NVR Logo
Raids of illegal immigrants have their U.S.-born children fearing
Thursday, April 05, 2007
Save and Share Share
WASHINGTON — As the government’s crackdown on illegal immigrant workers has intensified in recent months, so have the consequences for a large group of U.S. citizens: American-born children of illegal immigrants.

Numbering at least 3.1 million, according to an analysis by the Urban Institute and the Pew Hispanic Center, such children range from teenagers steeped in iTunes and MySpace to toddlers just learning their ABCs.
Until recently, their parents’ illegal status had limited impact on these children’s lives, because, although every year hundreds of thousands of illegal immigrants are detained attempting to cross the U.S. border, once they make it in, they are rarely caught.

But the increase in raids against companies employing illegal workers is beginning to change that.
In December, immigration agents descended on six meat-processing plants belonging to Swift & Co. and arrested 1,297 illegal workers. At one plant, in Worthington, Minn., the workers had at least 360 U.S.-born children and probably many more, according to a local pastor who raised money for them.

Similarly, of about 360 workers arrested during a raid of the Michael Bianco Inc. manufacturing plant in New Bedford, Mass., last month, about 110 were the sole caregivers for one or more children in the United States, according to federal and state authorities.
Last Thursday, Jessica Guncay, a chubby-cheeked fifth-grader, joined the ranks of children who have been separated from a parent when immigration agents raided a Dixie Printing and Packaging Corp. plant in Baltimore where her parents were working under false Social Security numbers.

During an interview in her Baltimore home the next day, Jessica, 10, said that although she had known her Ecuadoran parents were in the country illegally, she never imagined they would be arrested.

“I feel sick inside,” she mumbled, staring at her white sneakers.

Her mother, Ana Tapia, 40, who sat next to Jessica on the family’s brown velvet couch, pulled her daughter in for a tearful hug.

Though Jessica’s father, Jury Guncay, 45, remains in custody,Tapia was released several hours after the raid so Jessica would not be left without anyone to care for her. But the black monitoring bracelet around Tapia’s ankle testified to the limited nature of that reprieve: She must remain under partial house arrest until her case comes up in immigration court.

Her chances of winnBy N.C. AIZENMAN

Washington Post

WASHINGTON — As the government’s crackdown on illegal immigrant workers has intensified in recent months, so have the consequences for a large group of U.S. citizens: American-born children of illegal immigrants.

Numbering at least 3.1 million, according to an analysis by the Urban Institute and the Pew Hispanic Center, such children range from teenagers steeped in iTunes and MySpace to toddlers just learning their ABCs.

Until recently, their parents’ illegal status had limited impact on these children’s lives, because, although every year hundreds of thousands of illegal immigrants are detained attempting to cross the U.S. border, once they make it in, they are rarely caught.

But the increase in raids against companies employing illegal workers is beginning to change that.

In December, immigration agents descended on six meat-processing plants belonging to Swift & Co. and arrested 1,297 illegal workers. At one plant, in Worthington, Minn., the workers had at least 360 U.S.-born children and probably many more, according to a local pastor who raised money for them.

Similarly, of about 360 workers arrested during a raid of the Michael Bianco Inc. manufacturing plant in New Bedford, Mass., last month, about 110 were the sole caregivers for one or more children in the United States, according to federal and state authorities.

Last Thursday, Jessica Guncay, a chubby-cheeked fifth-grader, joined the ranks of children who have been separated from a parent when immigration agents raided a Dixie Printing and Packaging Corp. plant in Baltimore where her parents were working under false Social Security numbers.

During an interview in her Baltimore home the next day, Jessica, 10, said that although she had known her Ecuadoran parents were in the country illegally, she never imagined they would be arrested.

“I feel sick inside,” she mumbled, staring at her white sneakers.

Her mother, Ana Tapia, 40, who sat next to Jessica on the family’s brown velvet couch, pulled her daughter in for a tearful hug.

Though Jessica’s father, Jury Guncay, 45, remains in custody,Tapia was released several hours after the raid so Jessica would not be left without anyone to care for her. But the black monitoring bracelet around Tapia’s ankle testified to the limited nature of that reprieve: She must remain under partial house arrest until her case comes up in immigration court.

Her chances of winning a stay of deportation appear slim. Under rules adopted by Congress in 1996, a judge cannot allow illegal immigrants to remain in the United States merely because they have a child who is a U.S. citizen. Instead, parents must prove that if they were deported the child would suffer “exceptional and extremely unusual hardship” — a standard often interpreted to apply to serious medical cases only.

And so Tapia is wrestling with a dilemma that has become increasingly common for illegal immigrant parents: leave her child to be raised by relatives in the United States or take her along to an unfamiliar country offering far fewer opportunities.

In Maryland, she noted, she and her husband earned $11.25 an hour and were able to provide Jessica with a computer, a modest but tidy brick house and free access to an elementary school she loves.

Before leaving Ecuador 14 years ago, they could barely afford to sublet a single room on Guncay’s wages as a metalworker. Now Tapia worries he will no longer qualify for even that job because Ecuadoran factory managers prefer younger workers.

“I don’t even know how my husband and I are going to survive there, let alone support Jessica,” Tapia said in Spanish.

Mark Krikorian, executive director of the Center for Immigration Studies, which seeks to limit immigration, said he has sympathy for children in Jessica’s situation — but no more so than for any other child victimized by a parent’s mistakes.

“Kids often pay for the bad decisions of their parents. If you do something wrong that sends you to jail, well, your kids suffer for that. If you are careless with your mortgage and lose your house, your kids suffer along with you,” he said. The parents “knew what they were doing when they had kids here, knowing that they were still illegal immigrants.”

Krikorian applauded the new efforts against employers of illegal workers as a welcome departure from years of lax enforcement of immigration laws within U.S. territory.

In fiscal 2004, for instance, the government deported only about 51,000 immigrants who had been in the United States for more than a year, accounting for just 3 percent of the number of immigrants expelled and less than 1 percent of the nation’s estimated 12 million illegal immigrants.

Krikorian said lawmakers would only make matters worse by granting judges more discretion to allow those now being arrested to remain in the United States if they have U.S. citizen children, as proposed in a bill recently introduced by Rep. Jose E. Serrano, D-N.Y.

“You’d be making having a kid an automatic get-out-of-jail-free card,” Krikorian said. “You’d basically be saying that every illegal alien gets to stay permanently just because they had a kid once they crossed the border.” ing a stay of deportation appear slim. Under rules adopted by Congress in 1996, a judge cannot allow illegal immigrants to remain in the United States merely because they have a child who is a U.S. citizen. Instead, parents must prove that if they were deported the child would suffer “exceptional and extremely unusual hardship” — a standard often interpreted to apply to serious medical cases only.

And so Tapia is wrestling with a dilemma that has become increasingly common for illegal immigrant parents: leave her child to be raised by relatives in the United States or take her along to an unfamiliar country offering far fewer opportunities.

In Maryland, she noted, she and her husband earned $11.25 an hour and were able to provide Jessica with a computer, a modest but tidy brick house and free access to an elementary school she loves.

Before leaving Ecuador 14 years ago, they could barely afford to sublet a single room on Guncay’s wages as a metalworker. Now Tapia worries he will no longer qualify for even that job because Ecuadoran factory managers prefer younger workers.

“I don’t even know how my husband and I are going to survive there, let alone support Jessica,” Tapia said in Spanish.

Mark Krikorian, executive director of the Center for Immigration Studies, which seeks to limit immigration, said he has sympathy for children in Jessica’s situation — but no more so than for any other child victimized by a parent’s mistakes.

“Kids often pay for the bad decisions of their parents. If you do something wrong that sends you to jail, well, your kids suffer for that. If you are careless with your mortgage and lose your house, your kids suffer along with you,” he said. The parents “knew what they were doing when they had kids here, knowing that they were still illegal immigrants.”

Krikorian applauded the new efforts against employers of illegal workers as a welcome departure from years of lax enforcement of immigration laws within U.S. territory.

In fiscal 2004, for instance, the government deported only about 51,000 immigrants who had been in the United States for more than a year, accounting for just 3 percent of the number of immigrants expelled and less than 1 percent of the nation’s estimated 12 million illegal immigrants.

Krikorian said lawmakers would only make matters worse by granting judges more discretion to allow those now being arrested to remain in the United States if they have U.S. citizen children, as proposed in a bill recently introduced by Rep. Jose E. Serrano, D-N.Y.

“You’d be making having a kid an automatic get-out-of-jail-free card,” Krikorian said. “You’d basically be saying that every illegal alien gets to stay permanently just because they had a kid once they crossed the border.”
5 comment(s)

No Illegals.. wrote on Apr 5, 2007 11:49 AM:

" Perhaps we shouldn't enforce the laws for all other crimes because it would break up familes. Don't send a thief to jail, it will break the children's heart. Don't send rapists to jail, their parents will be sad. The point is that these people should not be here and their children should not be citizens just because they were born in this country. You could never go into Mexico and demand the same treatments that illegal aliens get in this country. In my area wages for carpenters have gone from $18-25 an hour 10 years ago to less than $8 an hour today. Why is that? Illegals. Sure they're "Doing the jobs Americans don't want to do" but that's because they pushed the wages down so far that it's not financially possible for americans to do the work. And let's not forget that the vast majority of these workers aren't paying any taxes but are using all tax payer services for them and their children. We're destroying the middle class of this country. We don't have to be the charity to the world, we need to look out for our own tax paying citizens first. "

center field wrote on Apr 5, 2007 11:43 PM:

" These peope fully understand the risks they are taking with their own childrens welfare when they chose to have a child that will have a different nationality than their own. They know that they are at risk of deportation, and consequently their chilren being taken by child services. Most of these people are not even attempting to become citizens of the United States, which is what they would be doing if they really cared about the welfare of their children. They cry when it happens to them. They want us to care when they didn't care enough about their children to prevent this from being a problem in the first place. I think we should have a mandate that decrees al these children accompany their parents on the journey back to Mexico. Problem solved. It would also cause older children of illegal aliens to pressure their parents into changing their status, because those kids don't want to go live in Mexico. "

non-resident concerned about citizen ignorance. wrote on Apr 6, 2007 12:32 AM:

" I am wondering if “center field” understands that there is a process to legalize while you are in the country and that the minimum years required before applying is ten years. And that after you apply you have to wait an uncertain time to get your date in court. If the court allows you to stay you become a permanent resident. After five years you can apply to be a citizen. So it takes about 15 years to become a "legalized" individual. Its not that immigrants don't want to become citizens, the matter concerns time. If we are talking about sending children, who were born here, to their parents’ country of origin, perhaps immigrants will consider this but only after you have unearthed your ancestor's remains and send those back to where ever it is them came from. "

non-resident still concerned wrote on Apr 6, 2007 12:34 AM:

" "No Illegals" - I know no one has in their minds to become housekeepers, janitors, grape pickers/planters. Maybe you are just not working hard enough. How much do you think jornaleros (day laborers) are charging for their work? Ask. I've done my research and it turns out about $10 an hour, at least. Your boss is stingy. Immigrants don't have to do with your $8/hr wage. One more thing. You are getting old, are you ready for retirement? These immigrants are paying social security for you and others. It’s somewhat funny that the IRS developed the Individual Tax Payer Income Number (ITIN) for those with legal or illegal status. $90 billion dollars in un-returnable taxes are paid by the undocumented workers. Go ahead do your own research on ITIN, on tax contributions, on the demographics for the next 30 years regarding age and ethnicity. Latinos are vital and Latin American countries are the source of labor for your retirement. Its a pay-as-you- go system for social security. Brush up on your counterarguments. "

gerrilyn wrote on Apr 10, 2007 7:42 AM:

" I think that when illegal immigrants have children in the US, and they get deported,their children should go with them until they (children) are old enough to come back to the Us. That way the children will not suffer when the parents get deported and the US, will not have to send this children to foster homes. "

Comment Guidelines
The goal of the story comments section at NapaValleyRegister.com is to have an open, thought-provoking, civil community forum for all issues.
What gets your comment posted?
• Staying on topic
• Keeping your comment to 300 words or less
• Avoiding name-calling
• Addressing your comments to the message rather than the messenger
What gets your comment deleted?
• Personal attacks
• Derogatory remarks
• Name-calling of any sort
• Going off-topic
• Hate speech
• Racially-insensitive comments
• Implying guilt of a subject in a crime story before there is a court verdict
• Posting e-mail addresses
• Posting comments of a commercial nature
• POSTING WITH ALL CAPITAL LETTERS
• Linking multiple comments together with "to be continued..." to get around the 300 word limit.
The fine print
- Comments are either approved or denied. We do not edit comments.
- You are welcome to modify and resubmit a denied comment.
- Comments may take several hours to be posted.
- Comments posted are those of the writer, and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of NapaValleyRegister.com, its employees or its parent company.
- Do you have information on a story? Please go to our virtual newsroom to send us a news tip.
- If you feel a posted comment has violated our guidelines, please contact online@napanews.com or add a comment indicating you have an issue and our moderators will review the comment in question.
Search:
Web Search Powered
By Yahoo! Search
Napa Valley Register on Facebook
Copyright © 2009 Napa Valley Publishing, a member of Lee Enterprises, Inc.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy