NVR Logo
Air conditioning, water planning and a closing window
Sunday, May 18, 2008
Save and Share Share
When Willis Carrier patented the air conditioner in 1906 he probably didn’t realize that he had just introduced a sea-change in urban-planning: would Miami, Phoenix or Las Vegas be what they are today without the ability to cool indoor air? The air conditioner was one simple innovation that radically- and rapidly- altered the options for human habitation.

An insight I gained from a presentation by the Southern Nevada Water Authority (SNWA) at the American Planning Association’s conference in Las Vegas was that, contrary to popular belief, the biggest water expenditure on the Vegas Strip is not the dancing fountains or faux Venetian canals. In fact The Strip’s principle users of non-recyclable water are the resorts’ vast air conditioning systems.   
 

More significant than that, the biggest overall water-consumer in Las Vegas isn’t on The Strip at all, but is rather found in the form of ornamental lawns used in residential and retail developments.
 

Las Vegas has flourished in a climate that one ordinarily couldn’t grow a tomato in. The city’s story is a tenacious example of urban development over the last century or so. Thanks to Mr. Carrier’s invention, the Chicago mafia and several dauntless developers, a rail stop in the Mojave Desert with a meager water apportionment from the Colorado River became a worldwide entertainment destination and home to a half- million people.
Nature though, is having her say:  During the last decade, 4.5 trillion gallons have been extracted but not replenished from Lake Mead- Las Vegas’ principle water source. In the end, water may what ultimately curtails Las Vegas’ remarkable growth.

   

Rapid suburban development brought thousands of new single-family homes and retail stores with green decorative lawns and few shade trees to an environment with less than four-and- a- half inches of rain per year, and average peak temperatures of 110 degrees. Currently, outdoor residential and retail uses consume about two-thirds of the city’s water. Ornamental turf draws 73 gallons-per- lawn-foot each year- a consumption rate that would require ten feet of yearly rainfall to sustain.

As a result, city planners are rapidly adapting water conservation measures that have been surprisingly simple and effective. By using “carrots and sticks” and an ambitious outreach program, the SNWA has converted 100 million square feet of decorative lawn turf into a water conserving uses, and has reduced overall water consumption from 350 gallons per capita per day to 260 gallons per capita per day.

A “carrot” that the water authority uses is a rebate in the amount of $1.50 per square foot of lawn that business and residential consumers replace with water-efficient landscaping; a “stick” has been the $400,000 in fines that they have collected from water restriction violators in just one year alone.

Lawn designs are now required to be both smaller and substantively covered by native plants that are well-suited to the dry climate. This design requirement has, according to SNWA, reduced the water demand from the aforementioned 73 gallons per lawn-foot per year, to just 17 gallons per lawn-foot/year.  

For larger public uses, vast swaths of decorative lawn areas have been converted from turf to desert landscaping with minimal-to-no water demands. In recent years 52 school lawns and twenty million square feet of golf course turf has been converted to desert landscaping. City public restrooms have been installing waterless urinals and new homes are being built with low-flow toilets and high water efficiency-rated plumbing fixtures.

Conservation alone is not the answer- the SNWA is getting ready to spend between $172 million to $206 million in order to build a new reservoir near the Mexican border - but conservation is a huge component of the water planning equation and, increasingly, it’s an indispensable one.   

 

Obviously, Napa Valley isn’t Las Vegas, but we can probably draw a few parallels. Although not situated in the middle of a vast desert, we do have a lush-agricultural preserve on the floor of a valley otherwise surrounded by dry hills. Between local reservoirs, wells, and our share of the state water project, the Valley has increasing demand and a finite number of replenish-able water sources.

 

Each new proposal necessarily runs a gauntlet of water considerations. I think of a recent commercial project before the American Canyon commission when we required the developer to lay down recycled water infrastructure -“purple pipe”-at the start of construction, rather than the unspecified time in the future that he was asking for. Although creating a steeper initial cost that the developer understandably hoped to avoid, the commitment to water conservation in our city planning is absolute, and is being enforced at all opportunities.  Drought resistant landscaping, storm water runoffs, and low-flow appliances have also now become staples in every project application that I have seen in the last three years.

 

We’re entering a new conservation mindset- the era of half-measures is over. While a debate can be had about the size of our population, incorporating conservation and sustainability at the nascent planning stages at least addresses the important reality that the conspicuous-consumption party is over. The conservationist argument has always been to use an ounce of prevention today to avoid a pound of cure tomorrow. Our window on being able to do that may be very close to closed however: high fuel prices and a new round of water-rationing across the nation this summer are the canaries in the coalmine for the non-sustainable growth mindset. 
4 comment(s)

kevin wrote on May 16, 2008 7:17 PM:

" People used to move to the southwest to get away from alergens. With all the landscaping, I have read, they now have levels that approach the ones we are subjected to. I would like to know what air conditioning has to do with water use? "

LMW wrote on May 16, 2008 11:59 PM:

" Matt you seem to be on target with my issues here in AC. Seek Main St Parks need for water, highs and lows are not cuttin it... landscape architect is not solution either, its common sense

Fixing it before we see another.... "

matt@newspeak wrote on May 19, 2008 4:03 PM:

" Thanks LMW- yes, there's no one single solution to water planning but having conservation engineered into the system is a big part of our future and its been really interesting to learn about it from a 'hands-on' perspective.

Landscaping helps a great deal b/c green spaces w/ drought resitant plants provide shade and consume a lot less water than just open greenery- such as lawns.

BTW- I saw the first detailed overview of the Am Can High School at the economic summit last Friday- its really impressive- it will set a whole new standard for school construction in terms of both "green", sustainable engineering (geo-thermal heating/cooling, solar power, water conservation, recycled materials), but also innovations such as "learning communities"- breaking up a big school into smaller communities to reduce class size. Fascinating stuff we can be proud of.

Kevin- the point about air conditioning was to illustrate that water consumption is most often through the everyday, non-spectacular things we rely on. In Vegas, for example, many people are surprised to realize its not the big water shows that use up non-reclaimable water, but rather the omni-present air conditioners and green lawns.

I also think Carrier's invention represents our different mindset today than 100 years ago. Last century development was pretty much a matter of- as soon as we can build somewhere- no matter how impractical, we should; today- from water planning, to housing, to traffic, to open space and ag land the question is- we know we can do it, but should we?

Thanks -MP "

LMW wrote on May 19, 2008 4:25 PM:

" I can't wait for my sons to attend the New High School, in the mean time advocating for buildgreenschools should assist with educating all, for the future of the rest of our schools throughout the county.

The new high school looks wonderful.. "

Comment guidelines
All comments will be screened and may take several hours to be posted.
• Keep comments clear, concise and focused on the topic in the story.
• Comments exceeding 300 words will not be posted.
• Refrain from personal attacks, degrading comments or remarks that do not add to a constructive dialogue.
• Comments implying suspects in crime-related stories are guilty before they have been proven so in a court of law will be deleted.
• Do not post e-mail addresses or links except for pages on Napavalleyregister.com or government Web sites.
• Comments will not be edited - they will be approved or declined.
• Comments may be used in the print edition of the newspaper.
• If you feel a posted comment has violated our guidelines, please contact dross@napanews.com or bkennedy@napanews.com
For further information on the comment guidelines, click here.
Search:
Advanced searchWeb Search Powered By Yahoo! Search
Copyright © 2008 Napa Valley Publishing, a member of Lee Enterprises, Inc.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy