’s a great priority because we don’t want sewage to contaminate the water used for irrigation,” said Castillo, who works for Gallo Vineyards in Sonoma County.

Castillo said several other improvement projects are in the works. “We are inviting people from Patzimaro to work together on projects that we may create in the future,” he said.

Rebuilding in Mexico

These projects help Napa Valley’s immigrant families stay connected to their hometowns. Their efforts are part of a huge transfer of funds from workers in the United States to relatives in countries around the world.

According to the International Fund for Agricultural Development, an arm of the United Nations, immigrants from around the world — many in the United States — sent some $300 billion to their countries of origin in 2006.

The IFAD estimates that $68 billion a year goes to Latin America and the Caribbean, with more than $24 billion going to Mexico.

According to a separate report from the Migration Policy Institute, a non-partisan think tank in Washington, D.C., in 2004 so-called remittance money sent to Michoacan formed 14 percent of the gross domestic product of that Mexican state of nearly 4 million inhabitants.

Migrants’ paychecks help feed and clothe their families and pay other living expenses, as well as providing a few luxuries that Americans would otherwise take for granted, like filtered water.

Jesus Valenci Alvarez is the parish priest of Parroquia del Sagrado Corazon, or Sacred Heart Parish, in El Llano. The town, he said, is “an agricultural community. The only ones who stay here cultivate the land. There isn’t a lot of business. It is a community only hoping for those who go to the United States to send money for them to survive.”

Transformation

After the wedding ceremony, a mariachi band led Herrera and Gonzalez through a courtyard and past a newer church — which celebrated its 25th anniversary in 2007 and was built largely with money earned in the United States.

They strolled hand in hand into the paved street along the plaza to the yellow dance hall. Much of the ground they walked on had been altered and improved by the El Llano natives who call the Napa Valley home.
18 comment(s)

NVR Brian Kennedy wrote on Jul 13, 2008 12:50 AM:

" A note on video load times. If your internet connection is slow you will have some buffering. Just hit pause on the video and wait for the gray load bar to get going. Web video will always be a struggle between quality and load time, and in this case I think we have a happy medium. "

napablogger wrote on Jul 13, 2008 1:48 AM:

" fascinating story, I had heard that many of our vineyard workers were from the same town in Mexico. It makes it much more personal to see the town that they come from. Also now we know why so many want to take long vacations in December, and the background of the whole school dispute here. "

JimClark wrote on Jul 13, 2008 5:06 AM:

" And one wonders why the economy is tanking? "

Reality Check wrote on Jul 13, 2008 7:12 AM:

" Nice story, but it does leave you wondering why the Mexican economy can't care for itself. Like Cuba, Mexico's number one source of income is money sent from the United States; even more than the sale of oil. The ability to send so much cash south is of course due in a large part through the inane generosity of our middle class that somehow feels the altruistic urge to offset their living expenses here in Napa through wanton entitlements. How long can the "bathtub" of our own finances withstand having the drain left open? "

locust55 wrote on Jul 13, 2008 7:19 AM:

" Beautifully put together story with the video and sound. wow! "

mamyt wrote on Jul 13, 2008 10:20 AM:

" When I read some of the comments of the bloggers I just want to cry. Is it possible that so many people are so full of fear and hate. There are people on here who seem to be obsessed with blaming everything they are unhappy about on some one else. If you are unhappy then start making changes that will allow you to be happier. Complaining alone is not a solution it's simply an attempt to commiserate with other sad people. "

mykdgirl54 wrote on Jul 13, 2008 11:05 AM:

" Im with Jimclark & Reality Check on this one...I think it's fabulous that she was able to realize her dream of getting married in that church. However, take note in the words she used " to go HOME" that's the Main problem. Immigrants many years ago, like those coming into ellis island, as soon as they reached that fateful city, they felt like they were HOME and they viewed America as their "new" home. Today's immigrants tend to view this county as a "transition" or a "tool" to achieve what they want and need in their "real" home.

How about giving some of those dollars to rebuilding the churches here? It's the same principle. Many feel honored to be able to give back to the small town they grew up in, and it warrants much respect from those that still live in that community also. I don't see why that same idea can't be translated to the towns they work and live in NOW! i.e. Yountville, Oakville, Napa, etc. Don't they understand the same honor & respect will follow? "

lahrgsp wrote on Jul 13, 2008 12:45 PM:

" My son's Dad is from there, well actually he is there now.
Nice to see what it looks like. "

kbf wrote on Jul 13, 2008 8:51 PM:

" mammy, It is not hate it is people getting real tired of haveing immigrants and illegal immigrants from Mexico coming here taking and all they want is osmeeday to go HOME. We had a guy put in new windows in our house he is legal and he sends money home every month so his brother can build a house for him and his family to go HOME to. If you want to be in this country, come legally and be part of us. You can still have your heritage, but learn to speak english and not want everything handed to you. "

greyhoundgirl wrote on Jul 13, 2008 9:05 PM:

" I'm with you mykdgirl. There will always be cultural strains when a "minority" culture, which is now the majority, refuses to integrate into the country that gives (yes gives) them everything they need to live a comfortable, healthy life. I don't think anyone is in fear or in hate of this culture. We'd just like to see some integration and not such a obvious lack of interest in this new "home" land. You have to give back when you take. "

JAGONZALEZ wrote on Jul 13, 2008 10:32 PM:

" Napa is my home but I am from El Llano and very proud of what we've accomplished here in Napa Valley. Some people just don't understand the struggle and values that we work for and live by. I'm happy to see some recognition. Gotta love it! "

Paddy wrote on Jul 14, 2008 9:25 AM:

" If these workers kept more of their money and sent less 'home' than maybe I wouldn't have to pay for subsidized, low-income housing and they would be able to afford insurance and not rely on emergency rooms.

Is it possible that if this money stayed in this country there would be more of an attempt to assimilate and not count the days until their return home after gleaning all they could from us? "

leavintown wrote on Jul 15, 2008 4:24 PM:

" I have a boat that I have to pay a Personal Property tax on. Give me a break. I have already paid taxes on it when I bought it, but they are looking to get more money out me. Why don't they do the same to these people that send money to other countries. Tax the livin daylights out of them if they decide to send the money out of the country and not spend it on American goods. Make them pay. I get penalized more money by taking out my 401K and spending it here in America than someone does for taking the money out of the country. WHAT A JOKE!!!!!!!!!!!!! "

leavintown wrote on Jul 15, 2008 4:29 PM:

" If just California taxed all the money going out of the state, WE WOULD OF NOT HAD TO LAY OFF ANY TEACHERS!!!!!! Something to think of Arnold. Calyfornya would have as many teachers out of work now. "

myword wrote on Jul 17, 2008 6:58 PM:

" I think someone just had a great idea...tax the money being shipped out of this country! Our tax dollars are paying for the Mexicans' education, subsidized housing, and medical; many are driving around with no driver's license (cheating the state!) and without insurance (cheating all those that are paying), and then taking their money to send "home". If "home" (Mexico) is that important, be my guest and return! What about "home" USA where they want all the benefits of a good life, yet refuse to learn the language, do what it takes to become legal, and pay for the benefits like the rest of us American citizens. And another thought.... If they are here, isn't this home? They aren't giving back to this "home", this community where they take and do not give. And not only take, but then send it out of our country. I imagine that the featured families are legal,...but seems they are speaking for many who are living here that are most likely illegal and draining our country of our resources to send back to Mexico. That is what I am sick of! "

sv wrote on Jul 19, 2008 6:58 AM:

" Please stop with the money issue, I am impressed how these families work and with the little money they make they still manage to send money to their home town. Have you really taken notice that they work harder at their jobs and get paid minimum wage and the wineries they work for here in the Napa
Valley hesitate to give them a raise every year? That IS why they can't afford to pay rent, medical ins because the winery they work for does not pay them what they should be getting paid. AND on top of that Napa Valley real estate agents took FULL advantage of these people when they DID try getting out of low income housing and BUY their own home only to have to LOSE it due to dishonest agents and now they have to go back again to low income housing. You complainers, when you go apply for a job the person hiring you automatically knows you NEED to make a decent wage to provide for yourself and your family, that's not what is taken in consideration when these men and women go apply for a job here in the Napa Valley. They are still happy after all this and their town reflects that happiness. "

notz wrote on Aug 12, 2008 7:56 PM:

" Good write-up. It's unfortunate that a positive story generates so many negative responses. Oh well. Keep up the good work NVR. "

napa89 wrote on Sep 20, 2008 10:49 AM:

" ok fine what about sending all the immigrants and illegal people back to mexico because "they are taking others jobs and money" so what are you going to do all the field work? if they dont do it who is? you? and besides all of you should go back to your countries because remember you or your families were once immigrants too! unless you are native Americans. "NAPA VALLEY" is what it is because all the mexicans are the ones to work the fields and pick the grapes and all that when all you people are enjoying the wine. and plus at least us mexican care about our families and work for something. unlike other selfish people that only care for them self's. oh and as far a taxes the imigrants still pay taxes on what they buy. even though they dont make much but the little they make they earn it with hard work. "

Comment guidelines
All comments will be screened and may take several hours to be posted.
• Keep comments clear, concise and focused on the topic in the story.
• Comments exceeding 300 words will not be posted.
• Refrain from personal attacks, degrading comments or remarks that do not add to a constructive dialogue.
• Comments implying suspects in crime-related stories are guilty before they have been proven so in a court of law will be deleted.
• Do not post e-mail addresses or links except for pages on Napavalleyregister.com or government Web sites.
• Comments will not be edited - they will be approved or declined.
• Comments may be used in the print edition of the newspaper.
• If you feel a posted comment has violated our guidelines, please contact dross@napanews.com or bkennedy@napanews.com
For further information on the comment guidelines, click here.
Search:
Advanced searchWeb Search Powered By Yahoo! Search
Copyright © 2009 Napa Valley Publishing, a member of Lee Enterprises, Inc.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy