NVR Logo
Napa High students march for teacher facing deportation
Thursday, March 20, 2008
Save and Share Share
With neon-colored signs made from poster board and markers, with cut-out photos of Spanish teacher Esther Colorado, with chants of “Let her stay!” about 50 students marched through the Napa High campus Wednesday, to the district building where three assistant superintendents waited.

The student protest was a last ditch effort to save Colorado, the Spanish teacher who will be deported to Spain at the end of June.
Colorado, 33, arrived at Napa High six years ago on a temporary visa as part of a teaching program. Equipped with master’s degrees in Spanish and English, and an infectious personally, Colorado became a favorite among students, teaching Spanish to both native and non-native speakers.

She became enamored with the country and the school, she said, and obtained a professional visa that would allow her to legally continue teaching at Napa High for up to six years.
But in order for Colorado to renew her visa at the three-year mark, she needed Napa Valley Unified School District to sign a document declaring that no resident job seeker would be qualified to replace her.

“The way the (immigration) system works, the district has to be able to declare there is no one who can fill her position,” said Sharyn Lindsey, NVUSD assistant superintendent of human resources. “We can’t say that.”
On Feb. 17, Colorado heard the news.

“They told me they’re not going to sponsor me any longer,” she said. In June, when the school year ends, she must return with her husband and 1-year-old baby to her hometown of Talavera in Toledo, Spain.

“It’s really amazing to have to change your life and you only have four months to think about leaving your life for six years,” she said.

In Spain, she will be unemployed, she said, noting that the public education system requires teachers to take an exam before they can get a teaching job. The exam is only offered every two years, and the next exam is in June.

Colorado will miss the exam while finishing the year at Napa High, and then must wait a minimum of two years before she can teach at a Spanish public school. To teach at private school, she said, she would have to move to Madrid, because there are no private schools in Talavera.

“I feel stranded,” said Colorado. “(I have) no control when it comes to my family and what’s going to happen in my life.”

“They have the right,” she said of the district’s decision, but “if they had a little bit more humanity, I don’t know.”

She has grown to love her school, she said, her colleagues and her students.

“They were crying” when they found out, Colorado said. “Some could not believe it. They wanted to know why, and if there was something they could do.”

So on Wednesday, students, former students and even a sprinkling of teachers grabbed signs, pulled on walking shoes and marched through campus yelling, “Miss Colorado! Miss Colorado! Let her stay! Let her stay!”

At the sound of the lunch bell, they marched from the gym, through the quad, to the principal’s office and down Jefferson Street to the white pillars of the district office.

There, three assistant superintendents, who met with students that morning to establish guidelines for the protest, heard their cries and answered their questions.

Lindsey thanked the students, but told them policies set by the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency dictated the outcome.

“I admire the support you’re giving Mrs. Colorado. … It’s not about her teaching ability,” she said to the emotional crowd. “We’re as sad as you are.”

Elena Toscano, NVUSD assistant superintendent of instruction, commended the protesters. “I’m proud to see you are exercising your civic right,” she said. “I’m proud of the fact that you are here.”

Toscano, who praised Colorado as an excellent teacher and phenomenal role model, said later that students earned “an A-plus in civic awareness of their right to protest.”

“Unfortunately,” said Lindsey, “we are legally precluded from being able to keep (Colorado) here at this time. … I don’t know what more you can do. I don’t know what more I can do.”

Junior Ricky Hurtado, protest leader and next year’s student body president, stood on the steps with the district officials, explaining to students that the district is in a legal bind.

“We’re here to let the legal system know we’re supporting her,” he shouted, before leading a chant.

“What do we want?” he shouted from the steps.

“Mrs. Colorado!” students called back.

“Mrs. Colorado! Mrs. Colorado!” they broke out in unison.

“She’s always there for her students,” yelled Hurtado. “We want to show that we are there for her, too.”

After the protest, Colorado sat with colleagues, crying in her classroom. Fellow teachers rallied to her support.

“The (Spanish) program has grown 100 percent since Esther came on board,” said teacher J.E. Buckingham, noting the importance of cultural instruction that only a native speaker can provide. The district “talks about how we want an educated workforce. I wonder how much of that is rhetoric,” she said, adding, “If it was a reality they would be doing everything they could.”

Sophomore Marissa Castaneda said “none can compare” to Colorado, explaining that even if the district can replace her on paper, no one will replace the relationships she has built with her students.

“I’m happy to have been able to be here for six years,” said Colorado, wiping tears from her eyes. “Some day maybe I’ll be back with a green card. … Yes, I will be back, but maybe not in Napa.”
48 comment(s)

areyoubitter wrote on Mar 20, 2008 5:43 AM:

" This is odd. When we have sooo many illegal citizens, Why would we deport a family who is GIVING. Her students and family need her here. If she did not pay taxes and slipped by,she would never face this. Why would they deport someone who IS PAYING TAXES,and helping our children??? Please someone Help this Family. It seems they are just trying to make an example out of her.
I hope someone hears about this and can help her. Things need to change but this is not the way. It just shows that the THOUSANDS of illegal citizens need to work under the table. WHAT AN EXAMPLE TO SET? NOT REALLY!! "

musikluvr wrote on Mar 20, 2008 6:30 AM:

" This was an opportunity to teach students about our legal system and immigration system and that this is an example of how it works. They should have been reminded that our country and our economic system is run on the rule of law. They should have taught the kids that laws can be changed by democratic processes. This rule of law is the envy of the rest of the world. But no, the activist, unionist teachers and administrators of NVUSD helped the students hold a protest, an empty wasteful exercise that changes nothing. How sad that the minds of our students are so twisted by our schools. I would never send my children to NVUSD. "

Firewater wrote on Mar 20, 2008 7:17 AM:

" Boy here are double standards, we let illegal immigrants live in napa for decades and everyone turns a blind eye. Now we have someone that is really contributing to our youth and they say their hands are tied. I don't buy it. There has to be some legal eagle that can get around this...Congrats to the kids that are rallying. voices do help..wish you luck "

kbf wrote on Mar 20, 2008 7:43 AM:

" No one understands. In Napa it is the wine industry that runs the city and county. The school district dosen't really care they are laying teachers off. I wonder if she has gone to the private schools in Napa to see if one of them would sponsor her. This time when the students marched it was for good and I applaude them. "

Napanee wrote on Mar 20, 2008 7:52 AM:

" Yes it is sad. But with all the lay offs of teachers lately the job should be given to a citizen of this country. Maybe the school can give her time off to fly home and take the exam that she needs to teach in her own country. "

toratora wrote on Mar 20, 2008 8:37 AM:

" Sounds like a better move for her to go back to spain and bump this 2 faced city and nation (Better life and people there) . This town and state does everything It can to turn a blind eye to the illegals here amongst us, The crime they bring with them, The suking sounds on our tax payer paid for social services that the illegals did not pay for!!
Mrs Colorado does not fit the mold, she is educated, She is not from south of the border, She gives back to the community does not just take like many of others.
I wish Mrs colorado the best of luck and thank here for being a great teacher!
VIVA ESPANA!!!! "

Skip M. wrote on Mar 20, 2008 10:06 AM:

" It seems patently ridiculous, at a time when we are cutting qualified teachers who are U.S. CITIZENS due to budget cuts, to even entertain the notion of retaining a non-citizen who is here on a TEMPORARY basis. This is the exact sort of thing that has been eroding our economy for over thirty years. To bring in foreign labor, particularly at the professional level, when there are plenty of qualified men and women right here in the United States. This displaces our own citizens and harms the earning power of those who are displaced. I am sure Ms. Colorado is a wonderful person and caring teacher. But, with all due respect, she should have applied for citizenship long ago if she intended to remain here. If she never intended to become a U.S. citizen, then it is time to move on. "

Paddy wrote on Mar 20, 2008 10:10 AM:

" This is an unfortunate turn of events for Esther Colorado. However, it's difficult feeling too sorry for her as I watch many of my friends lose jobs to temporary visa holders from all over the world.
The same laws that allowed her to work here are now requiring her to leave. Perhaps a native Napan, native Californian or native American will have an opportunity to do a good job in this open position.
I hope Senora Colorado has even greater success and happiness in her future endeavors. It sounds like she will be an asset no matter where she ends up. "

funnyme wrote on Mar 20, 2008 10:27 AM:

" I second you Skip.
I wonder if the uproar would have been the same if Mrs. Colorado had not been a spanish speaking person from Europe but from Mexico instead. I am willing to bet that "La Raza" and all of those groups would be screaming "discrimination" at its loudest...just wondering.
Good luck to you and your family Mrs. Colorado! "

selim wrote on Mar 20, 2008 10:29 AM:

" The central issue is that the district doesn't have the cajones to re-up her sponsor. Why? Is the district really overloaded with applications from people with 2 Masters degrees? Most likely not. The answer probably lies in the fact that they don't want (or waited too late) to file the paperwork with the government. This, folks, is an example of the system hosing over people who are immigrating PROPERLY...folks who are following the rules. They should be rewarded, not shafted due to lazy administrative paper-shufflers giving BS answers.

And there are those of you, of course, who trot out the union and call teachers "activists" and all the other rhetoric from the knuckle-dragging AM talk radio playbook...well...the union wasn't mentioned ONCE in the article. You're using an example of people standing up for another person they admire as some sort of excuse to go on a tired rant about "public troughs" or "unionist" or whatever. Face facts: she's here legally, she got treated unfairly, the results of that treatment will lead to a serious alteration in her life and the life of her family, and people are upset. There's no union agenda...just people support a teacher they respect. "

Dwayne wrote on Mar 20, 2008 11:11 AM:

" Veteran firefighters in Salem, Oregon are being fired as they are replaced by bilingual (Spanish speaking) firefighters, according to a new regulation that all firefighters must speak Spanish. Too bad about Ms. Colorado, but enough is enough. This country is in trouble because of it. We can't play give-away with our country any longer. "

vocal-de-local wrote on Mar 20, 2008 11:14 AM:

" selim, our country cannot afford to increase it's population period. It doesn't matter whether or not the person did all the right things, is a good person etc. Every person who migrates here increases crowding and eventually makes demands on our resources.

She's having a baby right? That's ok but maybe she has made a few too many assumptions about her immigration status and job security. She has obviously reached a level of comfort otherwise she wouldn't have brought a child into the world right?

Her baby and probably the next baby she has will grow up to make demands on our limited resources. The U.S. cannot afford to make every person who wants to move here cozy and comfy at the expense of the those who already live here.

Most of us do not approve of illegal immigration either. But some of those people will certainly make the argument that that they are making a positive contribution to our country. Legal or illegal is not the point. It's whether our country is becoming weighed down with too many people. We must draw the line clearly and not play favorites. Playing favorites puts us in a sticky position we cannot get out of.


"

jomar wrote on Mar 20, 2008 11:22 AM:

" LET HER STAY! She is an amazing teacher. I was one of her students the first year she was here. She is the kind of teacher we need here in the U.S. She made learning fun and students love attending her class. For a student who hated spanish and all classes for that matter I looked forward to attending my 2nd period spanish 2 class w/ Ms. Colorado as a teacher. WE NEED TO KEEP KIDS IN SCHOOL and with great teachers like Ms. Colorado we can. Have a heart and keep her here! "

pat wrote on Mar 20, 2008 11:22 AM:

" I honestly don’t see how this is a newsworthy story in the first place. Someone with a temporary work visa has to go home per the rules of the temporary work visa. What part of temporary is unclear here? No one is getting “hosed” for following the rules, rather, they are complaining about the very rules that allowed them here in the first place. "

l707 wrote on Mar 20, 2008 11:41 AM:

" I dont agree what you guys have written here that she is "facing deportation" that is not true she is my teacher and she is not getting deported thay have told her she had to leave but not get deported if she was to stay here and the police arrest her then she will get deported. But she doesnt want to stay for this reason that she is going to do something ilegal.


We the students are very very sad that she is leaving and eventhough their is nohting that we can do we still dont give up and we keep hoping that they will let her stay. WE LOVE YOU MRS. COLARADO AND WE WILL FIGHT FOR YOU DOESNT MATTER WHAT THEY TELL US! "

toratora wrote on Mar 20, 2008 12:26 PM:

" To The Register staff, Why do you have a problem showing my input about this story? Does not fit your bias liberal agenda? Please have the guts to answer if you can. "

PastNapan wrote on Mar 20, 2008 12:26 PM:

" To Pat: I think people in Napa see the irony of the Valley being flooded with illegal aliens and nothing is done and yet someone here legally(for now anyway) is being told to go home. I feel for her but like someone else said she is here on a temporary visa. And kudos to the liberal Napa Register for having the headline say she is being deported when in fact she is being told she will no longer be sponsored by her employer. "

NVR Moderator wrote on Mar 20, 2008 12:57 PM:

" toratoratora:
Your story inadvertently went into the postponed, rather than the posted folder. The comment is now up.
--Dan "

tiredofcomplainingnapkins wrote on Mar 20, 2008 1:40 PM:

" I understand why she has to be deported and I'm glad to see the system is working. But what I don't understand is how a man who plowed into a woman and destroyed her life was allowed to stay after commiting a DUI a year prior. Are immigration program is so messed up in this country. To bad for Mrs Colorado that the system actually looks for good hardworking here legally type of people, but let criminals here completely illegaly stay here and break are laws. "

redwino wrote on Mar 20, 2008 1:53 PM:

" It is great she was able to touch her students the way she did. That truly is an amazing skill. It is horrible that there are so many illegal people in California that are draining money out of our government who are never faced with deportation. Now, we are focusing our energy on someone who went through the correct legal steps and who has an honest living (paying taxes) and her visa is denied.
However, she knew the risks in receiving a temporary work visa. It was her choice to take those risks. Now she will have to roll with outcome.
"

ag707 wrote on Mar 20, 2008 3:17 PM:

" I honestly can believe this is occuring, i was shocked when i read the paper this morning. Mr.Colorado had been my teacher for tree years, and those 3 years where the best memories i have for highschool. She is and amazing teacher and more than that she is a friend to the students. She made class worth going to, she made us feel welcome even though she was the stranger from another country. She is a great role model, and will continue to be one. The nvsd can do something about it and its not fare that she has to go thru this. she has come so far, and now with a blick of a eye u espect her to pack her bag and go. She came to this country to establish a life, and she cant even do that. I thought his country was the place for oppurtunities.I just hope that at the end she is able to stay. Even though am not one of her students today i still whant her here. I want her to change students life just how she changed mine. Mr.Colorado dont give up, u have students and alumni that will have your support. "

opiniagirl wrote on Mar 20, 2008 3:29 PM:

" She did a great job while she was here on her work visa, no doubt about it! But the school cannot sponsor her again because there are Americans that are willing to do her job and have applied for it. The purpose of a Work Visa is for an employer to seek foreign labor to fill a job with NO AMERICAN applicants. This is certainly not the case any longer. This teacher is free to apply for another school district anywhere in the USA to sponsor her Work Visa. Nobody questions this woman’s ability to teach! Hopefully the AMERICAN CITIZEN that rightfully takes her place next year is just as good! "

John Richards wrote on Mar 20, 2008 4:06 PM:

" Selim, this issue has nothing to do with immigrating. The teacher is a temporary guest worker, not an immigrant. What part of "temporary" don't you understand? I understand she is grateful for the six years she was allowed to be here as a guest of our country. "

buttrflydancr707 wrote on Mar 20, 2008 4:49 PM:

" I understand that she was supposed to be here temporarly, but she was supposed to stay here for 3 more years! I understand that there are other teachers that are qualified to take her job, but really, what teacher takes the time to teach you about all the different spanish speaking countries? Hardly anyone does! Most teachers just teach you what is absolutely necessary and move on with their lives but not her. She takes the time to teach her students about everything THEY want to learn about while at the same time teaching everything that is required. And not only that, but we want a native-spanish speaking teacher because we don't want to be wasting our time doing things, like conjugating verbs, when we already know how to do that. We want to learn how to write and speak correctly!
And yes its true that she could try to get a job at a different school here, but its too late for that. If she had been notified of what was going on earlier, she could have applied for a job in a different school district.
A lot of things can be done to help her situation but we need people to take action, not just "support" her.
For example during spring break I will be going around downtown Napa to try and get signatures from people for a petition that we are trying to send to Sac.
So please people....have a heart and LET HER STAY!!! "

napanurse wrote on Mar 20, 2008 4:58 PM:

" The article states, “The (Spanish) program has grown 100 percent since Esther came on board,” said teacher J.E. Buckingham, noting the importance of cultural instruction that only a native speaker can provide. I completely agree with this. I am a white girl from Napa who is now fluent in Spanish because of Napa High and college Spanish classes. I know, without a doubt, that I learned more from the teachers who were native speakers. NVUSD won't declare that nobody else can fill her position. Are there other native Spanish speakers out there with 2 Master's degrees who also have such a brilliant track record with this district who are clambering for this job? If so, please, go ahead and give it to them. But if not, then there is no one else who can equally and as competently fill this position. "

buttrflydancr707 wrote on Mar 20, 2008 5:02 PM:

" I understand that she was supposed to be here temporarly, but she was supposed to stay here for 3 more years! I understand that there are other teachers that are qualified to take her job, but really, what teacher takes the time to teach you about all the different spanish speaking countries? Hardly anyone does! Most teachers just teach you what is absolutely necessary and move on with their lives but not her. She takes the time to teach her students about everything THEY want to learn about while at the same time teaching everything that is required. And not only that, but we want a native-spanish speaking teacher because we don't want to be wasting our time doing things, like conjugating verbs, when we already know how to do that. We want to learn how to write and speak correctly!
And yes its true that she could try to get a job at a different school here, but its too late for that. If she had been notified of what was going on earlier, she could have applied for a job in a different school district.
A lot of things can be done to help her situation but we need people to take action, not just "support" her.
For example during spring break I will be going around downtown Napa to try and get signatures from people for a petition that we are trying to send to Sac.
So please people....have a heart and LET HER STAY!!!! "

myword wrote on Mar 20, 2008 5:24 PM:

" First, I don't see this is front page news or news worthy of an article on any page. Are we supposed to feel sorry for Mrs. Colorado? I feel sorry for American citizens who can't get jobs right here in their own country! She knew for 6 years that she would have to leave the country and she whines that she has only 4 months to prepare and she has no control of her life. Did she think having a baby here would give her a free ticket to stay. Crying at school and upsetting students should never have been tolerated. The average teacher would never get by with this behavior! If she were smart, she would leave early and get to Spain to apply for the test to teach there. If she is unemployed in Spain, it is her choice. There are plenty of qualified substitute teachers in Napa to take her place, as well as those seeking full time employment. We have immigration laws for a reason and it is good to see NVUSD upholding the law and refusing to lie to the government to keep her here! Mrs. Colorado acts like the district was obligated to keep her here and shocked that they wouldn't lie for her! What does this teach our students? She is setting a poor example by her comments and behavior because she knew the law six years ago. Did she hope her whining would give her a new VISA status. She needs to go home and get in line legally if she wants to come back to the USA. No sympathy from me. More businesses need to abide by the law as did NVUSD. "

toratora wrote on Mar 20, 2008 6:06 PM:

" Dwayne, Your statement is idiodic at best, She is here teaching spanish as a second language to high school students. This country is in trouble because of the opposite Mrs Colorado brings to the table, She came here legally, She is not a drain on our society, She is educated. As for those firefighters being replaced by bilingual speaking people It goes to show you what it takes to be a firefighter not to bright and lets face it they are way over glorified. "

Joe wrote on Mar 20, 2008 6:09 PM:

" Deport her! there are plenty of people who are qualified for the job. It's not fair to the American citizens. She should just go live in Spain where she came from. I'm sick of all these immigrants getting jobs. I'm also sick of affermative action. All these minorities getting jobs because of there race when they are not the best person for the job. ... makes me sick! "

BecauseIcare wrote on Mar 20, 2008 7:30 PM:

" Ms. Colorado is not facing deportation. I think everyone should now that. She is here legally on a workers permit. She is not talking away a job that a American could of had. She applyed for it and got it.
No other American teacher can teach us the way that she has. She lets us have a sense of our culture and to be proud of where we are from.
Ms. Colorado is a excelent teacher. I am going to do all in my power to let her stay. People need to know how this isn't just effecting her, its affecting all students that take any form of spanish.
"

richy wrote on Mar 20, 2008 11:39 PM:

" HELLO there this is ricky hurtado
i am the organizer of the protest 3/19/08 and ASB President for 08-09
and i have been reading all the comments you guys left
im realy taking in concideration all you people have said
but its not going to change my mind to help a great teacher who she is
and i also believe that some of you are mistaken
but dont take me wrong
everyone thinks different
1st of all she is not an immigrant
and came to the U.S. legally
2nd of all she did not tell us anything
to organize the rally
and
3rd
we are not going to stop we are going to do our best to keep her at napa high
...............
like one comment said
she is helping our outh
so why cant you accept that
if you met her you would understand......
but i understand all of the people that posted comments
and there is what so ever any hardships.....
the rally was peacefull, organized,
and well prepared
if you have any questions regardiing this contact me
thank you
and thanks for putting you oppinions
"

Alpha wrote on Mar 21, 2008 12:54 AM:

" Stop it with the bickering! If this issue does not afect you directly, move aside. It's understandable that as Napa citizens you're concerned with this issue, but some of you have extreme and at times racist comments. I believe Napa High parents should have a stronger say on this issue because their children are the ones who will be more affected by this, and so they should work with NVUSD as well as with the government if they want to resolve it. As to those who say there are other qualified citizens for the job, how do you know? Facts are important. Assumptions and biased comments lead to no where. Consequently, if opposing views don't find middle ground, Napa citizens as well as American society won't be able to move towards a brighter future. Maybe if we save time arguing, we can get things done. Think about it, you're old enough to think positively for this country without demeaning those who you think you know, and stereotype. "

Reality Check wrote on Mar 21, 2008 1:46 PM:

" With "freedom of speech" so highly valued by journalists world-wide...how can the NVR Mod so heavily censor these blogs and not be totally ashamed of themselves. You're to report the news, not become it. You're to share opinions, not shape them. Is this the left leaning tripe they teach in journalism classes? Why don't you work for the Chinese as they prep for the Olympics...you're much better suited for that assignment. Shame on you! "

opiniagirl wrote on Mar 21, 2008 3:12 PM:

" richy;

The passion of your youth is inspiring, however; it is clear that the focus of the students of Napa High REALLY needs to be more on EDUCATION in general. Spanish is an extracurricular class that, while necessary for credits, should come secondary to English grammar and comprehension. Proper punctuation, articulation, spelling, vocabulary and grammar are abilities far more necessary to function professionally and socially than an ability to speak a foreign language. When addressing the public or dealing with the population of a community in any public forum; intelligence and integrity is judged by the ability to communicate efficiently.

As far as this teacher is concerned; it would be dishonest and unlawful for NVUSD to sponsor her if any American has applied for her job. We wouldn’t want to send the message that rules don’t apply to everyone, even the best of people. It is the responsibility of people, like yourself, who are in a position of some social stature to educate and motivate their peers in a way that is constructive and seeks an attainable goal. In this case, this teacher remaining at Napa High is NOT AN OPTION, because it would be dishonest and illegal to sponsor her again under the circumstances.

Good luck to you! =)
"

John Richards wrote on Mar 21, 2008 3:28 PM:

" Several have made the point that it would be difficult to find a replacement teacher who is as well-qualified and has 2 Master's degrees. Good point, but thanks to Affirmative Action laws those extras cannot be taken into consideration. Any applicant who meets the MINIMUM qualifications must be considered. "

Skip M. wrote on Mar 21, 2008 4:17 PM:

" As to how many people are available with two master’s degrees, I would submit there are more out there than you think. What’s more, the degree does not in itself translate to actual skill and talent. I know many in the teaching profession, as well as in my own (software development) that are educated far beyond their actual intelligence. "

Alpha wrote on Mar 22, 2008 1:58 AM:

" Affirmative action... Everyone seems to like to debate over this issue constantly. Which is great, but Mr. Richards, facts are important. Proposition 209 which passed on November 3rd of 1997 banning all forms of affirmative action in California. That's right, California banned affirmative action. "

Skip M. wrote on Mar 22, 2008 9:43 AM:

" Alpha: When was the last time you applied for a civil service position? Let me break this to you gently, the federal, state, county, and city governments all still follow the mandates of affirmative action. Don’t take my word for it. Go put in an application for anything at any of these levels. "

a teacher wrote on Mar 22, 2008 11:39 AM:

" And Skip M, as a person who has been on hiring committees I can tell you that we are not allowed to consider anything but the qualifications of the candidate. "

jfz wrote on Mar 22, 2008 11:55 AM:

" Not allowed to consider anything but the qualifications of the candidate? So you can be a horse's butt, not get along with your co-workers, and terrorize clients (students) because these social interactions aren't considered "qualifications"? Time to switch to a different school district! "

Paddy wrote on Mar 22, 2008 5:30 PM:

" Based on some of the shocking examples of English composition it's obvious to me that more attention should be spent in English class than Spanish class.
I do, however, appreciate the spirited debate by passionate students. "

Alpha wrote on Mar 22, 2008 8:24 PM:

" Skip M.: Following our rights, you’re entitled to your knowledge and opinions which I respect. Furthermore, your comment is a bit deceiving. Your comment reads as if there are “minority” Americans who have jobs that don’t deserve them and/or were given that job based on being a “minority”. Some clarification would be nice as I would not like misinterpret your comment.
-----------------------------------------------------------
Moreover, what’s wrong with today’s view on who should be allowed to work American jobs? If many say American citizens should hold such jobs, which they should hold first priority, then why can’t “minority” Americans be seen as capable of holding those jobs. If “minority” Americans apply to a job then it’s because they believe they are qualified for such positions, and have the credentials. Check the news and see who’s running for president. So how do we solve this? Should applications not be submitted in person and not have any evidence on to what race or ethnicity one is(which I don‘t find relevant)? Will that be the only way only the qualified will get the job? Because if that’s the case, then we would be demeaning “minority” Americans from their roots; having them hide their identity in order to comply with biased views. What a mess… Where’s this country headed to?
"

petebo wrote on Mar 24, 2008 11:17 AM:

" Yet another stoopid government moment devoid of any reason that might mbenefit the people of this community. When are we going to STOP allowing government to walk all over us? These courageous students know our system is extremely messed up and want to take things in to their own hands. Can't really blame them because the adults have just made things continually worse by allowing government to grow way too large. It is like a mammoth beast that has to be fed or it turns against you and becomes carnivorous. I applaud these kids because they know this is wrong and are not afraid to do something about it. We need to take a hint and learn from these young patriots and educate ourselves as to the deception of our collapsing system. This is all inter-related and in fact and the fear of confronting any facet of the federal machine has most Americans cowering in the shadows so as not to create any attention. We need to face the facts and quit trying to explain why our system is justified in actions such as this. Speak up kids, we are listening and hopefully a large enough percentage of American adults will come out of the brain dead coma they have been trapped in the past 60 years. Thank the good Lord kids are thinking for themselves instead of assuming everything they are told by government employee minions is true and that the government has the final say. WE HAVE THE FINAL SAY! They are watching the collapse of the financial system and wondering how this and other blunders are going to affect their lives as they inherit this mess. They are intelligent and are questioning government and that is very refreshing and promising for our nation. "

Skip M. wrote on Mar 24, 2008 11:53 AM:

" Alpha: Please explain the Affirmative Action questionnaire that must be completed every time I apply for a position with the State of California. Why is there no option of “Decline to state” on any of those questions? Why collect the data if is not to be used? Are we simply gathering the data to provide to some attorney when they decide to sue over the question of representation? I am not a racist, in spite of what Barak Obama says, but it does not make sense that we would collect all this information if it is not to be used in some way. The only time I landed a civil service position was in Hawaii, and the factor that tipped the scale was that I was the underrepresented minority (white male) in the position I was applying for. I always thought that was the greatest of ironies. True, that was Hawaii, not California. But it was still an interesting point. "

opiniagirl wrote on Mar 24, 2008 11:53 AM:

" I'm reminded of a quote;

The surest way to corrupt a youth is to instruct him to hold in higher esteem those who think alike than those who think differently.

Friedrich Nietzsche (1844 - 1900), The Dawn, Sec. 297

Somtimes someone has already said it better =) ! "

Skip M. wrote on Mar 24, 2008 6:08 PM:

" Opiniagirl: I’m not sure where you were headed with the Nietzsche quote. Although it is a good quote. Please forgive me. Sometimes I am a little slow on the uptake. "

opiniagirl wrote on Mar 24, 2008 7:32 PM:

"
When the adults involved in this situation encouraged the kids to all get together and march on this teacher’s behalf, knowing that the students’ perspective was uninformed and emotionally based, they set this kids up for failure and or disappointment.

What they should have done is educate them about the reality of the situation. They should have encouraged them to see this from a more informed, mature (adult) perspective. Most mature informed adults view this situation as not “a lost opportunity for a foreign visitor”, but a “new opportunity for a deserving American”.

This encouragement, lacking education, taught the kids that their emotionally based, youthful perspectives were correct and that the situation was unfair; essentially turning them into victims. Victims rebel and feel slighted and it is reflected in their behavior and attitude.
"

Skip M. wrote on Mar 25, 2008 10:07 AM:

" Opiniagirl: Very appropriate. Thanks for clarifying. "

Comment Guidelines
The goal of the story comments section at NapaValleyRegister.com is to have an open, thought-provoking, civil community forum for all issues.
What gets your comment posted?
• Staying on topic
• Keeping your comment to 300 words or less
• Avoiding name-calling
• Addressing your comments to the message rather than the messenger
What gets your comment deleted?
• Personal attacks
• Derogatory remarks
• Name-calling of any sort
• Going off-topic
• Hate speech
• Racially-insensitive comments
• Implying guilt of a subject in a crime story before there is a court verdict
• Posting e-mail addresses
• Posting comments of a commercial nature
• POSTING WITH ALL CAPITAL LETTERS
• Linking multiple comments together with "to be continued..." to get around the 300 word limit.
The fine print
- Comments are either approved or denied. We do not edit comments.
- You are welcome to modify and resubmit a denied comment.
- Comments may take several hours to be posted.
- Comments posted are those of the writer, and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of NapaValleyRegister.com, its employees or its parent company.
- Do you have information on a story? Please go to our virtual newsroom to send us a news tip.
- If you feel a posted comment has violated our guidelines, please contact online@napanews.com or add a comment indicating you have an issue and our moderators will review the comment in question.
Search:
Web Search Powered
By Yahoo! Search
Napa Valley Register on Facebook
Copyright © 2009 Napa Valley Publishing, a member of Lee Enterprises, Inc.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy