NVR Logo
Napan gets 18 years for killing Vallejo teen
Lombardi | Buy photos
Girl, 13, perished in 2005 RV fire
Thursday, November 29, 2007
Save and Share Share
Wednesday morning was emotionally charged for the family of a Vallejo teen who perished in a Napa motor home fire more than two years ago.

Family and friends of Rachel Ellis packed a Napa courtroom, leaving standing room only as they observed the sentencing of Joben Lombardi for his role in the 13-year-old’s death.
Sitting in the front row, Ellis’ mother, grandmother and other family members sobbed and glanced frequently at Lombardi, 27, as Napa County Superior Court Judge Stephen Kroyer sentenced him to 18 years in state prison for manslaughter and other counts. The girl died in June 2005, at Lombardi’s home on Dry Creek Road.

Last October Lombardi pleaded no contest to voluntary manslaughter, lewd acts upon a child under 14, and two counts of furnishing methamphetamine to a minor.
Earlier this year, Lombardi was facing a murder charge when he agreed to plead guilty to manslaughter.

At Wednesday’s sentencing, Ellis’ family, many wearing T-shirts and buttons with her picture, glared at Lombardi as he was escorted into court by the bailiff.
Only a few members of Lombardi’s family sat in the audience.

The soft sounds of crying could be heard as Ellis’ grandmother, Joyce VanBooven, read a poem she had composed in memory of her granddaughter.

“I call this ‘A poem to Rachel with love,’” VanBooven said. When she was finished, she looked over at Lombardi, back at the judge and said, “What goes around, comes around. He will get what he deserves in prison.”

Ellis’ mother, Mara Hale, also made a statement.

Sitting before Kroyer, Hale started to address her comments directly to Lombardi. Kroyer told her the protocol was to talk to the bench, adding, she could speak what ever was on her mind.

Speaking very softly, Hale said, “I will never have closure and I want him to hear what I have to say. I thought I could talk directly to him. I want him to tell me how he could let such a beautiful little girl burn to death. I will never be the same. I lost my best friend.”

Napa County Deputy District Attorney Paul Gero, who prosecuted the case, told the court he hoped Lombardi would have the courage to apologize to the family.

When it was his turn, Lombardi stood up and faced Ellis’ family.

“I’m sorry for your loss. But it’s not like you think. I’m not a murderer. That’s not me,” he said.

Kroyer called Ellis’ death a horrible tragedy for everyone involved.

“This has been a difficult case ... to try to accomplish justice. And there is no such thing as perfect justice,” Kroyer said.

After the hearing, VanBooven told the Register, “His apology meant nothing. It was all about him. He has not a single ounce of remorse.”

Lombardi’s mother, Karen Kramer, said Ellis’ death “was just a terrible accident. Joben is innocent. And that’s the God’s honest truth.”

Ellis ran away from her Vallejo home to Napa in June 2005 and was hired by an agency to sell subscriptions to the Vallejo Times-Herald. About four days before she died, she met Lombardi, his brother Kyle and one of their friends in front of the 7-Eleven store on Sierra Avenue in Napa, where Ellis was selling newspapers.

She left with the trio, and spent the next few days living in a motor home parked near the Lombardi residence in the 2200 block of Dry Creek Road.

During the preliminary hearing in the case, witnesses testified that Ellis had taken an extreme amount of methamphetamine, most likely rendering her unconscious before she perished in the fire.

John DeHaan, a forensic fire expert, testified that when Ellis’ body was recovered she had been standing upright in the shower stall in the motor home. He said she was overcome by the intense heat and smoke from the fire.

DeHaan concluded Ellis was unconscious when she was placed in the shower, and the fire was deliberately set.

Lombardi told sheriff’s detectives he was with Ellis the night of the fire, but left her asleep on a blanket in the RV with a candle burning. He said he went to the main house and went to bed.

Lombardi will have to register as a sex and narcotic offender for the rest of his life. As part of his plea bargain, Lombardi waived his right to file an appeal.

Hale has filed a civil wrongful death lawsuit against several people, including Lombardi, his grandmother Rosalie Lombardi and Ellis’ father, Scott Brian Ellis.

The civil suit claims that Hale’s family has suffered the “loss of love, affection and support due to the death of Rachel Ellis.”
26 comment(s)

skiph wrote on Nov 28, 2007 3:09 PM:

" Nothing excuses what he did to the poor girl...my only question is where was the family when she ran away? Best friends usually don't run away from each other. "

opiniagirl wrote on Nov 28, 2007 4:02 PM:

" I have a 13 year old daughter, she would never DREAM of leaving home! If you raise your children correctly they DON"T run away from home. These parents are partially responsible for their daughter’s apparent lack of responsibility and morality. This does not excuse the sick actions of this man. However the accountability for this crime extends beyond him to the parents of this girl...not the grandmother of this man...whom it seems as though they are trying to gain a financial windfall from. "

napaao wrote on Nov 28, 2007 5:31 PM:

" FREE JOBEN!!!!! "

starling wrote on Nov 29, 2007 3:33 AM:

" What I have never totally understood about this whole thing is why would he of put this girl in the shower in the first place? It doesn't make sense at all..Personally, I think she woke up and got in the shower to try and avoid the smoke or got lost in the smoke and ended up there and was overcome. Plus, she obviously told people she was older than she was because she wouldn't of been able to get the job she had being her actual age. Now days, who can tell a 13 from an 18 year old, especially if they tell you different? I am not blaming the girl by any means for her death and feel very badly for her family but the truth is the truth. Also, did they ever establish how the fire was actually started? They've said they didn't find a candle, so how do they know that it was infact arson? Sorry but I like to know all the facts before I make my final judgements, especially when lives are on the line. As for the lawsuit, unfortunately it happened on the grandmother's property which makes her liable also. I personally feel as sorry for Joben's family as I do for hers. "

Two Cents wrote on Nov 29, 2007 8:10 AM:

" Lets see if this post makes the cut as my last 2 didnt... why NVR?? Opiniagirl... I dont think the family is trying to gain a financial windfall. If you knew this family, you would know that the mother and the grandmother have enabled these boys and their behavior since they were small and their life of crime began. Just read the mothers statement in the article. She swears to God that her boy is innocent. COME ON! These boys picked up a 13 year old runaway to have their fun with for a few days until her demise. They all lived on grandma's property, and if she had been more cognizant of what was going on out there, none of this could have happened. She does have some ownership in this tragedy. The apple doesnt fall too far, ya know.... "

valleygirl wrote on Nov 29, 2007 8:59 AM:

" This is very sad for all involved. These kind of drugs do these kind of things. There is definately enough blame to go around. "

o0o4evrshortyo0o wrote on Nov 29, 2007 9:44 AM:

" i don't think that any one can make comments or judgments on this case without knowing all the facts, which non of you do, you have no idea how her home life was or the things that went on in it. You dont know her family or her for that matter and i dont think that joben got what he deserved, there is over 2,000 pgs of evidence pointing every finger towards him. he is lucky that he got offered what he did or he would have been given the death sentence for sure! "

opiniagirl wrote on Nov 29, 2007 10:42 AM:

" To: oOo4evr...The fact that the girl ran away and would rather work on the streets than go home is evidence of a lack of proactive parenting. Only parents can be held responsible for their parenting or lack of it. But for the fact that she ran away from home, SHE WOULD NOT BE DEAD TODAY! She didn't call her Mom when she ran away, did she? The only people chilren can count on is their parents, it's not an optional responsibility. Johan may or may not have directly or indirectly been responsible for the fire itself, but NOBODY BUT THE PARENTS ARE ULTIMATLY RESPONSIBLE FOR KNOWING WHERE YOUR CHILDREN ARE. "

hudds5 wrote on Nov 29, 2007 12:25 PM:

" Not knowing the whole family story doesn't change the views and opinions of those who have read this article, but the fact that a 13 year girl had to leave home is a serious matter. It's a sad situation that someone so young had to fall victim to such a vicious predator. Whether she looks her age or not does not dismiss the fact that she was killed, and a murderer was allowed to plea bargain his fate. If he survives prison life, he will be eligible for parole in nine years...which means he will be back in Napa looking for his next victim. "

cejagirl wrote on Nov 29, 2007 2:11 PM:

" 13 year old do stupid things all the time doesnt make the parents bad at all some time they just end up wiyh the wrong crowd and sometimes peer pressure is hard to resist if you want to fit in havnt you ben 13 "

opiniagirl wrote on Nov 29, 2007 2:31 PM:

" Looking for a victim??? Come on! "

opiniagirl wrote on Nov 29, 2007 2:34 PM:

" Supporting your adult child doesn't make you a party to his actions! She must beleive he is innocent of deliberatly causing this girls death. How can this girls parents demand that this adult man be controled by his Grandmother when they couldn't control their 13 year old little girl. "

napaao wrote on Nov 29, 2007 3:14 PM:

" opiniagirl you rock!!!! "

napawineo wrote on Nov 29, 2007 3:35 PM:

" For those of you that feel sorry for Joben's family, I say get a clue. You either know the family OR you used meth with this guy...no one in their right mind would feel sorry for him or the ENABLERS that allowed him to continue using METH and destroying not only his life but KILLING a 13 year old girl. I am sure his family is sorry now that someone has died, but why didn't they feel sorry back when he was using METH and getting him the help he obviously needed? To late to feel sorry now. I say 18 years is a joke, I think our DA is a joke for accpting the plea...I for one would have loved to be on that jury... It is easy to spot meth users in your neighborhood, just look for the 25-40 year olds living wtih family, not working and standing in the middle of the street at all hours tweaking...Call the cops and keep calling them, eventually they will get a slap on the wrist from our DA to reoffend again, but atleast you will have couple quiet nights. "

Two Cents wrote on Nov 29, 2007 3:56 PM:

" napawineo you are RIGHT ON! Ever driven past the eyesore on Dry Creek Rd just up from Alston park?? That is the Lombardi compound. I dont care what anyone says, yes you CAN judge a book by its cover. Opiniagirl, you make a good point about the 13 year old girl also obviously having some family trouble. However, what happened to her is unspeakable. This man has no conscious. Something is mentally wrong with a 25 year old man who preys on a 13 year old girl and do what he did to her. What's scary is that he will mostly likely be out in 9 years, back on the family compound, being enabled to continue his life of crime. "

opiniagirl wrote on Nov 29, 2007 7:19 PM:

" Maybe we should charge the girls parents with contributing to the delinquency of a minor. Or the company that hired her without checking her out. Or the friends of the girl that didn't tell where she was. Or the people that sold the candle. Or the city that paved the road for her to run away on. Where does it end? It all begins and ends at the girls home. Bottom line..if the child was brought up correctly with proactive parenting she would be likely alive today! It's the parent’s job to protect the child. Don't get me wrong..I agree that this man should be in jail, maybe even for longer than he was sentenced for...but this was a preventable situation. When I am asked, “Do you know where your children are?” the answer is yes, absolutely, no doubt about it, most certainly, YES! Quit making excuse and saying…weren’t you ever young?…you can’t control them!…The peer pressure id toooooo muuuuch! That’s a bunch of hoopty! Oh, by the way...thx napaaao "

The Needle wrote on Nov 29, 2007 10:25 PM:

" Until we as a culture and as a society take the business of "people making" and "child development" seriously we will continue to have hoards of joyless and loveless psychopaths like this not too bright monster. I say this with disgust now as it's gotten so much worse as it lasts generations. One perspective is possibly now more powerful at this time i.e. "how could this have really been any different?" The answer is a painful, "Not in this life time...". We do not value people in our culture as much as we throw that all around at times. We value power, status, possessions and yes, money. This mess is the result, or part of it. The rest is on the way. How truly disgusting to create evil through one's own progeny and then believe it's something else as his own mother apparently does. "

starling wrote on Nov 29, 2007 11:53 PM:

" Napawineo, obviously you have very strong opinions regarding Joben's family and that is your right. I do however, retain my right to feel sorry for his family as well as the victim's. Why is it that when someone messes up, people always tend to blame the family for it also? Granted, in some cases the families are directly responsible but Joben is 27 years old, an adult, and totally capable of making his own decisions and mistakes no matter how he was raised. Just because he does drugs does not necessarily make the family enablers or every member one either. As for his mother claiming that he is innocent, what mother who loves her child would say or want to believe otherwise? What mother would not stand behind and defend her child? I used to know his mother and I can guarantee you that she in no way wanted or encouraged him to do drugs, much less his grandmother. "

Two Cents wrote on Nov 30, 2007 10:17 AM:

" Opinioagirl.. your philosophy applies equally to the Lombardi's, dont ya think? I mean, if Joben was brought up properly, this wouldnt have happened, right? This could have been a preventable situation as well, had his mother taught him better. Also, had the mother and grandmother paid attention to the fact that him and his brothers had a 13 yr old girl in their trailor on her property in addition to methamphetamine, her death could have been prevented. Look into the family history and I think your defensiveness for them might change a bit. Another question I have had throughout this whole thing is how did the Vallejo Times hire a 13 year old to sell subscriptions? Dont you have to be 15 anymore and acquire a work permit to get a job? Or provide a drivers license or ID card? "

napawineo wrote on Nov 30, 2007 12:55 PM:

" Starling, I guess you do have a right to feel sorry for his family, but I am guessing by you feeling sorry for them you have never lived near a enabling family...A enabling family is one that allows grown adult children to live at home free of rent, use drugs, have their friends come by and use drugs, sell drugs, keep any hours they choose, disrespect the whole neighborhood by peeing in the street, puking on the lawns, Cussing at all hours and by allowing this to happen a family becomes an enabler., so feel sorry all you want, but someday if you live in napa long enough you are going to be neighbors with a enabling family and you will understand my stance... Trust me I don't know this guy or his family nor does it sound like I would ever want to... "

4EVERNRHEARTS wrote on Nov 30, 2007 1:00 PM:

" RACHEL[HAD]A BIG LOVING FAMILY SHE BECAME APART OF AT THE AGE OF 2 WHEN MARA AND GARY STARTED DATING AND SOON AFTER WERE MARRIED.RIPGARY LOST THIS YEAR.RACHELS FATHER HADNT BEEN THE DAD THAT SHE COULD'VE EVER SAIDSHEWAS "DADDYSLITTLEGIRL". AT A LOSS,THE FAMILY CRIED OUT FOR HELP 2 THE SCHOOL ,POLICE ,CPS LOOKING 4 HELP AS RACHEL WOULD RUNAWAY AND YES SHE WOULD N DID CALL HER MOM WHILE GONE WITH NO HELP FROM ANYONE WE FEEL THE LOSS AND WE THINK WERE WE WRONG NOT TO CHAIN HER IN HER ROOM WE SHOULD OF QUIET OUR JOBS STAYED AT HOME TOOK THE WINDOW OUT OF HER ROOM AND ALSO REMOVED THE DOOR KNOBS AS THEY DID ON MOTORHOME,AND HOW MANY GRANDMAS DO YOU KNOW THAT WOULD TELL THE FIREMEN TO PUT OUT THE BARN BEFORE THE MOTORHOME KNOWING HER GRANDSONS HANG OUT IN THERE UNLESS THEY TOLD HER SOMEONE WAS DEAD IN THERE SO THEY THOUGHT BECAUSE OF THE AMOUNT OF DRUGS THEY HAD GIVEN TO RACHEL TO CAUSE HER TO GO IN TO A DRUG COMA SHE WAS 13 YEARS OLD AND WE ARE LIVING WITHOUT HER WE WISHED AND BEGGED FOR ANSWERS ON WHAT TO DO WITH OUR RUNAWAY AND TAKE A HOUR AND LOOK AT HOW MANY RUNAWAYS THER ARE TODAY AND THERE FAMILES .HE GOT OFF EASY FOR HIS PART IN THIS AND WE HAVE TO LIVE MISSING HER FOR THE REST OF OUR LIVES AND NEVER KNOWING WHY ONLY GOD CAN JUDGE US NOW.AS FAR AS JOBEN AND THE GRANDMA THEY KNEW RIGHT FROM WRONG AND THATS WHY HE TOOK THE DEAL AND SHE TRIED TO SETTLE OUT OF COURT.DO YOU THINK WE WANTED MONEY urnuts. WE ONLY WANTED RACHEL HOME.SHES SAFE NOW WE TRY TO KEEP THAT IN OUR MIND "

Two Cents wrote on Nov 30, 2007 11:44 PM:

" Hey opiniagirl.. just for fun, read these archives from the NVR... still feel like defending these people? Still think Rachel’s parents are the one’s who did the poor job raising their kids? http://www.napavalleyregister.com/articles/2003/08/15/news/export61018.txt http://www.napavalleyregister.com/articles/2006/11/29/news/local/doc456d928319859190365521.txt "

opiniagirl wrote on Dec 1, 2007 9:58 AM:

" A 46 year old and 21 year old from that family with drugs and driving on suspended licenses???? So what. I NEVER SAID ANYWHERE that this guy was raised correctly. My point is that after adulthood the reponsibility (blame) stops with the criminal. If it does extend to anyone else it would be the family of the MINOR if there is NEGLIGENCE on their part. No 13 year old little girl is uncontrollable. Yes, quit your job, don't cry outfor help...get in their face and demand it. Move away, yes bar the windows...there is NOTHING that is to extreme when it comes to the safety of your child. If she ran away before this even solidifies my point. "

Joe wrote on Dec 1, 2007 3:08 PM:

" Mr. Lombardi was just trying to be nice to a girl who could have used some help and now he's being looked at like some kind of sick petifile. How does anyone know that he supplied her with drugs, or tried to do anything sexual with her? It says in the article that he slept in a different house. Why would he inentionally burn down his RV and draw all this attention. Maybe she lit the candle and fell asleep in the shower after being up for days. It sounds like a horrible accident. I'm sure many people will look at his picture and assume he's guilty because he fits the image of a stereotypical psychopath. "

Two Cents wrote on Dec 2, 2007 7:57 PM:

" Bottom line.. this guy is a menace to society and the apple doesnt fall too far from the tree, as evidenced by the archived articles I posted last. This poor girl was taken advantage of in the worst way. 13 years old is a rough age especially for girls. She obviously was troubled and its just sad that there are sick people in the world just waiting to prey on them. And even sadder yet, that there are people out there willing to make excuses for them. "

NaPaNaTiVe79 wrote on Dec 14, 2007 12:57 PM:

" First of all.. I have known Joben for YEARS. I am a female, he has in no way or manner EVER disrespected me in any way. This is a sad situation for everybody, especially that lil girl whom seemed soo lost. EVERYBODY involved is to blame. For the mother to say she lost her best friend.... Would your best friend run away from you? Obviously there was so much more to the story. Joben is NOT innoccent in this situation, nor is her family. I feel at this point the victims family is only out for money. Suing Jobens grandmother?? An old innocent lady that was supporting her grandsons?? I have a teenage daughter, and the LAST thing on my mind would be money. "

Comment guidelines
All comments will be screened and may take several hours to be posted.
• Keep comments clear, concise and focused on the topic in the story.
• Comments exceeding 300 words will not be posted.
• Refrain from personal attacks, degrading comments or remarks that do not add to a constructive dialogue.
• Comments implying suspects in crime-related stories are guilty before they have been proven so in a court of law will be deleted.
• Do not post e-mail addresses or links except for pages on Napavalleyregister.com or government Web sites.
• Comments will not be edited - they will be approved or declined.
• Comments may be used in the print edition of the newspaper.
• If you feel a posted comment has violated our guidelines, please contact dross@napanews.com or bkennedy@napanews.com
For further information on the comment guidelines, click here.
Search:
Advanced searchWeb Search Powered By Yahoo! Search
Copyright © 2008 Napa Valley Publishing, a member of Lee Enterprises, Inc.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy