NVR Logo
Woman's account of pit bull attack
Owners take full responsibility
Wednesday, April 30, 2008
Save and Share Share
A Napa woman said she feared for her life on Sunday evening while trying to protect her two small dogs from being attacked by four pit bulls.

“I thought my dogs were going to be eaten, and the pit bulls were going eat me to get to them,” Valerie Valentine told the Register on Monday afternoon. Valentine was bitten in the attack.
“The San Francisco dog mauling was going through my mind,” she said. In January 2001, San Francisco resident Diane Whipple, 33, was killed by two 120-pound Presa Canario dogs belonging to her neighbors in an apartment building in Pacific Heights.

Valentine said Sunday’s pit bull attack was the most terrifying thing that ever happened to her.
“I just knew I had to protect my dogs. They are my babies,” Valentine said, referring to Happy, a 9-pound rat terrier mix and Woody, a 6-pound toy poodle mix.

Valentine suffered bite wounds to her hands. She went to the hospital for a tetanus shot, but said her wound did not require stitches.
Desiree Biale and Timothy Lotton, who live at separate residences on the same property in the 1600 block of East Avenue, both own two of the pit bulls.

Biale and Lotton both said they were concerned for the victims and took responsibility for their dogs’ actions.

Evening walk

Valentine, who lives on Third Street, east of Soscol Avenue, said was walking Happy and Woody on their leashes.

“We were coming back from our evening walk. My puppies were looking forward to their chicken dinner,” Valentine said.

“I just started to cross the railroad tracks when I saw the four pit bulls. They were really big. It was strange. They were not growling and at that point didn’t look that aggressive. It was like they were marching toward me — panting. It was crazy. I have never seen an animal act that way.”

When the dogs charged at her, Valentine was able to pick up Woody and hold him over her head.

“The pit bulls were jumping on me trying to get at him. That’s when my hands got bitten. They had me pinned against the fence,” she said. Woody made it through the attack, she said.

Meanwhile, Happy wasn’t as lucky.

“He broke away from me and I started yelling, ‘run Happy, run’, while I am also screaming for help,” Valentine said.

Happy made his dash to escape the pit bulls, but unfortunately, he ran into a driveway just as the homeowner was pulling in.

“He bumped her with the car. She skidded and rolled. She’s OK, but she had to spend the night at the hospital to the tune of $500,” Valentine said. “She’s got a real severe case of road rash.”

Valentine said she was almost hysterical yelling and screaming for help.

“My neighbor Brandon had just gotten home from Alston Park with his dog, Marlin, a lab pit mix,” she said. “Brandon ran over to help get the pit bulls away from me, and Marlin ran over to protect Brandon. The next thing I know is one of pit bulls is attacking Marlin. He had to go to the vet emergency hospital in Cordelia. He got six puncture wounds on his leg and is on morphine.”

At that point the pit bulls ran east on Third Street.

“Police were called,” Valentine said. “They were there within minutes and the pit bulls were caught. Someone brought Happy over to me.”

‘So sorry this happened’

Desiree Biale said she does not know how her two pit bulls got out.

“When I left they both were in the house. When I got home, my roommate told me the police had my dogs,” Biale said.

Biale said her dogs have never bitten anyone.

“My female dog got out last week and attacked a cat. The animal control officer gave me a warning, but I have never been cited because of the dogs,” she said.

“I am just so sorry this happened. My dogs never should have gotten out and anything that happened is my responsibility,” Biale said. “I want to take care of any medical expenses if my dogs were the ones that bit the lady and the other two dogs.”

Timothy Lotton said he believes his two pit bulls got out when a neighbor left his sliding glass door open.

“They escaped with the other two pit bulls who were outside,” Lotton said. “I really don’t know what happened. I haven’t talked to any of the victims.”

Lotton said his dogs have never bitten anyone.

“They are friendly,” he said. “They have never been aggressive to humans or animals. I really feel so bad about this. That poor woman who was trying to protect her dogs, it must have so frightening for her. I am going to do everything I can to make this right. I pride myself on trying to give pit bulls a good name. This is such a tragic thing that has happened.”

The four pit bulls were taken to the animal shelter, where they will be quarantined for 10 days to make sure they don’t have rabies.

A dangerous or vicious dog hearing will be held after the quarantine period is over. The committee that conducts the hearing could impose penalties, up to destruction of the dogs.
35 comment(s)

mardog wrote on Jun 3, 2008 10:27 AM:

" Timmy, I am so happy for you! You got your babies back. You did everything the County of Napa asked you to do. I know they tried really hard by slapping a ton of stuff on you to try to keep you from your dogs, but you stayed strong. Enjoy your babies. Welcome Home, Tycoon and Kilo, your daddy missed you terribly, and he faught for you two. "

listen wrote on May 2, 2008 7:51 AM:

" VERY GOOD POINT WRITTEN ON PREVIOUS ARTICLE!!

rbrink21 wrote on May 1, 2008 2:40 PM:

" I have a pit mix. The sweetest dog I've ever met. She LOVES kids, just wants to lick all over them. She LOVES cats (we have three that she plays with all the time). We have a neighbor down the street with a bully breed. Also very friendly.

I used to be an anti-bully breed type of person until I met her at a local shelter and she and my other dog fell in love with each other. I can't imagine my life without her.

While walking my two dogs (on leash) they've been attacked two separate times by neighbors' offleash dogs. One attack was by two labs and the other was by a german shepherd.
The most aggressive dog that I've come across loose on our street however, was a Border Collie. The only dog I've ever been viciously bitten by (broken skin too) was a border collie mix.
My point is that ANY breed can be aggressive if they are not properly socialized and don't have a strong leader.

BTW, as a side note, in my hometown, a friend of mine's daughter was attacked by a neighbor's Golden. She had to endure 4 surgeries. My friend called the news station to report it and they told him that they weren't interested in the story, and yet they are more than willing to report when there is a pitbull attack. So just because you seem to "always" hear about pitbull attacks, doesn't mean that they are the only attacks happening, nor are they necessarily more common than attacks from any other breed. "

leavintown wrote on May 2, 2008 6:35 AM:

" We live near East Ave. There are several people in the neighborhood that don't manage their dogs very well. One house just lets their dog lay on the front lawn with no leash. One time this dog came up to my girlfriend, my baby, and one of our dogs that was on a leash. My girlfriend was scared and she didn't know what to do. The owner walked back into the house to get a dog treat to get the dog to come back instead of taking care of her dog right on the spot. If I had been on that walk that dog would of got a size 10 1/2 kicked at him all the way back to the house. Another dog is in a back yard, but the fence is so broken down, the dog can fit half way through the fence. It even scares me when he rams his body through the fence barking and growling. I could only imagine what the rest of my family is thinking. I think it will only take a couple of stories in the NVR about loose dogs getting beat to death by a pedestrian to make people contain their dogs better. Also, I think that the penalties should be A LOT stiffer if a dog gets loose and does bodily damage to a human or another animal. "

savetycoon wrote on May 1, 2008 8:37 PM:

" napabicycler, do you have pets or animals of any sort? if you do, and love them, then you would understand that this was not my brothers fault. his nieghbor left the door open, my brother doesnt' want his dogs runnin around as much as any one. he takes damm good care of his animals, and wouldn't put any one in danger on purpose. Just think before you say such harsh things about his animals. He is taking care of the bills i promise you that, but noone was tragicly hurt, and yes i feel really bad for that lady, and her animals, but i bet you it was the dog that had attacked a cat who bit her. my brothers pits were sweet, one of which is only 4 months old, now what damage can she do, she is just a pup. as for the other one, he is a sweet heart, who treated my 6 pound papillion like his own, and didn;t once growl at any dogs while walking him or playing with him out in the yard. This type of attack can happen involving any dogs. People you are so ignorant to think this only happens with pit bulls. Yes its happened more with this breed, but only becuase when it happens its worse. but my mom got bit in the face by a dalmation. so it happens with all kinds, hell my papillion raises more hell then my brothers pit bulls. just think, use your minds, these are living breathing animals, that make mistakes too. dont put them down just because they are pit bulls. "

coigue wrote on May 1, 2008 1:08 PM:

" Tim,

I am sorry for your situation. But your dogs attacked someone and bit them. This isn't the first time they have threatened someone, and you know that. Our neighborhood needs to remain safe. We simply cannot have the threat here.

Your neighbor "

coigue wrote on May 1, 2008 1:03 PM:

" Napa333, I know two of the people who were attacked by these dogs in Alta Heights while walking their dog. We have children walking dogs around here. We like it that way. We aren't going to give up our streets for fear of these dogs. "

coigue wrote on May 1, 2008 12:59 PM:

" I don't care what breed the dogs are, when they attack a person in this way, they should be put down. "

John Richards wrote on May 1, 2008 9:47 AM:

" Tim, dogs are not in the same category as kids. Any dog that bites a human being needs to be put down.
If it was up to me, it would be illegal to possess an animal that is capable of doing great bodily harm. "

napabicycler wrote on May 1, 2008 9:15 AM:

" There are many unanswered questions here. The distance from where these dogs live to where the attack happened is not just around the block, it is actually quite far. How long were these dogs out? Why, when the neighbor “accidentally” let them out, didn’t he call the owner to alert him? Or go after them himself? If a “neighbor” is allowed inside your house when you’re not home they certainly should have a phone number to contact you. One of these dogs recently attacked a cat. Did the cat live? Did the dog owner pay the vet bill, if there was one? I hope the owners of the offending dogs face the maximum punishment as well as stiff fines and restitution to the victims and their unsuspecting pets. "

listen wrote on May 1, 2008 9:04 AM:

" I really couldnt imagine what I would have done in that womans position either. I am so glad to hear her two dogs are still breathing and well, and my heart goes out to her. This situation is a very hard and sad one to be in. It is not okay for a dog to bite a person obviously but on the same side it wasnt meant for these dogs to get out and attack this poor woman, they were accidentally let out, that does not mean it is okay for them to hurt someone but I dont feel it's fair they should loose their life over this either. I personally have lived with these dogs, I am an animal lover so of course I loved them and they were never once aggresive towards me.

That does not matter though because the point is they hurt someone and they are being threatend to be put down. Tim is wonderful with his dogs, he would never purposly have them hurt anyone and I dont feel that they should be taken away from him. That would be heartbreaking. Tim has always been there for these dogs, and I know he would do anything to make this situation better for this woman, it is just so terrible it had to happen this way. I really hope these dogs do not have to end this way, they are such sweethearts and made a terrible mistake!! I hope the best for you and your dogs Tim!

I feel very bad for both sides and my heart goes out to you both.

Firewater- Great point! Think about it people!!! "

Firewater wrote on May 1, 2008 7:56 AM:

" I guess no one read my comments, that dogs can run loose in Napa after 10:00 because we do not have anyone on duty to pick them up. This is what appalls me. Why aren't you screaming about that.

As for Pits, I believe there are alot of great pits out there. an if anyone remembers the Michael Vick situation a Organization called "Best Friends.org" I belong to retrieved 22 of these pits because they didn't want them destroyed. and have been training them to be put out for adoption.
Go to their site an read these stories it is heartwarming.

I also have babysat a pit and she was the sweetest thing. I have had over 25 dogs in my life time, I had a ranch. all size and breeds and everyone got along even the other farm animals..

It is the people that raise them.Yes there are bad dogs, like there are bad kids and people, but don't group them together.

This was a sad situation for the lady, her dogs and the owner. I hope everyone can heal.
"

Word wrote on Apr 30, 2008 11:11 PM:

" This is absolutely intolerable. Law abiding, responsible citizens, should not be subjected to this type of threat. Our city government needs to get tough on dog owners who allow their pets to run loose. Stiff fines, followed by jail time for repeat offenders might be just what it takes. These folks are as dangerous as drunken drivers. "

barefoot wrote on Apr 30, 2008 10:06 PM:

" I know I'm jumping to conclusions, but......doesn't every dog attack interview contain the words "my dog never bit anyone, my dog never was never aggressive". Maybe our love for dogs has skewed our perception of their innocence. Please note: I'm not picking on pits. I was attacked by a dog when I was young. It was all my fault. I was tresspassing. The dog used descretion. It was a black lab. Never broke the skin. "

barefoot wrote on Apr 30, 2008 9:57 PM:

" I know I'm jumping to conclusions, but......doesn't every dog attack interview contain the words "my dog never bit anyone, my dog never was never aggressive". Maybe our love for dogs has skewed our perception of their innocence. Please note: I'm not picking on pits. "

savetycoon wrote on Apr 30, 2008 9:17 PM:

" I am tim Lottons sister, and i have seen his pits grow up, they were nothing but bundles of love towards everyone that they saw. In fact when tim lotton brought Tycoon home, our grandma was deathy afraid of pit bulls, just for the fact that everyone gives them a bad name. but tycoon was that dog that proved pits to be just as wonderful, and or more loyal and affectionate then any other animal. my brother loves his dogs as if they were his own kids, even more so. he takes better care, and shows more affection towards these animals, then i have seen with parents with their own kids. These animals dont diserve to be put down. I am truely sorry for the owner of these two poor dogs, and the owner her self. But no one was tragicly hurt. I promise you my brother will make sure that this doesnt' happen again. please don't talk down apon my brother and his babies. And don't let the name pit bull make you think that they should of been put down. these dogs are apart of our family. And they diserve to stay in this family. As my brother has said, Don't get rid of your children just because they bullied someone. Just use your own mind to think. don't let the name pit bull judge for you. "

vocal-de-local wrote on Apr 30, 2008 9:02 PM:

" I wonder, what is it that attracts people to this type of breed when there are so many nicer breeds out there such as labs and golden retrievers? The humane society has numerous mixed breeds for adoption which end out with fewer medical/behavioral problems caused by inbreeding. All full breeds are susceptible to a greater amount of problems. It's just that the pit bull was bred for "Bull baiting" in the early part of the 19th century. "Bull baiting" was a game where pit bulls were led into an arena to kill a bull so that it would tenderize the meat. Why would anyone want a dog that had the capability of bringing a bull down?

I'm sure there are some nice pit bulls, but statistically speaking, we must look at the breed as a whole. If I had a dog that escaped and attacked another person, I would have the dog put down, period. I would not consider that dog "nice". And I would never again provide a home for that type of dog. I hope the dog owner's landlord or insurance carrier is aware of the liability. "

valleygal wrote on Apr 30, 2008 8:23 PM:

" Very sad situation...I feel sorry for the lady that was scared and trying to protect her pups, and I feel bad for the owner of the pit bulls. I hope it all works out for the best, for everyone. "

mardog wrote on Apr 30, 2008 5:41 PM:

" I just wanted to comment to everyone reading this article and to the ones that have commented. I am Tim's aunt and I have been around his dogs and so have my kids. The two dogs are his babies. He was not raising them to fight or be aggressive. Tim used to live with his grandmother that is in her 70's with the dogs. Never once were the dogs aggressive with his grandmother or anyone else. I am sorry for the lady and the animals that were hurt in this incident. Tim was not at home when this happened and when he left home that night the dogs were in his house. His babies may be put to sleep and it is crushing to all of us in the family because the two dogs were so sweet and loved by all of us. I also had a pit bull as my pet and my daughter was raised up with her. Never had issues with her. Dogs will be dogs and not all animals get along with each other just like humans. So think about it before you give the pit bull breed such a bad name. "

Jcorrie wrote on Apr 30, 2008 5:00 PM:

" This is Timothy Lotton, the owner of two pits involved in this incident, I have a few things to say to all of you who are bad mouthing me and my dogs. They are good dogs one of them is only 4 months old, and didn't do anything. I feel bad for what my other dog did, and I'm going to do everything I can to make things right. I want to get my dogs back. THEY DO NOT DESERVE TO GET PUT DOWN. And yes, my neighbor left my door open while I was out. I gave him permission to go into my house, but do you think I told him to leave my do open and let my dogs out? You (the public) would have to be an idiot to think that I wanted to let my dogs out. To all you who think my dogs should die; would you put your kid to sleep for beating up anther kid ? I don't think so.
Looking forward to your comments,
Tim Lotton "

Ephemerol wrote on Apr 30, 2008 4:37 PM:

" I urge the city government and all clear thinking people in the city to see that these animals are *banned* from being held as pets there due to their genetic instability. I currently live in the East Bay and it's a nightmare here with these animals and there are many in my own neighborhood. If you do in-depth research on this breed and talk to the breeders you will begin to understand that no matter how cute and cuddly that may appear, one has to train them *not* to kill as it's in their genes to do such and were bread for just this purpose and much worse. Purchase the ballistic pepper ( Fox brand ) that will be able to take them down at a range of say 25 feet if you are walking your own dog, or carry a baseball bat and use it accordingly if or when needed until the city acts powerfully and with intelligence in this area. Even when the police shoot them multiple times, the pit bulls get off on pain and aggression and it does not stop them but excites them and revs them up. One is safer off with Mt. Lions.
"

napabornandraised wrote on Apr 30, 2008 4:06 PM:

" Wow! why do people constantly try to give excuses or reasonings as to how pit bulls aren't dangerous dogs and are so loving and friendly? Please! when do you hear about other dog breeds attacking or even killing people. Let's get real Napa, these dogs are not dogs that we want in the same neighborhoods that our kids play in. "

moo20 wrote on Apr 30, 2008 3:03 PM:

" i know tim and ive been around his dogs and they have never been aggresive torward me. Ive always been a lil nervous around pit bulls though but i never felt threatend in anyway by them. I feel sorry for the women and her dogs i dont know what i would have done in that situation.. they do not live in 2 seprate houses either "

moo20 wrote on Apr 30, 2008 2:50 PM:

" i know tim and ive been around his dogs and they have never been aggresive torward me. Ive always been a lil nervous around pit bulls though but i never felt threatend in anyway by them. I feel sorry for the women and her dogs i dont know what i would have done in that situation.. "

local81 wrote on Apr 30, 2008 1:55 PM:

" I have a pitbull and i also have young children. My pitbull is like another child to me i walk him at dog parks and he has never attacked another dog even when another womans poodle bit my dog. I have to say in this case i think the owners are ignorant and should be punished for "THERE" actions. Its not the breed thats but but ignorant owners that are giving these beautiful breed a bad name. "

napa333 wrote on Apr 30, 2008 1:04 PM:

" I live in Alta Heights and know for a fact that those dogs (or some other dogs living at that address) have attacked another dog that was walking by with it's owner, and they also attacked a lady that was walking by. Something needs to be done. Especially with all of the little kids in the neighborhood. "

napabicycler wrote on Apr 30, 2008 11:24 AM:

" "... a neighbor left his sliding glass door open." What? Am I the only who notices that this does not add up? Of course if you blame someone else, then why should you have to take responsibility?
"

reason-ator wrote on Apr 30, 2008 10:53 AM:

" I think all dogs start to behave differently in groups than they do individually. That's why they call it 'pack mentality'.

I believe dogs sense fear. A pit bull is going to sense a lot more fear from a human than a little dog would, because the human wouldn't be as afraid of the little dog. Just one more reason why pit bulls are victims of their reputations sometimes. "

Native74 wrote on Apr 30, 2008 10:45 AM:

" Has anyone ever put a connection between pit bull attacks and earthquakes? It just seems to me that the last few attacks in the Bay Area have happened prior to a shaker event...just seems uncanny to me. "

winemd wrote on Apr 30, 2008 8:43 AM:

" The article sounds like these two people are in the group of people who would be considered resposible pit bull owners. They are family pets, not fighting dogs. So if the dogs' environment is not the issue, then it makes sense that genetics has played at least a part in this tragedy. "

Dwayne wrote on Apr 30, 2008 8:28 AM:

" I can't help but wonder, considering the pack mentality of dogs, if anyone draws a parallel with human gangs, as in gang-bangers. "

formernapamom wrote on Apr 30, 2008 8:09 AM:

" I have mixed feelings about pit bulls due to their reputation. I do feel that their temperment is influence by how they are handled by their owners. When my sister was pregnant with her first child she got a pit bull puppy that had been rescued; she (the puppy) had been kepts locked in a closet with no food or water. I was terrified with what could happen once my sister's baby was born. I will admit the dog is as dumb as a box of rocks but she is not aggressive at all and actual obeys commands from my now two-year-old niece. One thing owners may not know is pit bulls are escape artists. They should never be left unattended outside, even in a fenced yard. My sister NEVER leaves the dog outside; she is kept inside, and when she is at work the dog is kept in a crate. When the dog is outside she is ALWAYS on a leash. It is the owner's responsibility to raise the dog correctly and maintain control of the dog at all times (this goes for all breeds). "

loomco wrote on Apr 30, 2008 7:40 AM:

" How do four viscious dogs, from two seperate houses, get from Alta Heights to the railroad tracks at Third and Soscol without anyone knowing they are gone? Something fishy here... "

Firewater wrote on Apr 30, 2008 7:38 AM:

" Well people listen to this, last nite my roommate almost hit 2 pits playing in the middle of our street running loose at 10:00 p.m. he brought them into our backyard to protect them they seemed very friendly.We watered and fed them,

We called a few times to the number in the phone book, saying they are closed, kept calling telling them they are always claiming pits are dangerous and we wanted them picked up since we couldn't keep them in our yard, We have a dog and cat. Well after waiting a hr we get a message from the Sherrif's office. "We are sorry we don't have anyone after 10:00 p.m to pick up these dogs, so you can either tie them up in your yard or run them loose and hopefully they will run home"..

I was in shock I couldn't believe I heard this. So sad to say we let them loose. They seemed real friendly, but who knows.

Does the public know you can let your dog loose after 10:00 and nothing will be done.very scary. I love dogs but if you are out walking at nite just getting off a bus after work I guess you better carry mace.

Something needs to change. I am a taxpayer and I am appalled. "

hudds5 wrote on Apr 30, 2008 7:06 AM:

" True, any dog can be violent or aggressive but it appears that the PITBULLS are the most dangerous when they attack. Not too many people are afraid of a pack of pomeranians running wild in the neighborhood as they would a couple of pitbulls coming at them. Mrs. Valentine is fortunate that she did not get seriously injured and the owner of those dogs should be punished. "

nwnapan wrote on Apr 30, 2008 5:25 AM:

" Pit bulls are great animals. They are loyal, loving and make great pets. The caveat is that unless you have the time to exercise and train your Pit on a daily basis AND you have had experience with other strong willed breeds you have no business owning one, period. Any untrained dog is dangerous, but aggressive breeds like the Pit are particularly so because of the damage they can inflict. These dogs should not be returned to the owners. It's too risky a proposition for a second chance. "

Comment guidelines
All comments will be screened and may take several hours to be posted.
• Keep comments clear, concise and focused on the topic in the story.
• Comments exceeding 300 words will not be posted.
• Refrain from personal attacks, degrading comments or remarks that do not add to a constructive dialogue.
• Comments implying suspects in crime-related stories are guilty before they have been proven so in a court of law will be deleted.
• Do not post e-mail addresses or links except for pages on Napavalleyregister.com or government Web sites.
• Comments will not be edited - they will be approved or declined.
• Comments may be used in the print edition of the newspaper.
• If you feel a posted comment has violated our guidelines, please contact dross@napanews.com or bkennedy@napanews.com
For further information on the comment guidelines, click here.
Search:
Advanced searchWeb Search Powered By Yahoo! Search
Copyright © 2008 Napa Valley Publishing, a member of Lee Enterprises, Inc.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy