NVR Logo
Motorists deal with changes on Soscol and Trancas
Sunday, July 01, 2007
Save and Share Share
It’s been two months since the city made over the Trancas/Soscol/Big Ranch intersection, leaving motorists suddenly unable to make turns they had practiced for decades.

As part of punching through Soscol Avenue so it connected to Trancas Street opposite Big Ranch Road, the city installed raised medians to limit turns near the intersection.
Customers at Silverado Plaza and Financial Plaza could no longer zip back and forth across Soscol. Left turns in and out of the Custom House center on Trancas were barricaded.

Warren Magee, owner of the Custom House, remembers going to dinner on a Friday night when the Trancas median was merely two lines of paint. At dawn Saturday, “this thing was here.”
Magee pointed to a raised concrete barrier as long as a football field that blocks turns at his driveway. When big rigs now deliver furniture, they obstruct traffic — and sometimes break the law — in their attempts to turn in.

Beer and soda distributors have stopped delivering to the Food Mill because turns are so tight, said Mike Reza, a Food Mill manager, who shakes his head at the intersection redesign.
“Some things you do on paper don’t work out in actual life,” Reza said of the new traffic restrictions.

“People can find us, but it’s dangerous to get out,” said Sue Dee Shenk, executive director of Napa Valley Community Housing at Five Financial Plaza.

Motorists can no longer turn north onto Soscol from Financial Plaza’s main exit, forcing many to use a formerly ignored exit behind Westamerica bank or make U-turns on Soscol, she said.

Cars making U turns at rush hour back up traffic, Shenk said. “There’s honking at them all the time. It’s a dangerous thing to do,” she said.

“I have to do things in a kind of backwards order,” said Lisa Haro, who was accustomed to visiting the Bank of America at Trancas/Soscol, then driving over to Silverado Plaza to shop.

Getting across Soscol is now so difficult she visits the businesses at Silverado Plaza first and sometimes skips Bank of America, preferring to use the bank’s downtown branch.

“It doesn’t make any sense,” Haro said of the redesign. “The logic behind it, I just don’t get it.”

“All my customers are complaining,” said Terri Fahey, a clerk at Longs Drugs in Silverado Plaza. “They want to know what the heck people were thinking.”

At rush hour, vehicles stack up trying to exit Silverado Plaza onto Soscol northbound. Other motorists are using the service alley behind Silverado Plaza as a shortcut, creating conflicts with delivery trucks, said Longs manager Luis Rodrigues. “It’s a very dangerous situation,” he said.

What were they thinking?

According to Farid Javandel, the city’s traffic engineer, the changes at Trancas/Soscol are identical to turn restrictions at other high-volume intersections around town.

The new medians are similar to those at Trancas/Jefferson and Lincoln/Soscol, where businesses have fewer points of entry/egress, but traffic flow and safety are improved, he said.

These improvements were long overdue at Trancas/Soscol, where nearly 20,000 vehicles a day on Soscol meet more than 20,000 vehicles daily on Trancas, he said.

There were 29 collisions at Trancas/Soscol in 2004 and 2005, a high percentage of them head-on or broadside, Javandel said. He predicts that the new medians will lower the accident rate.

“People go, ‘I can’t get there,’” said Larry Pollard, the city’s assistant public works director, of motorist complaints. “Well, yes you can if you take a deep breath.”

“It’s a matter of getting used to things,” Javandel said. “If there is someone who drove into town for the first time, they’d navigate this without a second thought.”

Motorists squawked when median controls were installed at Trancas/Jefferson years ago, Pollard said. “Now people don’t bat an eye,” he said.

Mayor Jill Techel said she understood the public’s shock. “I think we’ve frustrated a lot of people. Change is like that,” she said.

The safety benefit makes these changes worthwhile, but the city could have done a better job informing the public and merchants of what was about to occur, Techel said.

Barry Martin, the city’s public outreach coordinator, said he met with businesses in Silverado and Financial plazas in 2003 to explain the changes, but failed to talk to the businesses in the Custom House complex.

The city accepts responsibility for creating a problem for trucks entering Custom House, Javandel said. The Custom House sign will be moved and the center’s entry altered at city expense to correct the situation, he said.

Some customers are trying to circumvent the median at Custom House by making illegal maneuvers around it, both entering and exiting the center. “We flip around to get out of here,” an employee said.

The proper way for eastbound Trancas traffic to enter Custom House is by making a U turn at Big Ranch, Javandel said. Exiting vehicles that want to go eastbound need to turn westbound, then make a U turn from the two-way center lane of Trancas or nearest intersection, he said.

Dennis Pedisich, president of Napa Community Bank, said the redesigned intersection was an overall plus for his bank. Some 10,000 northbound Soscol vehicles now arrive at Trancas directly opposite his building.

“It’s been an education process for our customers,” Pedisich said. To take the sting out of the traffic changes, the bank held weekly contests for customers who made a U turn to get there. Winners received a free lunch for two.

Frustrated motorists need to remember that U turns are legal at intersections unless they are expressly prohibited, Javandel said. Southbound Soscol vehicles can hang a U at the rear entrance to Silverado Plaza, he said.

Magee said motorists will eventually come to terms with the new turn restrictions. “I’m sure it will eventually work out, but it’s caused a headache for a lot of people,” he said. “People want to go where they want to go.”

Click the blue dots for information
Please install Flash and turn on Javascript.


14 comment(s)

Dirty Napkin wrote on Jul 1, 2007 7:22 AM:

" That is the dumbest thing this city ever did! Besides not having the ground tested before building a parking garage on it. Who is at the controls anymore?? "

The Archipelago of Ricochet Islands wrote on Jul 1, 2007 9:14 AM:

" The Archipelago of Ricochet Islands and the failed attempt at traffic control is typical of Napa over the past (at least) decade. I have spoken with dozens of business owners who have said Napa is the hardest place with which to conduct business and poor traffic design adds insult to injury. The medians are so poorly designed that many drivers are either driven toward the adjoining lane to navigate around them or have hit the median (proof is in the dozens of areas where broken cement can be seen). The you’ll-get-over-it attitude of the City Engineer seems a bit arrogant. Businesses have suffered all over Napa from poor traffic design. Illegal u-turns, redirected traffic down residential streets or customers altogether choosing not to do business with those so hard to access have been the results. The thousand of gallons of gas burned in waiting for horribly managed traffic lights and navigating the maze is another negative. One of the busiest streets(?) now is the alley behind Silverado Plaza (good job). One very prominent businessman told me that it is easier to do business with Daniel Ortega of communist Nicaragua than with Napa officials and their failed plans. "

Sandra wrote on Jul 1, 2007 9:19 AM:

" I work in the Silverado Plaza. Since the street changes there is too much traffic in the alley. With this new and dangerous situation created by the street changes, the register then informs people that it is OK to use the alley. How is this going to help this situation??? Could someone explain how encouraging more traffic in this alley to get around the street changes is going to make this better? The city messed up, plain and simple. Such extensive street barriers are not needed at this intersection. The barriers on Jefferson St. make more sense, and allow easy acess to the shopping centers. These barriers make no sense and create more danger, and do not allow easy access anywhere. "

Steph wrote on Jul 1, 2007 9:48 AM:

" What if the west driveway entry from Trancas into Financial Plaza was turned into a enter AND exit? I'd use that to get back onto Trancas east-bound and to get into Silverado Plaza. Would that work? "

Everyday wrote on Jul 1, 2007 12:02 PM:

" Somebody ends up plowing into those concrete dividers northbound Soscol in the left turn lane. It makes it look like to lanes are starting to turn left on Trancas. Unfortunately the far left one is only for the bank and a concrete barrier there become unavoidable if you're doing 30 or even 20 mph and don't see it until too late. As a taxi driver, I had to pick up a very nice man who lives at the veterans home because he suffered two blown tires running over the turn median...Did they just have too much concrete and tried to get creative? Painted lines marking that as a turn lane into the bank would be safer and just as efficient. "

You drive it wrote on Jul 1, 2007 12:39 PM:

" What a mess!! "Change is like that" is a sorry answer too.The planner and the mayor should have to try and navigate this area twice a day!! "

omg wrote on Jul 1, 2007 12:59 PM:

" It's not the "change" that is frustrating people! It's the "ridiculous change"! Change is good if it's thought out and works! But creating worse driving conditions that creates more traffic jams and illegal turns...iyiyi. Someone higher up needs to look into the people designing these roads. I'm only a "domestic engineer" (aka housewife) but I think I could have come up with a better design! "

John wrote on Jul 1, 2007 2:59 PM:

" I don't see what everyone is complaining about, i think its great and not difficult to navigate, the traffic in that area has been cut down significantly. There are so many different ways to exit and enter all these areas, people should stop complaining its a great design "

Get Over It wrote on Jul 1, 2007 4:51 PM:

" I agree, it's not that much of a problem. As stated, if you were navigating it for the first time, you would think nothing of it. Suddenly everyone is a traffic engineer and an expert. I've never seen a town where every little change, from the Chiefs Market to to some new traffic flows is greeted with such whining. Get Over it!! "

La Homa Drive Resident wrote on Jul 1, 2007 7:39 PM:

" I've driven these section of roads for over 12 years. This latest round of assinine projects should serve as an eye-opener to the continued saga of bumpkins running Napa government. What was a slighlty risky left turn from La Homa to Soscol (at peak traffic) is now ridiculously dangerous at all times. Saturday it took 9 mins for me to make that turn. To go south after shopping at Nob Hill takes much longer due to the 10-12 cars stacked up to turn left onto the extension. Or, my alternative is a dangerous left turn from the Cetner onto Soscol where I can make a left onto the glorious extension. To turn right onto Soscol from La Homa, I now have the extra thrill of risking my myself against the cars barreling around the curved extension. There's more! Factor in the extra risk from the apt complex; they're down to only one driveway to turn left onto Soscol, AND the cars turning left from the old Soscol onto the new! And this was for accidents that already had stop lights nowhere near where anyone is NOW having trouble? How about enforcement? Oh yeah, enforcing lights? Not here... I moved here from Silicon Valley and that's some real traffic...but it's from cars, not the worst traffic flow designs that continue to plague Napa. This isn't the only one. Look how the traffic stacks up from River Park to turn left onto Imola. Solution? Fire everyone involved in this project, including every government official that think it's okay to issue patronizingly ignorant statments. This project doesn't work. It hurts many businesses, it will hurt innocent drivers. It's not going to get better with time, just less people will bother. They will go elsewhere! If anyone with the proper knowledge had taken the time to study the impact to the businesses and drivers, they would have known. So they obviously DIDN'T do their jobs. To this end I say, Napa, you suck. I am moving away from here as soon as possible. So should you. "

Concerned Resident wrote on Jul 1, 2007 7:45 PM:

" Napa is run by bumbling "officials" who have never experienced how to grow a city like Napa. Our government should come from places like Palo Alto, and other such Peninsular Governments who know how to grow cities with the proper expertise. All of them should be fired. This project is a disaster. Business have and will continue to be hurt and so will people. Left turns have increased exponentially for the surrounding residents and if they don't wish to risk themselves, they now have to drive backwards to get around the corner. Idiots all of them. Just look at the faces of government and you will find the problem. "

wingmate wrote on Jul 1, 2007 11:28 PM:

" Having already written one letter to the editor about my frustrations brought on by this new intersection configuration, I would like to add my voice to these complaints about the redesign of the Soscal/Trancas/Big Ranch Road confluence but with the emphasis of the flow into and out of Big Ranch Road. There are now two lanes that can go straight south onto Soscal from Big Ranch Road and one is a shared right hand turn lane. If there is more than one car planning to go straight, cars desiring to turn right onto Trancas now have to wait for the lights to cycle through to green. For those wanting to turn north onto Big Ranch Road from westbound Trancas, there is no longer any right hand turn lane and so they have to wait (wasting gas and polluting the atmosphere) for the light to turn green. Those who need to turn left from eastbound Trancas must dodge the cement island, which shows the marks of many who haven't successfully done that. And all of this has significantly increased the traffic on Big Ranch Road with cars and trucks using it as a more convenient route to transition from the Silverado Trail to Soscal than before this redesign. I feel that this intersection configuration has resulted in greater inconvenience and longer wait times than existed before for those of us who live off of Big Ranch Road. "

High speed wrote on Jul 1, 2007 11:55 PM:

" Cars now go belting north along Soscol towards Trancas at high speed. The narrowing of the lanes previously slowed traffic down. Near the Silverado alley is also a bus-stop, with the bus poking out into the driving lane. The other day, a truck parked in the lane caused a narrow miss when two lanes suddenly became one, at high speed. There are way too many exits and entrances in that whole general intersection area to make this design work efficiently. I also pity the residences on either side, which now have a raceway running through them. What was it all for anyway? "

Joe wrote on Jul 6, 2007 5:27 PM:

" I've used the alley behind silverado plaza for a long time as a shortcut. I hate those speed bumps they have back there though. "

Comment Guidelines
The goal of the story comments section at NapaValleyRegister.com is to have an open, thought-provoking, civil community forum for all issues.
What gets your comment posted?
• Staying on topic
• Keeping your comment to 300 words or less
• Avoiding name-calling
• Addressing your comments to the message rather than the messenger
What gets your comment deleted?
• Personal attacks
• Derogatory remarks
• Name-calling of any sort
• Going off-topic
• Hate speech
• Racially-insensitive comments
• Implying guilt of a subject in a crime story before there is a court verdict
• Posting e-mail addresses
• Posting comments of a commercial nature
• POSTING WITH ALL CAPITAL LETTERS
• Linking multiple comments together with "to be continued..." to get around the 300 word limit.
The fine print
- Comments are either approved or denied. We do not edit comments.
- You are welcome to modify and resubmit a denied comment.
- Comments may take several hours to be posted.
- Comments posted are those of the writer, and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of NapaValleyRegister.com, its employees or its parent company.
- Do you have information on a story? Please go to our virtual newsroom to send us a news tip.
- If you feel a posted comment has violated our guidelines, please contact online@napanews.com or add a comment indicating you have an issue and our moderators will review the comment in question.
Search:
Web Search Powered
By Yahoo! Search
Napa Valley Register on Facebook
Copyright © 2009 Napa Valley Publishing, a member of Lee Enterprises, Inc.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy