NVR Logo
Unlawful dumping turns city crew into garbage collectors
The city of Napa averages a call a day to pick up dumped garbage on public right of ways, costing taxpayers thousands of dollars and hundreds of staff hours. This couch on Randolph Street showed up on the curb as a free giveaway and is now a ripped and torn eyesore. J.L. Sousa/Register | Buy photos
Tuesday, February 19, 2008
Save and Share Share
Jeff Folks’ Public Works crew weren’t hired to be garbage men, but it turns out that’s how they spend their time.

About once a day, these street maintenance workers are diverted from their regular duties to pick up ratty couches, broken TVs and worn-out microwaves dumped on Napa streets.
Folks wouldn’t put it so bluntly, but some people are pigs.

When they move, they push their unwanted junk to the curb and hightail it out of town.
When a sofa wears out or a car battery dies, they lighten their load on a dark, dead-end street.

“The word is out. If you put something on the street, the city will pick up,” said Steve Barragan, a public works worker.
Maybe it’s the state of the economy or the rise in home foreclosures, but the number of illegal garbage dumps is growing, said Jane Thomson, the city’s code enforcement officer.

If the trash is on private property, it’s on Thomson’s turf. It’s her job to find the property owner responsible for cleanup. If it’s on the public right of way, then Folks’ crew handles the job.

In three months, his crew has picked up 30 washers and dryers, Folks said. After the holidays, at least 100 Christmas trees were dumped along city streets.

Some dumps are in-your-face blatant, Folks said. Twice in the last month, someone has dumped a truckload of construction debris on the top floor of the Second Street parking garage.

When a family lost its home to the bank, they apparently left town with only the clothes on their backs, Thomson said. “Their solution to cleaning out the house was to throw it all in the street,” she said.

Fearful of what he would find, Barragan recalled recovering a gunny sack with an apparent body inside. Someone had disposed of a dog, he said.

Folks recently hauled a moldy couch to the city’s Corporation Yard. When workers dug under the cushions, they found a .22-caliber handgun. An earlier couch yielded 52 cents.

These cleanups divert city workers from their regular duties. This means less maintenance for city streets, said Kevin Miller, the city’s materials diversion administrator. The public ends up paying for the thoughtless acts of others, he said.

City officials are asking the public to report illegal dumps. A license plate can help the city track down the perpetrator. A first-time offense can come with a $100 fine, Thomson said. Fines rise with repeat offenses.

Some people are too lazy to do the right thing, Miller said. Others are poor and don’t know of low-cost options. And then there are those who are downright malicious, he said.

Electronics and hazardous waste can be disposed of for free at Napa Recycling and Waste Services facilities near the Napa County Airport, Miller said. Items in good condition can be donated to Goodwill or other charities. For $30, the garbage company will remove up to four bulky items from your curb.

A garbage and recycling insert in the Yellow Pages of the AT&T phone book explains all this in detail, Miller said. More information can be found at www.naparecycling.com

Questions can be answered in English and Spanish by calling 257-9292.

What about people who put unwanted objects on the curb with a “free” sign?

Don’t put them on the public right of way, Thomson said. Pull the item back onto your yard. And if it’s not gone in a day, maybe that’s a signal to find another disposal method, she said.
31 comment(s)

Suze wrote on Feb 19, 2008 8:03 AM:

" This is one of my pet peeves, I was startled to read how bad it really is. Not only that, but it does not even address the amount of furniture, appliances and general trash (dead dogs and goats included) that get thrown into rural creeks. Add this to the amount of cars abandoned on the highways and it is easy to see how it is taking large amounts of local tax dollars to prevent our streets and highways from looking like ghettos and certain third world countries south of the border. I knew of a person used to work for a city council in the U.K., and they found it was actually cheaper to provide dumpsters than it was to go around and clean up after the 'fly tippers.' It is just a thought, we have a lot of transient population who have absolutely no interest in 'doing the right thing.' "

kevin wrote on Feb 19, 2008 8:11 AM:

" Gee, MAYBE it has something to do with the fact that EVERY OTHER CITY/COUNTY has at least one, if not multiple, CLEAN UP DAYS where customers can leave bulky items at the curb and have them disposed of at no additional charge. Doesn't seem to matter what service it is, our "leaders" repeatedly "roll over" and settle for the least service at the highest price: be it cable, waste management, road repair, water, whatever.... "

dreamzruler wrote on Feb 19, 2008 9:03 AM:

" WOW! This is right in front of my apartment...the worst part is these people life off our tax dollars, own a truck, and have left this 'eyesore' in our parking lot for months! "

musikluvr wrote on Feb 19, 2008 9:09 AM:

" Paying city crews to do this is a ridiculous waste of taxpayer dollars. The garbage company will do it. Just call them and it will cost $35, only a tiny fraction of what city employees cost - Don't forget the city pays people over $45,000 plus benefits to push lawnmowers. "

pm1972 wrote on Feb 19, 2008 10:09 AM:

" Starting to look like south of the border isn't it? "

steph wrote on Feb 19, 2008 10:31 AM:

" Not to mention the slobs who dump their unusable junk (broken, dirty, outdated, etc.) at the thrift stores. I feel badly for the guys who have to clean that up. These are charities trying to help the less fortunate, and they have to deal with lazy thoughtless people dumping at their donation stations. Yes, I agree with the author, some people are pigs. Oh well, you can't count on all members of society to behave mindfully. What a wonderful world it would be, though... "

MyInput wrote on Feb 19, 2008 11:15 AM:

" Illegal dumping doesn't seem much of a problem in Napa. I assume this has more to do with City employee's response than is obvious. I've seen communities where things are much worse. We have a pretty remarkable set of options for reuse, recycling, and pick-up or drop-off of unwanted items. "

truthteller wrote on Feb 19, 2008 12:27 PM:

" These city employees are lucky they have jobs. Whine anyone? "

kingsavage wrote on Feb 19, 2008 1:07 PM:

" a little known fact is that the steel mill in american canyon will take your old appliances for free. all you have to do is get them out there. dont pay those thives at the garbage co. "

Barry Martin wrote on Feb 19, 2008 1:49 PM:

" In response to "kevin": City residents receive a coupon each year that allows them to drop off a full load of unwanted items at any time within a 4-month window. The type of curbside "clean up" day you refer to is very expensive - in the range of $130,000 to $200,000 for a City wide effort - and all the ratepayers (that's you) pay for it in the long run. Many communities are no longer offering curbside "clean up" day programs due to cost.
In response to "musikluvr": The cost of $35 you refer to for NRWS to pick up your bulky items is a price that does not reflect the real cost of the work. That low cost for the service is actually a benefit citizens receive as part of the current contract. If the City calls NRWS for that type of unscheduled pickup, the charge is $210, which is closer to the real cost of providing the service.
In reply to "truthteller": It's unfair to suggest that this news story means City employees are complaining about doing their work. On the contrary, the point of the story is that when some individuals choose to break the law and dump illegally, it creates an eyesore, degrades our neighborhoods, and spends our collective tax dollars to clean up after the irresponsible people.
"Kingsavage" is right that Steel Mill Supply in American Canyon accepts scrap metal items from those who have the means to transport them. (More info is in the Recycling Guide in your phone book.) They do not take furniture and other types of items that are often left on the curb. If you have questions about this issue feel free to contact me at 258-7843 or bmartin at cityofnapa.org "

napanurse wrote on Feb 19, 2008 1:56 PM:

" I used to live in New York City and you can put anything you want on the curb on garbage day and the waste company will pick it up. Even things as large as couches and bookshelves will be picked up. Here in Napa they won't even pick up an extra bag of garbage next to your can. "

napaao wrote on Feb 19, 2008 2:44 PM:

" thats messed up!! i get so mad when i see old junk along my scenic cruises! stop trashing our city! "

4gNapan wrote on Feb 19, 2008 3:04 PM:

" I ride a motorcyle round this lovely valley of ours, and it dismay's me the amount of trash I see dumped willy-nilly, without regard to the hazards or impact. Henry road seems to be a popular dumping ground, I've seen televisions, Oil cans, washing machines, beds, furniture, you name it... it's sad.

35 bucks isnt that much to pay to have an old couch hauled away.. "

pinonut wrote on Feb 19, 2008 3:48 PM:

" Thank you, Barry. And for all of you who feel the city is not providing the same services as other cities, keep in mind that the property tax rate in New York City ranges from 12% to 15% for residences, including co-ops and condos. In Napa it is about 1.2%. We can pay higher taxes or higher garbage fees, but whether you are an owner or a renter, the cost has to be born by someone. "

GetUrHeadOut wrote on Feb 19, 2008 4:52 PM:

" Keep closing dumps and raising fees at the ones left, you have not even see the beginning yet! "

pm1972 wrote on Feb 19, 2008 5:14 PM:

" The dump will take almost anything, and allot of it is free--especially electronics. Only a lazy or uninformed person would do this. Did you read the article last week about the oil drums at Lake Hennessy--you can dump oil for free. That is just a total disregard for the law--like I said earlier, it is starting to look like south of the border.
Isn't it???? "

Kevin wrote on Feb 19, 2008 5:56 PM:

" So Barry, why are the garbage rates the SAME in Napa (or even higher) than places that DO have a "clean up" day? Shouldn't our rates be LOWER? "

Dirty Napkin wrote on Feb 19, 2008 6:19 PM:

" I have never seen such a paper in my garbage bill. I would use it every year to throw away all the junk that comes in my garbage bill. "

steph wrote on Feb 19, 2008 6:38 PM:

" Try using the dump in Sonoma County--they reject a lot of stuff from dumping that most other places wouldn't consider hazardous--like treated wood, for example. They won't let you leave it, and then they offer ridiculous suggestions for disposal--like, "Call this number" or "Drive 100 miles away to this other place". And all I can imagine is that people just dump it on the side of the road, then. At least Napa is more user-friendly. "

comment wrote on Feb 19, 2008 9:57 PM:

" What about people that live in apartment complexes, Mr. Martin? I previously lived in a complex where garbage was paid. I never recieved any coupons from my landlord. Are they using them for themselves, or does the complex as a whole recieve only 1? I think most of the stuff dumped illegally comes from apartment complexes in the rundown areas of town. I doubt these people recieve the coupons because their garbage is paid by the landlord. Maybe things would improve slightly if they did. "

Firewater wrote on Feb 19, 2008 10:07 PM:

" Why does the garbage company have a limit on Paint Cans?. I moved into a home someone left about 80 cans and they will only take 15 at a time that I have to drop off "

kdbk wrote on Feb 19, 2008 10:58 PM:

" Wise-up people. pm1972 has made it quite clear to you, in plain ENGLISH. But I guess that some around here don't like clarity and truth.

Now, let's have a look at today's (and most EVERY day's) crime stories in the Register. And check the monthly DUI reports too.

It is NOT simply a cliche to say that "Napa used to be a very different place". It's true here as it is in much of the West/Southwest region of the country. How sad...for everyone involved. "

DavB wrote on Feb 19, 2008 11:53 PM:

" The suggestion that Napans are knee-deep in trash is just plain, well, rubbish. I, for one, simply don't see trash accumulating on our streets. Of course there is, always has been, and always will be those who'd rather dump things illegally, without regard to health or environmental impact, than take responsibility for their waste. But creating free-for-all garbage collection won't solve the problem. Hiding or subsidizing costs of trash disposal is counterproductive. Underpriced waste disposal causes overreliance on landfills and increases the long-term risks of environmental contamination. Our City fathers shouldn't overreact. As citizens, we should help turn in those who break the law by dumping illegally, and we should encourage our city leaders and staff to continue the good job of keeping our streets clean. With the right mix of enforcement and reuse and recycling options, Napa will remain pretty low on the list of trashy cities. "

Ruff Limblog wrote on Feb 20, 2008 7:25 AM:

" Charge for disposal at the time of purchase and pick up for free... simple and effective. Works now for pop bottles and cans, and would solve this problem. Of course, there is a certain satisfaction about griping about human nature rather than designing systems that allow for it. Doesn't anybody find it sad that people who lost their home (for whatever reason) and have to leave town are expected to cough up money to pay for trash pickup. That money could be all they have to get home. I'd bet a dollar a month would fund both 'big item' and street trash pickups better than the 'fee-per-pickup' system used now. In any case... city crews are more far more expensive than paying the recyling and waste company to do it. ~Ruff "

Ruff Limblog wrote on Feb 20, 2008 7:34 AM:

" How many waste and recycling customers are there? If the cost for a city-wide pickup day is $200,000 and the number of customers is 50,000 then $0.50 cents a month should cover it and this 'issue' goes away. I am willing to pay an extra $1.00 a month to have the garbage company handle street trash and big item pickups for 'free' at the time of need. So, let's see if the city council has any stones to fix something developers don't care about. ~Ruff "

NValleyGirl wrote on Feb 20, 2008 3:54 PM:

" To kdbk: I knew someone would try to spin it. How about we don't need to look south of the border everytime something is unsightly in Napa. *gasp* Could it be that there are just lazy people here (oh my), born and raised in Napa, California, or even (here it comes) the United States. What a novel concept. There were DUI's, unlawful dumping, littering, crime, etc. before the immigration boom, so get off of it. Your reach at best, is laughable. "

dreamzruler wrote on Feb 21, 2008 12:52 PM:

" LOL I love it...no laughing matter but it is funny how many excuses you see here. What it comes down to is just plain laziness. Try walking downtown during chef's market where you will see people throwing wrappers on the ground 5-10 feet away from a trash can! Whether you're a napa native or a transplant, a lazy bum or just a spoiled child who has had someone wiping your backside all your life-accountability is the real problem here.
There is a disease spreading across our nation. People just don't want to deal with their problems-just set them aside. Life isn't easy enough so just have another xanax, put your kid in front of the tv, and throw the crap you don't want on the street. Cheers! "

cathyodom wrote on Feb 21, 2008 2:00 PM:

" Jeff Folks and Crew- thanks for cleaning up the city streets! Also, a note: On Vine Hill a few weeks ago, someone put two very nice love seat couches in frong of their house with a "FREE" sign on it. Very good intentions. However, 3 skateboarding teens picked up one of the couches, putting it on their skateboards, and then transported it over to Vine Hill park, where they left it. Then it got rained on and ruined, and probably the street crew had to pick it up and haul it to the trash at a cost of time and money for dumping. At least once or twice a year there's a couch left in my park. Count up all the parks, and couches, and that adds up. If you don't want the couch, maybe try Salvation Army to come and pick up for free. "

old_Napan wrote on Mar 2, 2008 9:31 AM:

" I response to Barry Martin: Thanks for lettingthe world know that the city's contract with NRWS is flawed. I can see that the number of calls for this service will be on the rise if you can have a $ 210 service provided for only $35. In the case of the employees finding items of value in the trash: These items are to be turned in to to the city for proper handling. I hope the lack of this being in the article doesn't give the impression that city employess are personally gaining from their jobs. I feel that if the employees have time to dig through furniture and trash to find valuables is for the effort of returning the items to the owner or for the city to offset the cost of their services. "

14obama wrote on Mar 2, 2008 10:44 AM:

" Yes and there's gonna be more of it !
Let's be Realistic here ! Not everyone can afford to have garbage pick-up. There was a time when every town had a place for free disposal. Now we pay for pick-up and when taking loads to the refuse center. The garbage rates continue to climb while big money is made from the by-products. Seems to me we're getting shafted as usual. Too bad that Greed has to be so rampant these days. "

14obama wrote on Mar 2, 2008 11:47 AM:

" Hey dreamzruler !
Thanks for the advice! I'll do just that! When I'm at the chefs market,I don't mind people throwing things on the street. It's all gonna be swept up,anyway. Throwing stuff out of cars is my pet peeve. I suppose it's good practice,not to anywhere,though. Afterall,we are "creatures of habit". Also: musikluvr should apply for the job,pushing lawnmowers. "

Comment guidelines
All comments will be screened and may take several hours to be posted.
• Keep comments clear, concise and focused on the topic in the story.
• Comments exceeding 300 words will not be posted.
• Refrain from personal attacks, degrading comments or remarks that do not add to a constructive dialogue.
• Comments implying suspects in crime-related stories are guilty before they have been proven so in a court of law will be deleted.
• Do not post e-mail addresses or links except for pages on Napavalleyregister.com or government Web sites.
• Comments will not be edited - they will be approved or declined.
• Comments may be used in the print edition of the newspaper.
• If you feel a posted comment has violated our guidelines, please contact dross@napanews.com or bkennedy@napanews.com
For further information on the comment guidelines, click here.
Search:
Advanced searchWeb Search Powered By Yahoo! Search
Copyright © 2008 Napa Valley Publishing, a member of Lee Enterprises, Inc.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy