Conaway: Napa at mercy of 'vineyard elite'
Author James Conaway, who has written two books about Napa Valley’s evolution as America’s wine capital, was one of the keynote speakers at a California Preservation Conference program held at the Napa Valley Opera House. J.L. Sousa/Register |
Buy photos
Author of controversial books speaks at preservation conference
By KEVIN COURTNEY
Register Staff Writer
James Conaway, the bad boy author whose two Napa Valley books have laid bare local political wars and the vanities of wealthy wine industry newcomers, is back.
The author of “Napa: The Story of an American Eden” and “The Far Side of Eden” returned Thursday morning to address a California Preservation Foundation conference at the Napa Valley Opera House.
Repeating criticisms found in his books, Conaway said the undoing of the Napa Valley may be the sprawl of boutique wineries by rich newcomers who would sacrifice our natural and architectural heritage in the name of “showing off.”
Because of its international reputation, the Napa Valley is attracting a swarm of millionaires who build “baronial” estates and gut the integrity of neighborhoods by buying second homes, Conaway said.
He cited the architecture of Dominus Estate — a winery covered with stone-filled gabion enclosures — as an example of “totalitarian” design, an “unapproachable” building that serves the “vineyard elite” that now rule the Napa Valley.
In the same vein, Conaway disparaged the Frank Gehry-design for what will be Hall Winery in St. Helena, a clear case of a building dictated by “fashion, not function.”
Tourists play into this trend, Conaway said. “They’re attracted by the spectacular.” Be wary of catering to tourists, he said. “Tourism can devour the thing it loves.”
Conaway, who is an editor at large for Preservation magazine, said George Yount, the valley’s first white settler, would hardly recognize the place today.
The Napa of his day was marked by abundant wildlife, clear-running streams and dense forests on the western hills, Conaway said. If conference attendees were to venture into the hills today, they would find forest “scrapped raw” by vineyard development, he said.
Conaway praised the wine industry as the essential underpinning for the Napa Valley’s quality of life. “Agriculture is the source of all good things here, although it’s easy to forget sometimes,” he said.
Perversely, the very success of the Napa Valley wine industry — wine grapes are “one of the most valuable legal crops in the country” — has created the conditions that threaten it, he said.
The valley is attracting the mega-wealthy who want a piece of the action, he said. Vineyards have been planted on questionable terrain. The homes of the rich are infected by “gigantism.”
Corporations, which now own 20 percent of the valley’s tillable land, are another threat, Conaway said. In a wine industry downturn, corporate owners might be tempted to spend big bucks to repeal the Agricultural Preserve, allowing vineyards to be replaced by houses, he said.
Conaway lamented what he sees as the prevailing ethics of the times. Americans value growth and land use entitlements more than preserving our country’s architectural heritage and landscapes, he said.
“No piece of the nation goes unassigned to market forces,” Conaway said.
Conaway’s next book, set for release later this year, is “Vanishing America: In Pursuit of Our Elusive Landscapes.”
For those who want Conaway’s take on Napa Valley happenings since “The Far Side of Eden” came out in 2002, stay tuned. He’s working on the third volume of his Napa trilogy.
All comments will be screened and may take several hours to be posted.
• Keep comments clear, concise and focused on the topic in the story.
• Comments exceeding 300 words will not be posted.
• Refrain from personal attacks, degrading comments or remarks that do not add to a constructive dialogue.
• Comments implying suspects in crime-related stories are guilty before they have been proven so in a court of law will be deleted.
• Do not post e-mail addresses or links except for pages on Napavalleyregister.com or government Web sites.
• Comments will not be edited - they will be approved or declined.
• Comments may be used in the print edition of the newspaper.
• If you feel a posted comment has violated our guidelines, please contact dross@napanews.com or bkennedy@napanews.com
For further information on the comment guidelines,
click here.
hudds5 wrote on Apr 25, 2008 6:35 AM:
pbfallon wrote on Apr 25, 2008 9:12 AM:
JimClark wrote on Apr 25, 2008 10:01 AM:
I continue to believe that this issue has become too political and needs more time to set some real principles and policies that will further reduce the amount of housing tracts and hotels that seem to be proliferating throughout Napa County.
I continue to believe the County and City governments are extremely delusional in what they seem to believe to be necessary. When I drive past the Wine Train station, I see this hotel and “resort” under construction next to the Napa River. When I drive down Soscol and see the mud flats at low tide, I have to wonder. There is some question as how many of those rooms will be occupied and what kind of revenue they will pay to the County/City of Napa. The larger question is will those revenues reduce the tax encumbrances on local taxpayers? Or, will local government perform as the bozos in Sacramento? Reduce the deficit by increasing taxes and spending that money on some other project?
I grew up in Napa and I have seen it become Mondaviland; a theme park for wannabe snobs and moneyed elitists. Our hillsides are blemished with the “homes” these elitists have paid off or twisted government arms to be capable of constructing the devastation of our real Napa Valley.
Voting yes may maintain the status quo but we all need to try to maintain what is left of our rural atmosphere. "
Sickothis wrote on Apr 25, 2008 10:03 AM:
southnapareader wrote on Apr 25, 2008 10:56 AM:
napablogger wrote on Apr 25, 2008 12:02 PM:
since1976 wrote on Apr 25, 2008 12:21 PM:
Sorry mom, you could afford to buy a house here thirty years ago and now I can't. I wouldn't call that financial security for the locals. "
vocal-de-local wrote on Apr 25, 2008 1:29 PM:
napablogger wrote on Apr 25, 2008 4:06 PM:
Boy this comment box isn't working right. No scroll bar, bleeding off to the left side. Anyone else having that problem? "
Bill wrote on Apr 25, 2008 4:58 PM:
Instead a nation or county of gentleman vinyardists tending their vines with the teaming masses of field hands fending off left wing environmentalists in the tradition of Tidewater aristocrats.
It appears that in the Napa Valley all geese are also swans. perhaps we haven't come that far.
Not forty acres and a mule but 160 and a minor Barony.
Now I may have to read this author. "
cordell wrote on Apr 25, 2008 6:06 PM:
Unclestuy wrote on Apr 25, 2008 6:52 PM:
napablogger wrote on Apr 25, 2008 7:30 PM:
160 acres and a Barony, I like that. "
napaninsf wrote on Apr 25, 2008 9:33 PM:
109823 wrote on Apr 25, 2008 10:26 PM:
johnmo wrote on Apr 28, 2008 8:29 AM:
E. & J. Gallo, Central Valley of California, replaces Louis M. Martini’s seat. Gallo: the largest wine producer in the USA says Wine Business Monthly 2006 ranking based on U.S. produced case sales. Gallo recently purchased William Hill.
Francis Ford Coppola, the Hollywood movie mogul replaces John Daniel. Jr. Inglenook seat. Coppola recently renamed the site “Rubicon. “ 18th largest producer USA.
The Louis Stralla, Napa Wine Co. seat replaced by the Pelissa Family, long time local winegrowers who also represents about 25 small wineries.
Charles Forni's Napa Valley Co-op seat replaced by Hall Wines, owned by Kathryn and Craig Hall. The co-op sold almost all of its wine to E & J Gallo during the 1940’s and into the 70‘s.
Robert Mondavi’s seat replaced by Constellation Company of Canandaigua, New York: 2nd largest in the USA: owns Franciscan Oakville Estate, Mount Veeder Winery, and Robert Mondavi.
Larkmead‘s Elmer Salmina seat replaced by the Frank Family. Rich Frank is a former Disney and Paramount Television executive.
Beringer replaced by Foster's Group of Australia: owns St. Clement, Etude and Stags' Leap Cellars among its other Napa Valley holdings. Foster’s is the 5th largest.
Beaulieu/Mrs. Georges de Latour replaced by Diageo, Great Britain: owns Sterling, Provenance, Acacia and Jade Mountains. 8th largest in the USA.
"