NVR Logo
Mourners gathered near Vintage High to celebrate slain 19-year-old's life
Linda Smernes holds a candle in memory of her son, Robert Ratto during a candlelight vigil with friends and family at Solomon Park, Wednesday. Smernes's son, Anthony, and daughter, Renee McCurdy, stand close. Lianne Milton/Register | Buy photos
Thursday, September 07, 2006
Save and Share Share
A 16-year-old Napa boy has been charged with murder in Tuesday's fatal shooting of Robert Ratto, 19, of Napa. Police have not released the name of the suspect -- being held in Napa County Juvenile Hall -- because he is minor.

Ratto, a 2006 graduate of Vintage High, was pronounced dead when paramedics responded to a report of a shooting around 5:30 p.m. Tuesday at an apartment complex in the 300 block of Collier Boulevard.
He, along with the suspect and another 16-year-old boy, was sitting in a parked car in the apartment complex parking lot, Napa Police Cmdr. Steve Potter said.

Ratto was sitting in the passenger seat, one of the boys was in the driver's seat and the other in the back seat. The gun went off and one bullet struck Ratto in the torso, Potter said. The two boys carried Ratto to an apartment in the complex, where paramedics found him mortally wounded.
"The boys were friends," Potter said. "When officers first arrived they told them there had been a confrontation in the parking lot and the victim was shot. After talking to the boys, it was learned there had been no confrontation."

Witnesses and neighbors also said they did not hear or seeing anything relating to a fight.
Ratto's mother, Linda Smernes, remembers her son as "exceptional, very social with a lot of friends. He worked very hard to graduate last June and was very proud of himself. It was difficult for him," she said. "He was a hard worker. He would never just ask for money. He would do chores to earn it. He was just the sweetest kid with a gentle spirit. After he graduated he was looking forward to going to a training program to learn a trade. And now he's gone."

Potter said at this time investigators do not know where the teens got the gun, which detectives have recovered. The suspect was taken to the police station from the scene, interviewed and arrested.

Although Potter declined to discuss details of the interview, he said detectives gathered enough information to charge the youth with homicide.

Potter said the three boys were just hanging out together before the shooting happened. "There is no indication that there was any trouble among them prior to the shooting."

The homicide does not appear to be drug or gang related, Potter said.

In addition to the homicide charge, the suspect is also being held on charges of possession of a controlled substance and possession of a controlled substance for sale.

About 120 friends, teachers and family members met at Solomon park near Vintage High School Wednesday evening for a candlelight vigil. Mourners of all ages formed a grief circle, celebrating Ratto's spirit and sense of humor. The crowd shared stories of Ratto's life and his impact on them. Longtime friend Joseph Trefry, 21, lamented not being more of a mentor to Ratto. One teacher demonstrated Ratto's signature move, "the dance." As the sun went down and the moon rose, the mourners, several wearing T-shirts bearing Ratto's picture, with "In loving memory" and "Rob Rat" printed on the shirt, lit candles and hugged their loved ones.

Ratto was born in Berkeley and came to Napa in 1995.

In addition to his mother, Ratto is survived by his sister, Renae McCurdy of Napa, and brothers Anthony Smernes of Vallejo and Daniel Smernes of Eugene, Ore.
14 comment(s)

1LoveRob wrote on Sep 7, 2006 2:39 AM:

" If the boy is charged with murder this would make it intentional whereas manslaughter would be accidental. But what confuses me is they say murder yet it says "the gun went off" making it seem like an accident. So which is it? "

Sara wrote on Sep 7, 2006 7:30 AM:

" I knew both of thsese kids and it is a shame that it happened. But the person who shot Rob did not do it on purpose. It was a complete accident. You people in the register need to stop treating it like it was on purpse that he got shot. It was not gang or drug related so get it right. YO7u know if it was my son who was being charged with anything I wouldn't publish it. The shooter shot and killed one of his best friends and I think he will never forger what happened but you people are making it hard for anybody to forget anything. There is alos flowers and candle's and a poster to sign at the place that ROB was killed why can't you mentition that? I think it is just wrong that you can't add others things like they were friends or the flowers and everything on Collier!!!! HE should not be charged with murder it should be accidental homicide. They need to fix it. Rob would not want his freind going to prison for the rest of his life. REST IN PEACE ROB... "

me wrote on Sep 7, 2006 7:46 AM:

" felony murder if a felony was being committed at the time of the accidental shooting; i.e. a crime such as selling drugs... "

Sara wrote on Sep 7, 2006 8:39 AM:

" They werent selling drugs they were very good friends "

God is in control Trust in him wrote on Sep 7, 2006 11:01 AM:

" FROM ALL I READ IN THE REGISTER IT SEEMS AS IF IT WERE ACCIDENTAL I THINK THAT THE BOY BEING CHARGE IS GOING THROUGH SUCH A HARD TIME AND NEEDS SOME COUNSOLING AND EMOTIONAL HELP INSTEAD YOU ARE TREATTING HIM AS A MURDERER "

Rational wrote on Sep 7, 2006 11:29 AM:

" Take the emotions out of it for a moment: Someone had a gun. That person had his finger on the trigger of that gun, and it was pointed at the victim. The person pulled the trigger, and the bullet hit the victim. The victim died. It is a crime to kill someone. The shooter should be punished, not sympathized with. The sentiment behind it does not matter except in degrees of criminality. If you hold a gun in your hand, be prepared to answer for anything that may result. "

That Person Walking By wrote on Sep 7, 2006 11:57 AM:

" I didnt ever meet Robert, I have never met any of his friends. But I do know who the boys mother is, MRS. Linda, she is a loving and carryiong woman, so sweet and always has a smile across her face. Right know we need to comfort this wonderful family of Roberts. From these other comments I can already tell Robert was a great person as well. But then again thats no suprise if you know his mother. REST IN PEACE ROBERT "

Gatuso wrote on Sep 7, 2006 2:53 PM:

" First of all why did robert go inside the car when he knew his firend had gun on him, he should have known better and stayed away from him. 16yr old+gun= Danger "

muchlove wrote on Sep 7, 2006 3:32 PM:

" rob died to early and it was far from his fault. it was so far from drug related thats crazy to even mention it "

CommonSense Stan wrote on Sep 7, 2006 8:29 PM:

" The kid that shot him was charged with possesion of a controlled substance and possesion to sell controlled substance.If you play with fire you get burned.Check out some of his "friends". People who have had contact with the victim paint him in a less forgiving light then the victim's family(which is understandable). I'm not trying to smear him at this difficult time for his family.All I'm saying is, parents, know who your children are with and what they are up to.He was with a criminal element and wound up paying with his life.Be realistic about your children for the sake of others around them. "

jacob wrote on Sep 7, 2006 9:17 PM:

" they are both my freinds, im the same age as rob. they were really good freinds, i know because of 1's accidents u must be responsible and be a man to pay 4 ur dues. i got texts phone calls 2 come and comfort freinds while at work. i know at my age 2 lose freinds its hard, i came here 4rm the sonoma county area and my best freind since elementry got shot, same ordeal an accident. but you know some people dont know how 2 handle a gun. it is a serious crime i wont debate that but at the same time a person of my freinds age it will be 1 of the hardest things 2 forgive urself. im sorry 4 the mother i ask 4 u or any 1 reading this 2 show sympathy on both sides. "will see u again 1DAY rob". R.I.P "

Boone wrote on Sep 9, 2006 1:09 PM:

" Damn hella crazy. I visited Napa (where I'm originally from) this summer and met him; and kicked it with him a couple of times. Crazyness, I'll miss him. "

been there, done that wrote on Sep 13, 2006 1:44 PM:

" I agree with CommonSense Stan; the "victim" was probably up to no good "

Curious wrote on Sep 21, 2006 4:15 PM:

" This may have been an tragic accident and I am sorry for the families. I do want to say one thing though. If there was not drug dealing going on then why did the 16 year old have drugs on him and why did they have a gun with them in the first place. Something was going on in my eyes. I know I am not going to get in the car with my best friend while they are playing with a gun. Somone had said on here that they were best friends and the 16 year old can not be charged for murder. Just because they were friends and it was an accident doesnt mean the law goes away. "

Comment guidelines
All comments will be screened and may take several hours to be posted.
• Keep comments clear, concise and focused on the topic in the story.
• Comments exceeding 300 words will not be posted.
• Refrain from personal attacks, degrading comments or remarks that do not add to a constructive dialogue.
• Comments implying suspects in crime-related stories are guilty before they have been proven so in a court of law will be deleted.
• Do not post e-mail addresses or links except for pages on Napavalleyregister.com or government Web sites.
• Comments will not be edited - they will be approved or declined.
• Comments may be used in the print edition of the newspaper.
• If you feel a posted comment has violated our guidelines, please contact dross@napanews.com or bkennedy@napanews.com
For further information on the comment guidelines, click here.
Search:
Advanced searchWeb Search Powered By Yahoo! Search
Copyright © 2009 Napa Valley Publishing, a member of Lee Enterprises, Inc.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy